REVIEW

TV Review: Jane Austen Lite - Emma Is Masterpiece's Breezy Comedy of Manners

Written by Cynthia Greenwood
Published March 26, 2008

Since long before the 2007 box office release of The Jane Austen Book Club, the world has been open to new interpretations of Jane Austen’s satirical comedies. The great English novelist’s popularity on screen has probably never been greater.

Emma, Austen’s masterful comedy of manners, blends wit and irony supremely. Published in 1816, the novel is peopled by the gentry who reside in the kind of English village that Austen knew intimately.

PBS probably expects that airing adaptations of six works by Austen will attract a younger viewing audience to Masterpiece, the cozy Sunday evening staple once known as Masterpiece Theatre. The 39-year-old Gillian Anderson, the show’s new host, may help do the trick. She’s younger and less loquacious than Russell Baker and Alistair Cooke, her staid predecessors.

On Sunday, PBS reprised a 1996 TV production starring Kate Beckinsale as the self-assured Emma and Mark Strong as Mr. Knightley, her brother-in-law and confidant. Without dwelling on the frustrations that this truncated teleplay presents to lovers of Austen’s books, the show excels in several ways.

Beckinsale’s take on the intelligent, genteel Emma balances the literary heroine’s good-hearted nature with a plausible naiveté about the realities of social class. At 21, Emma has yet to come to terms with the responsibilities of her social position, so she never imagines that her desire to play matchmaker will hurt the ones she tries to help.

Beckinsale’s portrayal of Emma is not necessarily better than Gwyneth Paltrow’s rendering in the 1996 film, which was written and directed by Douglas McGrath. Beckinsale has a more youthful aspect, though. Compared to the film, she brings a different emphasis to scenes involving her rival Jane Fairfax and the opportunistic Frank Churchill. Beckinsale’s Emma passes for a young woman we can continue to like in spite of her social blundering.

The age gap between Emma and Mr. Knightley – she is 21 and he is around 37 - comes through clearly in the PBS production. Playing Mr. Knightley, Mark Strong’s righteous indignation is more pronounced than Jeremy Northam’s quieter rendering in the film. Strong’s Knightley seems harsher with Emma, in part because many of Knightley’s softer moments are slashed from the script. Therein lies the greatest flaw in Andrew Davies’ breezy teleplay, compared to McGrath’s elegant screenplay for the film. Key dialogue and scenes, vital to advancing Austen’s study of character, are missing from the TV version. The teleplay cuts sections that offer insight into the character of Mr. Knightley, Harriet Smith (her friend), Mr. Elton (the vicar), and Frank Churchill (a possible suitor).

page 1 | 2
Cynthia Greenwood writes about books and the performing arts. She is the author of The Complete Idiot's Guide to Shakespeare's Plays (to be released in April 2008 by Penguin/Alpha Books). She has written for The New York Times, Playbill, Andante, San Francisco Chronicle, Houston Chronicle, Dallas Morning News, and The Handbook of Texas Online. She reviewed opera and classical music for Houston Press from 1998-2002.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
TV Review: Jane Austen Lite - Emma Is Masterpiece's Breezy Comedy of Manners
Published: March 26, 2008
Type: Review
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: Classics, Video: Drama, Video: Television
Writer: Cynthia Greenwood
Cynthia Greenwood's BC Writer page
Cynthia Greenwood's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Cynthia Greenwood
Video: Classics
Video: Drama
Video: Television
All Video Articles
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — March 26, 2008 @ 19:22PM — Barbara Barnett [URL]

So much Austen, so little time...

I loved the Paltrow/Northam Emma, despite the fact that the age difference between Knightly and Emma was smaller than it should have been. Still...

#2 — March 26, 2008 @ 21:34PM — Josh Lasser [URL]

Congratulations! This article has been selected for syndication to the Advance family of websites and toBoston.com, which will allow even more readers to enjoy it.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/75198)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments