Greed, Soup and The Rape of the Oceans
Published November 06, 2007
Take Canada for example. We may have some measure of restrictions on shark finning yet we have no regulation or law that prevents shark fins from being imported into the country. It didn't take me long to find a fair number of restaurants in Toronto that serve shark fin soup.
Even my home town of Hamilton where, as the manager of one popular restaurant told me, "shark fin has not really caught on with most of the people here," I nevertheless found that almost every Chinese restaurant in the downtown Hamilton core serves shark fin soup. It may not be listed on the menu, but many do have it if you ask.
What is the point then, of making the act of finning illegal on our own shores if we import the product of that same illegal action? Is the effect not exactly the same? Have we no responsibility whatsoever for the products we choose to allow into our country? Then again,our own record is pretty shaky when it comes to protecting not just the environment, but endangered species as well.
John Baird, the Minister of the Environment showed great enthusiasm for Rob Stewart's message and wanted to get involved. But of course, once the photo opp was complete, nothing was done. Really, you had to know that his promise of action was non existant. He's a politician after all.
Mr Baird has not only failed to take any type of action whatsoever, but Canada led the charge against adding two new species of sharks the CITES endangered list. This in spite of Mr. Baird's office having received 3500 e-mails in a single day on the issue. The voices of the people were completely ignored.
CITES, or The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species met recently and a proposal to add more species of sharks to an already ridiculously small list was discussed. Canada stood firm in its refusal to add two species, the Porbeagle shark and the Spiny Dogfish to the list. Thanks to Canada's insistence, these two species did not make the endangered list even though experts agree their numbers have also declined by over 90 percent.
So why would Canada not support the inclusion of these two species to the CITES list Mr. Baird? Perhaps it's because like illegal finners, we're making a killing off these animals? Canada has fisheries for both sharks and is not about to give up a lucrative trade even if we are playing with a soon to be non-existent resource.
- Greed, Soup and The Rape of the Oceans
- Published: November 06, 2007
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Sci/Tech
- Filed Under: Sci/Tech: Science, Sci/Tech: Physical Sciences, Politics: Policy, Politics: International, Politics: Government, Culture: Society, Culture: Education
- Part of a feature: Swimming with Humans - The Precarious Life of Sharks
- Writer: Nathalie Vanderheyden
- Nathalie Vanderheyden's BC Writer page
- Nathalie Vanderheyden's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
- RSS Feeds
- All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
Articles in this series
BC articles by Nathalie Vanderheyden
Sci/Tech: Science
Sci/Tech: Physical Sciences
Politics: Policy
Politics: International
Politics: Government
Culture: Society
Culture: Education
All Sci/Tech Articles
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments
Comments
Thank you so much. This topic means a great deal to me. I appreciate that!
Cheers
Nat
Shark Fin has no flavor. Try using tofu. Same effect without the carnage.
Sharkfin soup gets it's flavor entirely from the herbs and sauces that are added to it. Uninformed people believe that it is an aphrodisiac.
Great article! Here's some interesting information:
"Spiny dogfish are fished for food in Europe, the United States, Canada, New Zealand and Chile. The meat is primarily consumed in England, France, the Benelux countries and Germany. The fins and tails are processed into fin needles and are used in less expensive versions of shark fin soup in Chinese cuisine. In England it is sold in "fish and chip shops" as "rock salmon", in France it is sold as "small salmon" (saumonette) and in Belgium it is sold as "sea eel" (zeepaling). It is also used as fertilizer, liver oil, and pet food, and, because of its availability and manageable size, as a popular vertebrate dissection specimen, especially in high schools."
Their conservation status is "Vulnerable" ...
Thanks so much for commenting and adding the extra info guys. There's so much to talk about on this issue. I didn't even get into all the health stores and pharmacies that sell shark cartilage pills for joints and arthritis. I even saw one bottle labeled as "prevents tumors". Can you believe that?
"I didn't even get into all the health stores and pharmacies that sell shark cartilage pills for joints and arthritis."
Yeah, my grandmother (who has terrible arthritis in her hands) once received some shark cartilage pills from a "natural health" store as a gift from a family member. As you can imagine, it didn't help...









Nice set of articles Nathalie! Keep it up!