Movie Review: I Am Legend
Published December 20, 2007
I Am Legend has had quite a history in its 50-plus years of existence. It began life as a novella by Richard Matheson that was published in 1954. Ten years later Matheson would translate it to the screen for an Italian production called The Last Man on Earth starring Vincent Price. Despite Matheson's work on that script, you will not find his name in the credits. Due to artistic differences over the finished product he took his name off of it; in its place is an alias, Logan Swanson.
Still, it stands as the most faithful adaptation of the source. Seven years later Hollywood took a shot at the tale with the Charlton Heston vehicle The Omega Man. It, too, differs from the source and has a touch of camp when viewed today. Now, we are faced with a third try, the Will Smith vehicle I Am Legend. Well, at least they got the title right this time.
From a purely technological standpoint, I Am Legend is the most accomplished filmed vision of the story yet. We are given a completely convincing vision of a long abandoned Manhattan. It is overgrown with weeds and herds of deer run freely between empty cars and barren streets, hunted by lions and our hero, Robert Neville (Will Smith). This brings up a big question early in the film: "What happened?" It is not long before we find out.
Via flashback, we are let in on an important piece of information. In 2009 a cure for cancer is uncovered. Before long the cure has mutated into a deadly virus that has wiped out 99% of the world's population. The rest of the survivors have been turned into bloodthirsty creatures that exhibit similarities to both vampires and zombies, while not truly being either. All have become these things, all except one. The one lone holdout is Robert Neville, a man seemingly immune to the effects of the fast moving virus.
In this bleak future, Neville lives his life. During the day he cruises the streets looking for supplies, making sure he is back by night to the security of his home in Greenwich Village. It is in this house, with steel shutters and massive dead bolts that he, and his dog Sam, hide themselves away each night, keeping their distance from the creatures of the night. In addition to keeping himself alive, Neville has also set up a lab in the basement where he works feverishly, searching for a cure to the disease.
It seems simple enough, but it is an emotionally and psychologically complex story that looks into moral responsibility and the effects of loneliness on the individual; pretty heady stuff for a mass-marketed, would-be blockbuster (a status that has all but been assured by its opening weekend box office). Now, this film starts off strong, although the further in it goes, the more it devolves into more standard Hollywood action, ending with a climax that feels a bit hollow and tacked on. Still, for the first half to two thirds it works quite well. Most of its success can be laid at the feet of Will Smith who wrings as much as possible out of the nearly excellent screenplay from Mark Protosevich and Akiva Goldsman.
- Movie Review: I Am Legend
- Published: December 20, 2007
- Type: Review
- Section: Video
- Filed Under: Video: Action, Video: SF
- Writer: Chris Beaumont
- Chris Beaumont's BC Writer page
- Chris Beaumont's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
i cant agree more the end was a let down aswome movie but i felt left out like i needed more of the virus also why dose he have to die it would of been great to see will smith kick some infected ass at the end
Kept attention well, but as pointed out, annoying technical gaps - why not try the compound that worked on the rats on his dog ? Why no UV lighting in the house in case worst came to worst, especially in the lab (sunbeds/mercury vapour lamps !) ? Didn't quite get the misplaced mannequin bit - had he forgotten about it, was it one of his own traps ?
If you're seemingly immune, why not examine your own immunity and try an inoculation early on ? If it's a mutant strain, won't the people who had the benign form be protected in any way ?
And "Dr. Krippen"'s name came as a bit of a heavy-handed clunk - is it in the original ?
Still, will certainly dig out the original novella.


Christopher Beaumont spends much of his time writing about entertainment when he isn't sitting in a movie theater. He is known around the office as the "Movie Guy" and is always ready to talk about his favorite form of entertainment and offer up recommendations. Interests include science fiction, horror, and metal music. His writings can be found at 



I saw that Batman Superman ad...I thought it was just a little touch to the scenery, nice to know the Batman/Superman flick is on the way.
Great review of a great movie!