Music DVD Review: Blackfield - Blackfield NYC: Blackfield Live In New York City
Published December 30, 2007
I've made no secret of the fact that the greatest, and most unexpected musical discovery I made in 2007 was the band Porcupine Tree.
Although I was a bit of a late bloomer to this band, once I "got it," I pretty much dove straight into the deep end of the pool — devouring everything I could get my hands on. Which proved to be a considerable task, since this band has apparently been the best-kept secret on this side of the pond since at least the mid-nineties.
So, in the way of a quick introduction for the uninitiated, Porcupine Tree began as a prog-rock band heavily influenced by people like Pink Floyd in the nineties on albums like The Sky Moves Sideways and Signify.
They have long since developed a harder, more distinctive sound uniquely their own on albums like Deadwing and this year's great Fear Of A Blank Planet, which I named my #2 Album Of The Year, right behind Springsteen's Magic.
In the #3 slot on that same list was Blackfield II, the second album from the side project of Porcupine Tree's resident creative genius, Steven Wilson.
So heres the thing.
Back in the seventies when I did my time behind the counter at a record store, I used to live to turn my customers on to guys like this. Steven Wilson is an absolutely major songwriting talent lying in wait to be discovered. With Porcupine Tree, he creates these incredible soundscapes that veer from quiet nuance, to bludgeoning metallic knockouts that quite literally split your skull in two.
Blackfield is Wilson's side project with Israeli singer/songwriter Aviv Geffen, that allows this amazingly prolific songwriter to explore lusher, more romantic pop terrain. Except for the fact that there is a dark edge to so many of these songs, masked as they are by the denser arrangements of Blackfield's two albums.
What we have here is a live DVD recorded earlier this year at New York City's Bowery Ballroom.
My review is simple. It's great. Buy it. There's nothing really fancy here. It's a great, if very straight forward — there are no special effects or tricky camera angles — document of the event. Well okay, I'm a little bit mystified as to why Aviv Geffen has all of that glitter all over his face.
- Music DVD Review: Blackfield - Blackfield NYC: Blackfield Live In New York City
- Published: December 30, 2007
- Type: Review
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Music: Live Concerts, Music: Progressive Rock, Music: Video, Review, Video: Music
- Writer: Glen Boyd
- Glen Boyd's BC Writer page
- Glen Boyd's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us


>







The videos you provided really help to tell your story. And you're right, there's nothing fancy in their show, and the songs are fairly straightforward renditions of what you get on the album, with just a bit harder edge. But with songs that good, there's no need to glam 'em up.
I was surprised I found "End Of The World" to be the best performance of this sampling being that it's my least favorite tune on Blackfield II (although I still liked the studio version alright). When the opportunity comes up for both Wilson and Geffen to sing lead together, they do it well.
Thanks for the write-up, Glen.