Movie Review: The Other Boleyn Girl
Published March 01, 2008
I will spare you many of the boring details of the story. While the individual details themselves might be interesting, the lack of anything of substance binding them together causes the story to come across blandly.
A big problem are the performances, or perhaps it is the way they are written. I just did not like any of them. Are we supposed to see romance? Intrigue? Personal drama? Whatever they were going for I just did not see it. I could not identify with or even like them. The father is weak and selfish, Anne is manipulative and power hungry, and Mary... well, she's the closest to human but still lacks much depth.
This movie just may not be for me and it belongs to a genre that more often than not escapes me. I sat there wanting to like it, but I couldn't. There is definitely plenty of intrigue to be milked, but everything is so stagy that it just sucks the humanity out and leaves melodrama that would be better served on the stage.
Bear witness as Eric Bana's King Henry VIII stomps around like a petulant child who doesn't get what he wants and just sits on the floor and pouts. Watch as Scarlet Johansson whimpers her way through as Mary, never giving us anything to root for, simply making sad faces throughout. All the while Natalie Portman's Anne chews up everything in sight; nothing is left untouched as she boils over with supposed emotion.
Nothing clicks, and when it came to a merciful end I was left wondering why. There is certainly plenty of talent involved, why is this not more involving than it is? Why is everything so drained of personality in the midst of wildly overdone theatrics?
Whatever the truth behind the fiction is, you would likely be better served reading the biographies written about Anne Boleyn than getting mixed up with this film.
Bottom line. You could do a lot worse on the big screen, but you could also do a lot better. Those who eat this stuff up are likely to enjoy seeing this dry telling play out. I hope it works out for you. As for me, I hesitate to call it bad, but it certainly could have been a whole lot better.
- Movie Review: The Other Boleyn Girl
- Published: March 01, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Video
- Filed Under: Video: Drama, Video: Historical
- Writer: Chris Beaumont
- Chris Beaumont's BC Writer page
- Chris Beaumont's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
I liked this movie. It was a bit more accurate than that of the TUDORS series on SHOW TV. Also, it didn't have so much blah blah sex in it. I went for the history and not the sex, so I rather enjoyed it. However though there was very, very little truth in the trashy TUDOR series on TV. My advise to others is not to watch it. It is filled with nothing but trashy lie after lie.
I was however very pleased that the truth came out about Mary Boleyn, who had the only living child of Henry Tudor, (Henry Tudor Carey) Should be Henry Tudor Jr. and not Carey by rights. This child of Mary Boleyn, as well has living descendant today. I happen to one of them.
OH! this movie was very nice. I loved it!!!
WOWSERS! What a great flick! It shows you can make a good movie without all the sex.
Sad experience
Movie lacked so much. "no sex?" What the hell were you watching the whole movie was based on sex very bad movie. Very little wait no "no action". Made history very boring. The jokes thrown in the lines (script) were not even remotely funny. Very Dry. My girl fell asleep it was so bad.


Christopher Beaumont spends much of his time writing about entertainment when he isn't sitting in a movie theater. He is known around the office as the "Movie Guy" and is always ready to talk about his favorite form of entertainment and offer up recommendations. Interests include science fiction, horror, and metal music. His writings can be found at 


Spend your money diffrently and buy the book it was so much better then the movie. I've been looking forward to this movie coming out for 6 months now, and now wished I hadn't seen it. It doesn't due the story justice. I know they have to shrink down the story for the big screen but they left out some key elements and added in some "hollywood" that I could have done without. Just my opinion but I'd stick with the book.