TV Review: Battlestar Galactica - "He That Believeth In Me" Gets the Fourth and Final Season Off To A Flying Start
Published April 07, 2008
Previously on Battlestar Galactica...
Cult favorite Sci Fi Channel series Battlestar Galactica returned on April 4 for its fourth and final season, and no amount of previously-on's can succinctly capture the massive scope of what transpired in season three. And considering that the final episode of season three ("Crossroads, Part II") originally aired on March 25, 2007, it's been a long, long time between fresh material (Sci Fi has been re-running season three in the past few weeks to allow viewers to play catch-up).
If you're one of those people who haven't yet climbed on board, BSG is epic series television in the best tradition of such fan favorites as The X-Files and Buffy the Vampire Slayer. What BSG has in common with those shows is a compelling story arc that's frequently illuminated by smaller scale character studies, a quality of writing that far exceeds much of what we're served up on prime-time network television, characters in whom we become fully invested, a community of committed fans who dissect and discuss every word and action, and a cast of actors who more than live up to the challenges of all the above. This series of reviews will assume that you have some familiarity with the story thus far, but if you need a refresher course, Sci Fi has a video up on the official BSG page that promises to get you up to speed in eight minutes.
One of the great things about this show is its unflinching look into the abyss of the human soul. Nearly annihilated, made extinct, gone from the universe, you'd think the human race might have had the sense to pull itself together and become a better people so that it might survive, right? But no such luck — instead we're just as venal, just as self-serving, just as opportunistic, just as dishonest, and just as downright bad as we've always been.
This is no white hat/black hat Star Trek universe. This is humanity as we know it, where good people sometimes do bad things and make terrible choices, often because they act out of their own self-interests or out of jealousy or out of any of the other things that make us all less than perfect. And just like in real life, they can turn on a dime and do the right thing in the face of overwhelming obstacles, act selflessly in the face of great personal danger, and sacrifice themselves to the greater good. Thanks to the writing and the overall excellence of the cast, it's impossible to watch this show and not end up feeling deeply about these characters and seeing a lot of ourselves and our current events reflected in the story arc.
- TV Review: Battlestar Galactica - "He That Believeth In Me" Gets the Fourth and Final Season Off To A Flying Start
- Published: April 07, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Video
- Filed Under: Video: Cult, Video: Drama, Video: SF, Video: Television
- Part of a feature: One Frak Mind: The Search for Earth
- Writer: Lisa McKay
- Lisa McKay's BC Writer page
- Lisa McKay's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments on this articleComments
Thanks, El B. I agree that the long relationship between Tigh and Adama is problematic, unless it turns out that the Cylons have existed longer than everyone thinks they have.
As it happens, this is the first season of BSG we're watching on television. We got hooked on the series via DVD and watched all three seasons that way (the last one in a marathon effort to be done by Friday's premiere -- they sure held those back till the last minute).
Agreed about the DVDs, we mowed through the 20 episodes over the two weeks and then watched Razor on Friday before the show, which we tivo'd to lose the commercials.
Did you notice that in the opening credits, they no longer state that the Cylons have a plan. Sounds more like the writers and between the start of production on the third and the fourth they changed what they were doing from the start.
Well, as Tory said "Maybe something's changed." I wonder if the four were triggered too soon?
Also, regarding Tigh being a Cylon, couldn't he have been replaced during the occupation on New Caprica when he was having his eye removed?
I don't know, just a thought.
"couldn't he have been replaced during the occupation on New Caprica when he was having his eye removed?"
Yes, but then he couldn't be one of the twelve.
Congratulations! This article has been selected for syndication to the Advance family of websites and to Boston.com, which will allow even more readers to enjoy it.
Add your comment, speak your mind
(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/75535)
Good write up. I didn't watch BSG until last January when I reviewed the HD set. Then slowly watched the DVDs with the Mrs. One a week for the next nine episodes is tough. I have been spoiled.
The writers certainly have a lot of explaining to do. I buy Tory, Anders, and Chief as Cyclons, but not so much with Tigh. Sure it would help explaining his hatred for Cylons and his alcoholism, but considering how long he has known Bill Adama, that one is going to be tough to sell. They would had to have had skin jobs back during the first war.
I hope we don't get too many single story episodes that run outside the grand scheme. That one with Helo and the bad doctor was terrible and appears to be forgotten.