NCAA Football Week 5 Preview
Published September 28, 2007
BC Tailgate is the official home on Blogcritics for college football news, rants, and riffs. Every conference is covered — we don't play favorites to the big boys.
ACC by Geeves
Big East by Dan McGowan
Big Ten by Geeves
Big XII by Ben Miraski
Conference USA by Matt Sussman
Independents by Benjamin Cossel
MAC by Matt Sussman
Mountain West by Matt Sussman
Pac 10 by Steve
SEC by Josh Hathaway
Sun Belt by Benjamin Cossel
WAC by Matt Sussman
Well, it's a good thing Georgia Tech went and showed how wrong I was by losing to Virginia. Oh well, I guess that just makes Boston College the clear favorite now. Though the rest of the conference seems doomed to peck at each other and crush BC's BCS score, I'm sure the team will be perfectly okay with it as long as they get their first post-O'Brien conference championship.
Virginia Tech, Miami, Rutgers, Virginia, and BC should not have a terrible ton of difficulty... well, maybe Miami will, because they haven't dominated Duke like in years past, and Duke's offense looked pretty spiffy this past weekend.
Georgia Tech will welcome Clemson to town and hope like heck that Tashard Choice can find some running room within an incredibly quick Tigers defense.
Florida State stays at home to play Alabama, and I think I like Bobby Bowden's odds of not adding to his win total. Unless Nick Saban decides to quit as coach this week. You really never know with that guy.
Lastly, Louisville hopes to end their freefall, which in theory will be easy considering their offense and NC State's defense. Then again, Tom O'Brien is a good coach, NC State isn't a horrible team, and we didn't expect Louisville to be 2-2 right now, either.
WInners: Duke, NC State, Alabama, Clemson. That's right, the mighty will continue to fall this week. Also, these games will be incredibly dull without any upsets.
West Virginia's first true test comes Friday night when the fifth ranked Mountaineers travel to Tampa to meet No. 18 South Florida in the conference opener for both teams. Last year, Pat White and Steve Slaton were shut down by the Bulls defense, combining for just 60 yards and three turnovers. They'll need a stronger performance this time if they hope to stay in the BCS title game discussion.
Expect to see Slaton break out this week in what will one of the most exciting games in the conference all season. I like the Mountaineers 45-35.
Quick notes
UConn should handle Akron this weekend, which means the Huskies will head to Virginia next week with a chance to become bowl eligible.
It's not all that often you see a 37 point favorite lose, but that exactly what Louisville did last week against Syracuse. At this point, the Cardinals might be the most disappointing team in college football, counting Michigan.
No. 24 Cincinnati will be 5-0 when it heads to Piscataway next weekend for a date with tenth ranked Rutgers.
- NCAA Football Week 5 Preview
- Published: September 28, 2007
- Type: News
- Section: Sports
- Filed Under: Sports: College, Sports: Football (American)
- Part of a feature: BC Tailgate
- Writer: Matthew T. Sussman
- Matthew T. Sussman's BC Writer page
- Matthew T. Sussman's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Geeves totally wins for creativity this week. But he should watch out... A similar article written by a writer in South Bend got a fairly nasty reception from Charlie Weis.
Guess this was just the week for poor coach-media relations.
HA! I fear not the stadium-cleaning wrath of JoePa.
I'm sorry, but it really was boneheaded coaching. That conservativeness is exactly why they're 0 for their last 9 against UM.
Yeah, Pico, I hear Saban didn't lobby too hard for Jimbo to rejoin him in Tuscaloosa. I know he got a raise from FSU but this will set his head coaching candidacy back at least a year because that offense is pretty horrible.
As for Muschamp, he's a smart enough guy but has just never gotten a defense to play at the level he did under Saban and I think Saban is the missing ingredient in that. Auburn's defenses were better under Gene Chizik. Tubs has gotten the best of Florida a few times but I think his former charges at Ole Miss did him a major disservice. Auburn upset UF last year -- that was Florida's one loss -- and Ole Miss made them look bad. I'm sure Meyer was on the warpath all week.
I'd love to see Croom get that upset, I have a lot of respect for him.
The word was that Fisher was expecting Saban to make him OC at Miami, and Saban wisely didn't offer that to him but a position coaching job, so he stayed at LSU until FSU took him off the Tigers' hands. Fisher is one helluva recruiter but his play calling can be rather bizarre at times.
Muschamp has done a reasonably good job at Auburn with arguably significantly less talent than he had at LSU. But their offense (especially Brandon Cox) is turning over the ball a lot and saddling their defense short fields to work with.
I'm kinda rooting for Croom, too. I don't know if it's going to be USC, but I feel he's got at least one more upset up his sleeve. Better watch out, it could be 'Bama ;&)
I know he hasn't had as much talent at Auburn as he did at LSU, but Chizik got more out of the defenses he coached at Auburn than Muschamp has. I don't know why it's not working. I thought it was a coup when Auburn hired him.
I think Arkansas and SCAR are more vulnerable to MSU than 'Bama, if only because they got us last year. I have a feeling we're going to be a little more prepared. Hell, Saban can't help but have this team better prepared than Shula did regardless of the opponent.
Fischer is a quintessential example of a coach who got famous on the backs of his players. He's not a brilliant tactician who got more out of his players than was there nor is he a guy who has developed a system of any note. He's got a standard offense that will succeed or fail based solely on the assembled talent. FSU doesn't have much of that on offense.
Well, I thought Muschamp did a pretty good job against that high powered Florida offense, didn't you?
Makes a big difference when the Aubie offense is not putting their defense in the hole so much.
SEC football just plain rules...
said it all already i bet you owe bookies big........




Matt Sussman is the former sports editor of BC Magazine and also writes for 


re SEC (Josh):
Good takes, this is definitely a down week for matchups in the SEC.
Saban facies his old OC Jimbo Fisher from LSU in the FSU game, while he'll go up against his old DC Will Muschamp in the Iron Bowl. Neither are said to have left on good terms with Nick, but I'm not holding my breath that any "revenge" will factor into the outcome of either games.
Tubs typically does well against Fla. but the Gators will be motivated to avenge their only loss last year in a field they've never lost in since Meyer became head coach. This one should be ugly, but this being the SEC, you can't say for sure.
And I, too, was thinking that MSU could be a trap game for Spurrier.