Reflections on God and Santa
Published December 06, 2007
It's Christmastime again — the one time of the year when everyone, Christians and atheists, Democrats and Republicans, even cats and dogs, can put aside their differences and enjoy the same wonderful holiday.
The Christmas spirit has caused me to start thinking about the nature of God — and the nature of Santa Claus. Now I'm sure I'm not the first person to speculate on the relationship between the two, but there are some amazing similarities that have led me to conclude that they are, indeed, the same person. Or, more precisely, I believe that God is the grown-up version of Santa Claus.
Let's start with the obvious physical characteristics. Both God and Santa are portrayed as old men with long white hair and a long white beard. While Santa is a little on the portly side, God apparently watches what he eats. St. Nick, of course, is obliged to down those millions of cookies left out for him, so I'm not judging.
Another striking feature of the two big guys is the way us humans treat them both as, essentially, ATM machines. Kids sit on Santa's lap and reel off a long list of toys that they really, really want, while "prosperity" preachers tell their flocks that God will give them anything they want — a new car, diamond rings, or that big new house. Of course, while Santa gives away his stuff for free, God usually requires that you ante up at least 10% of your income before giving up his stuff to you.
Then, of course, there's the whole reward and punishment system that both employ. While Santa promises presents for good children and threatens bad kids with a lump of coal, God is a little more serious about the whole thing, promising Heaven for those who believe in him and eternal torment in the fiery pits of Hell for those who don't. Stylistic differences, for sure, but essentially the same system.
- Reflections on God and Santa
- Published: December 06, 2007
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Culture
- Filed Under: Culture: Holidays and Traditions, Culture: Humor and Satire, Culture: Religion
- Writer: Doug DeLong
- Doug DeLong's BC Writer page
- Doug DeLong's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us




I think that's part of it, for some people. But there's a lot more to it than that.
Also, the legend of Santa Claus has its origins in the Catholic church and in Germanic paganism. The two versions were later unified in the wake of the spread of Christianity, so it's not quite accurate to divorce belief in the Santa legend and belief in the Biblical legends, at least historically speaking. The Santa-based Christmas rituals were brought to America by the Dutch in the 1600s or 1700s, evidently. I think the Santa legend began to take on a non-religious life of its own as a natural by-product of relative economic prosperity in the 1900s, where he has become a symbol more associated with secular materialism, while serving as a watchful omniscient eye to keep the kiddies in line, at which point your theory would, at some level, apply. And there, it's easy to see why hardcore Christians would object to immersion in the Santa legend among the secular: he serves as a God-substitute vis-a-vis the parent/child relationship.
The Christian reward-punishment paradigm is an irresistible draw for many, and I think you're right in noting that this pattern of belief is imprinted at an early age via Santa. Whether that represents an inherent need or whether it's just an accident of history ... who knows?
Now, if you could explain hunting for colored boiled eggs on Easter Sunday ....