Book Review: The Return Of The Sword Edited By Jason M Waltz -
Published April 05, 2008
The first real sword and sorcery stories I ever read were ones featuring Robert E. Howard's Conan the Barbarian. To be honest, I can't remember whether or not I read them in their book form first, or in the Marvel comic adaptations, but there wasn't much difference between the two when it came to literary merit. Conan was probably the ideal comic book character.
Robert E. Howard had created him as so much larger than life, and involved him in such spectacular adventures, the stories were ideally suited to the medium. The character was so much a figure of fantasy that it really didn't stand up to the scrutiny of live action and the movies were a great disappointment. They weren't even bad enough to be good. Even with Conan being played by the walking, talking cartoon character, Arnold, there was something about live action that robbed the character of his ability to be larger than life.
That's what makes the whole genre so much fun in the first place, as far I'm concerned. Nobody reads sword and sorcery for it's intellectual qualities after all, they read it for the escapism offered by the adventures. You read them for the very qualities that make it impossible for them to be filmed; the ability to fight 25 opponents at once; take on a multi-headed, multi-armed, poisonous creature without breaking a sweat; and getting the scantily clad wench in the end.
The scantily clad wench was of course one of the primary drawing cards for sword and sorcery's original demographic; adolescent males. Thankfully it turned out that women liked a good sword fight as much as men, and the genre started to gain a level of enlightenment when it came to the objectification of women; especially when women started creating their own characters and writing the stories. With women stepping out of the harem and on to the battle field the whole complexion of the genre changed.
With the stories no longer being geared strictly for the guys who lived in their basements playing Dungeons & Dragons, the plots became more imaginative, and the characters more complex, while still retaining the all the exciting bits that made them so attractive in the first place. You don't need to look any further than Flashing Sword Press' newly published anthology, The Return Of The Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz, for proof of just how far the genre's come since its comic book days.
Of course that's not to say there aren't stories in the collection that show a fond attachment for those roots, and feature lots of good old-fashioned sword play and witchcraft. Let's face it, there's always going to be a market and a need for that type of story, but here they're balanced with stories that delve a little deeper into the psyche of the warrior, and look beneath the armour, behind the shield, and under the helm.
- Book Review: The Return Of The Sword Edited By Jason M Waltz -
- Published: April 05, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Books
- Filed Under: Books: Action and Adventure, Books: Adventure, Books: Fantasy, Books: Literature and Fiction, Review
- Writer: Richard Marcus
- Richard Marcus's BC Writer page
- Richard Marcus's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
As one of the writers who has work appearing in this book, I offer a great big "thank you" for this review. I'm glad to see there are still those who appreciate that fiction can be fun escapism!
Very well-written review that has 'The Return of the Sword' on my to buy list.
I'm delighted to see both this anthology and its parent magazine getting the attention they deserve. As a reviewer, I see far too much "McFantasy" these days ... but I still love the old high fantasy when it's well done instead of just a rip-off. I'm glad there's a market for it.
Also worth mentioning is Ursula Vernon's novel _Black Dogs Part One: The House of Diamond_ from Sofawolf Press. It's like discovering the genre again for the first time: classic tropes done with fresh voice.
There are still some folks writing and buying this stuff, for readers who are willing to hunt around.
You know, it's a bit embarrassing for a writer of heroic fantasy to admit but this review made me giggle like a schoolgirl. Richard, I'm very glad you liked the story and thank you for the excellent review. What's even better for all of you that may run out and buy it: mine's not the best story in there. It's a great collection that is working hard to revitalize the genre, one gout of blood at a time.
For those who might be interested in some 'behind the scenes' type stuff regarding "The Battle of Raven Kill" you can visit my blog at the URL beside my name here.
This anthologies been on my list to buy for a while now, but I never seem to get farther than that--until tonight! Thanks for providing the impetus to get me purchasing. :)
Thanks for bringing this book to your readers' attention. It is one fun book, and not a boring page in it.
-- Steve
Thanks for bringing this book to your readers' attention. It is one fun book, and not a boring page in it.
-- Steve
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this book. Kind words are always helpful for those interested in buying a copy.
Thank you for writing this in-depth review of the new anthology. For those of us who love this genre, take a look at this publisher's magazine, Flashing Swords.
It's heart warming to know that others want to read great Sword & Sorcery stories!
- Dianne
Thank you for the kind words! I am another writer in the anthology, and I have to agree-- there are a lot of fun stories here.
An excellent review of an extrodinary book. Thanks.


Richard Marcus is a long-haired Canadian iconoclast who writes reviews and opines on the world as he sees it at 







The review gives a deep understanding of the writing and impact of the stories in this book. I'm not a fantasy fan, usually, but after reading Richard Marcus' take on "The Battle of Raven Kill," I know I must read this book.
Vivian