OPINION

Playoffs To Determine An NCAA Football Playoff System

Written by Matthew T. Sussman
Published December 17, 2007

Okay, we all agree. The BCS sucks. It doesn't determine the true two best teams. And no measurement can accurately determine the two best teams year in, year out.

So how shall we improve the method to determine a college football national champion? Maybe replace it with a classic bracket. How about add one more game? Perhaps we simply leave the BCS alone. Or something completely outrageous?

There's only one way to find out. Let's see if the BCS can be overcome the opposition by using the contender's core postseason mechanism: the seeded bracket.

THE SEEDS

1. BCS

As I've said, I like the system because of the Global Thermonuclear War chaos it causes. And without it, we don't have a magical 2007 Fiesta Bowl.

2. 8-team playoff

The most sensible number of playoff entrants. Beyond that you're often looking at three-loss teams.

3. "Plus-one" game

A bit ridiculous, because in a year such as this one you have more than four legitimate national championship arguments, but it's one of the more talked about — and even more important, realistic — solutions.

4. 16-team playoff

Now you're getting into more of a December Madness feel. Plus it mirrors the Championship Subdivision almost perfectly. Sixteen teams also enables the chance for a team from each conference...

5. 32-team playoff

...Whereas a system with thirty-two teams enables the chance for Michigan to participate every year.

6. One team per conference

And none more, which would likely eliminate teams like Georgia, Kansas, Missouri, Arizona State. Plus, it's only 11 schools — 12 if you want to include the top indie team. So there are first round byes.

7. No championship game

You know, before the BCS, we just had bowl games. That wasn't so bad in hindsight, now was it?

8. 64-team playoff

UTTER MADNESS! Also, if it must mirror the NCAA basketball tournament, I'm not opposed to Appalachian State-Delaware being the play-in game.

9. ESPN's 10-team bracket

By this, I don't mean implementing this 10-team system. Instead of having the two teams play football against each other, the learned ESPN counsel of Mark May, Kirk Herbstreit and Lee Corso actually decide who wins the games by talking about them once an night on SportsCenter.

10. World Cup-Style Pool

Sixteen teams in four pools. Everyone in a pool plays each other. Top two teams advance to the final eight. Plus ... international referee scandals! That always sweetens the entertainment. Stipulation: games have to be played at 5 a.m.

11. Reality TV-style voting

Money and ratings meet fan-teractivity. Starting in November, 10 teams are [gulp] selected. Each week fans vote online or text message the names of a team they think shouldn't play for the national championship. Then, in four weeks, we have two teams left over. And of course, it's all broadcast on prime time.

page 1 | 2
Matt SussmanMatt Sussman is the former sports editor of BC Magazine and also writes for Deadspin, SPORTSbyBROOKS, The Futon Report, and the Toledo Free Press. Catch him with Tuffy on Treehouse Fort, the official show of BC Sports.

Feed the feedback back to matt.sussman@blogcritics.org.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Playoffs To Determine An NCAA Football Playoff System
Published: December 17, 2007
Type: Opinion
Section: Sports
Filed Under: Sports: College, Sports: Football (American)
Writer: Matthew T. Sussman
Matthew T. Sussman's BC Writer page
Matthew T. Sussman's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Matthew T. Sussman
Sports: College
Sports: Football (American)
All Sports Articles
Matthew T. Sussman's personal weblog
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — December 17, 2007 @ 11:38AM — Tuffy [URL]

The plus-shaped football field system gets its championship shirts from Lane Bryant.

#2 — December 17, 2007 @ 11:52AM — Druxxx

I like the reality TV vote off.

I think there are 119 teams in Division 1A.
We play 118 weeks, one team is voted off each week.

So what if that takes over 2 years. The BCS makes no sense, so why should the new system.
Plus everyone says how much they love college footballs "regular season." This just makes it over 100 weeks longer. And college football would become year round.

#3 — December 17, 2007 @ 19:33PM — RJ Elliott [URL]

10. World Cup-Style Pool

Sixteen teams in four pools. Everyone in a pool plays each other. Top two teams advance to the final eight. Plus ... international referee scandals! That always sweetens the entertainment. Stipulation: games have to be played at 5 a.m.


Hilarious!

#4 — December 18, 2007 @ 19:18PM — Jordan

Oh please, anything but #9. With Mark May and Lou Holtz running things we'd have a USC-Notre Dame title game for eighteen years in a row.

#5 — December 18, 2007 @ 19:21PM — Jordan

Actually, scratch that: #9 and #16 are the exact same thing.

#6 — December 19, 2007 @ 14:59PM — The other anonymous

Round 1 winners:

USC wins every time
ESPN's 10 team bracket

X-Box 360
97 team playoff

8 team playoff
no championship game

Reality TV vote-off
Plus 1 game

Round 2 winners:

USC wins every year (same as the ESPN picks)
X-Box 360

No championship game
plus 1 game


Round 3 winners:

X-Box 360
No championship game


GRAND CHAMPION:

NO CHAMPIONSHIP GAME!!!
College football returns to the 80's

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/71989)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments