DVD Review: The Presidents - A History Channel Documentary Series
Published January 09, 2008
One thing that I could have done without in all this are the little bits of re-creations. They don't have sound and get maybe just a few seconds apiece. A lot of them are so quick as to be almost subliminal, gone before you would become conscious of the artifice — which is good. There was a somewhat distracting and obnoxious bit with an actor playing as Chester Arthur as a window shopping dandy.
One really useful visual point that they actually could have done more with is the use of vintage editorial cartoons, such as this depiction of Arthur as a "great machine trick." This gives a pretty good idea of the natural viewpoint that many contemporaries would have had.
Chet Arthur had a particularly interesting entry for being one of the less regarded presidents. In his background, he came up as tax collector of the New York Port Authority (a really important post in the pre-income tax era) with sponsorship of the particularly egregious New York patronage machine. President Hayes had made a big point of removing him from the job in a highly public attempt at civil service reform. The really interesting thing about that is that when he ascended to the presidency after Garfield's assassination, Arthur became the one who actually passed major civil service reform, even at the expense of his long friendship with Senator Conkling. His own party wouldn't nominate him to run for his own term after that, but note also that he set about a very desperately needed upgrade of the navy — which apparently had less than a half dozen ships that were really top flight. Seems like actually pretty fair accomplishment for a less than one term president.
Another tack that could be seen as distracting or illuminating (somewhat mixed results there) is the occasional invocation in narrative and video of modern issues seen as reflecting similar types of issues. Thus, the machine hack Arthur from the old school reforming civil service gets cut with images of the stalwart anti-Commie President Nixon going to China.
- DVD Review: The Presidents - A History Channel Documentary Series
- Published: January 09, 2008
- Type: Review
- Section: Video
- Filed Under: Politics: U.S., Politics: Government, Culture: History, Video: Documentary, Video: Historical, Video: Television
- Writer: Al Barger
- Al Barger's BC Writer page
- Al Barger's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Geoff- My point about activist vs pacifistic presidents is general, so it won't apply 100% in all places and times. Also, all presidents do something - and some things they're supposed to do. Trust busting was significant, but pretty mild as "activism" compared to FDR's breathtaking socialist usurpations.
And doing little or nothing would have been far better when he came to power. It was his huge, arbitrary and unpredictable interventions that drug out a bad market correction into a decade+ depression. Thomas Sowell notes that Black Friday in 1987 was proportionally as bad as the 1929 crash - yet Reagan resisted strong political pressures and did nothing. Arguably as a result of benign neglect, that bad minute in the market is now barely remembered.




I've been fascinated by the American presidents, all of them, since I was a small child. I've read extensively about them as well.
I found this History Channel series to be fairly interesting, but of course it's impossible to go in depth about any of the men who held the highest office in the land.
I would disagree with your opinion that "do nothing" presidents are better than "big doer" presidents. It was "do nothing" presidents like Millard Fillmore, Franklin Pierce, and James Buchanan (the 13th, 14th, and 15th presidents) who allowed the U.S. to spiral into the Civil War. It was other "do nothings" like Calvin Coolidge and Herbert Hoover who allowed the economy to plunge into the Great Depression.
Of course, activist presidents can also get us into trouble, such as the current one who led us into an unnecessary war with Iraq.
Finally, William Howard Taft wasn't exactly a "do nothing" president. For all the credit that Theodore Roosevelt gets for "busting" the trusts and monopolies of the times, William H. Taft's administration actually took more action against the trusts than did that of Roosevelt's.
This series was a good starting point for people who would like to know more about our presidents. Thanks for sharing.