When Real Snipers Fire
Published April 08, 2008
Suzanne Smalley asked in a Newsweek article if it is possible that Hillary Clinton “really thought she risked her life disembarking from a plane in Bosnia and running for cover under sniper fire. Hillary has been telling the story of her visit to Bosnia in 1996 for many years, gradually adding embellishment and changing details. Perhaps she may have actually come to believe it.”
All those who have experienced war know that it is impossible to forget the difference between a quiet day and a day when bullets are flying around.
During the war in Bosnia, my city, Gorazde, was under siege. Snipers fired from the surrounding hills at anything that was moving.
I was thirteen in 1992, but I can still vividly remember the feeling when snipers fired around me.
I would freeze and shake in fear. My heart would beat incredibly fast and the adrenaline rush would be unbelievable. Terrified and confused, I would run for cover. Sometimes I would just drop on the ground and hope and pray to survive.
Bullets and bombs abruptly ended my childhood. I couldn’t play children’s games any more. I had to think about survival. Moments like these forced me to grow up overnight.
I can still hear in my head the sound of bullets piercing through the air and (luckily in my case) hitting the walls around me.
This will stay clear in my mind forever, no matter how sleep-deprived or tired I get!
Hillary Clinton wrote in her book, Living History, about her 1996 trip to Bosnia and said that there were reports of gunfire but does not mention hearing or seeing it on her way to Tuzla.
In December 2007, she spoke about her visit and said that they “landed in one of those corkscrew landings and ran out because they said there might be sniper fire.”
On February 29, Hillary stated that the greeting ceremony “had to be moved inside because of sniper fire.”
On March 17, Clinton described the same trip yet again but this time said that she now remembered “landing under sniper fire. There was supposed to be some kind of a greeting ceremony at the airport, but instead we just ran with our heads down to get into the vehicles to get to our base.”
Only after videos showed her walking calmly off the plane and meeting a little Bosnian girl in a small ceremony on the airstrip, Hillary said that she “misspoke” about snipers.
“So I made a mistake. That happens. It proves I’m human, which, you know, for some people, is a revelation,” Hillary said, blaming tiredness for her “misspeaking.”
BBC writes that the word “misspoke” is a useful one in this context. It implies that “something which feels like a lie is really little more than a slip of the tongue.”
- When Real Snipers Fire
- Published: April 08, 2008
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Politics
- Filed Under: Politics: Elections and Candidates, Politics: International, Politics: U.S., Politics: War and Terrorism
- Writer: Savo Heleta
- Savo Heleta's BC Writer page
- Savo Heleta's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
You are absolutely and totally right about the experience of being the subject of hostile fire.
You never, ever forget it.
Ever.
And, unless you're a congenital liar, you won't "misspeak" about it, either.
Globalization has its fruits for democracy: had Mrs Clinton run in 1992 and misspoke similarly about a foreign venture into a country unknown to most of her electorate, maybe a few letters to the editors would have appeared but it would not have questioned her credibility. In 2008 you have a great chance that you have an eyewitness of any public event all over the world who can write in English and finds access to the internet. I have seen many comments in the blogosphere coming from Bosnia on this issue. I guess that the next American government as a global power will have to take into account the global public opinion more than every before. It may be better for the whole world.






Synthesized memory, or confabulation, is a well-documented psychological phenomenon. We've all done it. We tell a story - true or made-up - about something that happened to us, it gets a reaction, so the next time we tell it we embellish it, and so on down the road, adding more and more details until time and distance make it hard to distinguish fact from fiction even to ourselves.
I have a very clear memory of playing 'doctor' at age 6 with a girl in my class which, for very good anatomical reasons which I won't go into but which you can probably guess at, cannot possibly be true.
The difference in Hillary's case, which she should have known, is that every public appearance she's made since, oh, probably at least 1991, is well-documented and easily checkable.
Perhaps she really believed that her 'memory' of the Tuzla trip was real. Whatever the truth of the matter, I would expect her to be more careful when making public statements about her past from now on.