McFadden For Heisman - There, I Feel Better
Published November 27, 2007
Batting Around is BC Sports' look back at the week's happenings in the world o' sports, presented in a lineup card format for some undisclosed reason.
The Lineup Card
1. RB Darren McFadden
2. K Jeff Reed
3. CF Torii Hunter
4. PG LeBron James
5. Pete Sampras (ret.)
6. LG Kalani Heppe
7. RB Priest Holmes
8. G Chris Osgood
9. SP Joe Kennedy (RIP)
Coach: Houston Nutt
1. RB Darren McFadden — I'd been hoping, praying, reaching for someone not named Tim Tebow I can get behind for the Heisman Trophy. (To those who missed last week: I'm not sure why I can't support Tebow. He's just a football player, and I never met him.) But perhaps McFadden, who literally willed his unranked Arkansas Razorbacks to a triple-overtime upset at top-ranked LSU, put himself back in the race.
He leads all non-Conference USA running backs with 1,725 yards. His sum of 15 TDs isn't eye-popping but he has manned the Arkansas offense from the old-style "single-wing" formation, and has thrown 6-for-11 for 123 yards and four touchdowns. No picks, either.
Combining all those touchdowns (and the one he caught) he only had 20, which is less than Tebow has just running the ball. But what's rarer these days? A quarterback who can run, or a running back who can pass?
Maybe it's about innovation. If an offensive lineman can ever kick 40-yard field goals, I'd probably give him my Heisman vote, which is — sadly — nonexistent.
2. K Jeff Reed — Initially there was no reason to watch a Pittsburgh Steelers-Miami Dolphins game on Monday Night Football, unless winless Miami was somehow making a game of it, which was highly doubtful.
And that's when the rain turned an ordinary football field into tabula rasa, a 100-yard field bereft of paint, with a texture consistent to that of a foam mattress. Perhaps Pittsburgh was experimenting with TempurTurf©, the field that conforms to a football player's body as he falls to the ground.
Probably the only guy who saw playing time and didn't fall down was Reed, the Steelers kicker. He overcame a poorly, poorly shanked field goal attempt by kicking a 24-yard field-goal, which even I didn't think he'd make. Those three points were the only ones score the entire game, and they came in the 60th and final minute. Not since the 40s had an NFL game gone scoreless well into the fourth quarter, let alone the final minute.
- McFadden For Heisman - There, I Feel Better
- Published: November 27, 2007
- Type: News
- Section: Sports
- Filed Under: Sports: Baseball, Sports: Basketball, Sports: College, Sports: Football (American), Sports: Hockey, Sports: Tennis
- Part of a feature: Batting Around
- Writer: Matthew T. Sussman
- Matthew T. Sussman's BC Writer page
- Matthew T. Sussman's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
- RSS Feeds
- All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
Articles in this series
BC articles by Matthew T. Sussman
Sports: Baseball
Sports: Basketball
Sports: College
Sports: Football (American)
Sports: Hockey
Sports: Tennis
All Sports Articles
Matthew T. Sussman's personal weblog
All News articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments
Comments
By trying to find someone other than Tebow, you prove you are prejudiced against greatness and should never be given a Heisman ballot.
I do have self-loathing tendencies, so you might be right Shawn.
I was a little snappy, huh.
It just irritates me that people actually are going out of their way to vote against Tebow. Why is he so hated? He has outperformed in every way, and should be looked at as a model athlete. Yet people don't want to give him the recognition he deserves. After reading your article again there seems to be some sarcasm, but I don't know. I'm just getting irritated by all the people (not just you) who appear to be grasping at straws.
Mcfadden had 2 great games this season. The LSU win was great. But two other running backs also combined for 170 yards on 12 less carries that game from Arkansas. He didn't by any means carry the team.
Where was he for the Auburn game when he rushed for the grand total of 43 yards. Or FIU for 61? Or Ole Miss for 88? He's good, but his stats aren't amazing. When Reggie Bush won the Heisman, he averaged 8.7 yards per carry. Mcfadden has rushed the ball 100 more times than Bush and has gained 1,725 yards. 15 less than Bush. Reggie Bush was phenomenal. Darren Mcfadden is just everyone's alternative to one of the best quarterbacks the country has ever seen.
I'll admit Tebow is just a sophomore, and in no way compares to some of the college greats. But on the other hand...this kid is a sophomore and is breaking records those college greats couldn't. This season his stats surpass every other quarterback by far, and his closest competition, Mcfadden, isn't really that strong of a running back. Unless you count 61 rushing yards against FIU strong.


Matt Sussman is the former sports editor of BC Magazine and also writes for 



Someone's found the softer side of Sears photography. And you thought me mad when I suggested my BCS theory!