Theater Review: Bleed Rail Is a Bloody Mess
Published May 29, 2007
Mickey Birnbaum's Bleed Rail, making its world premiere at the Theatre@Boston Court in Pasadena, California, is a testament to a liberal bleeding heart writer, hemorrhaging with good intentions. Good intentions alone are never enough and this patient needs intensive editing to stitch up the messy subplots and themes into a healthy message play.
In the program notes, Birnbaum states he was inspired to write this play by a 2001 article in Mother Jones by Eric Schlosser. The article, called "The Chain Never Stops," is written with Upton Sinclair in mind. We know this because the beginning pull quote is from the book The Jungle.
In the magazine article, Schlosser means to expose the indignities that the meatpacking companies pile upon their employees, three quarters of whom Schlosser claims are immigrants. While Sinclair wrote about matters of sanitation and work conditions, Schlosser writes about crafty legal maneuvers as well as devastating injuries including those that weren't well understood in Sinclair's day — repetitive motion injuries.
Birnbaum seems to nod his head toward both Sinclair and Schlosser. Using sounds and motions and lots of red stage blood, director Jessica Kubzansky conveys the goriness of the work. The chain never stops because the workers, Ryan (Dennis Flanagan) and Justin (Josh Clark), aren't allowed to stop or hold up the line, threatened with layoffs. This is very much in line with Schlosser's article.
Yet Birnbaum meanders off into contemplations about poor white trash girls like Jewel (Lily Holleman) who get pregnant in the back of an SUV and use sex to substitute for rent, about entrepreneurial minimal-wage workers like Keith (Cyrus Alexander) who supplement their income by making amateur porn to sell on the Internet, and about the anger of one man who loses his dignity and his sometime-girlfriend when he's injured on the job.
Although there is a passing mention of co-workers who are Latino, this production and the script focuses on poor white workers and yet veers off again from the sudden wealth of a porn maker to violent confrontations with an indignant boyfriend of one of the porn stars, hallucinations of a drugged out worker and the sudden physical rehabilitation of all the characters so the two men can go to Iraq. And of course, we get to know what happens in Iraq to Ryan and Keith and it isn't good.
In a way, the quick recovery of Ryan from his work-related injury seems a betrayal to Schlosser's article. Schlosser makes it clear that the physical outlook for these people is bleak. Birnbaum, like a miracle of TV, quickly glosses over this so he can move the action to Iraq and get an anti-war message in. And that's not even the ending there. Tacked on is a scene in a heavenly factory where cows are given back life, literally stitched together and our cast are all back together to see those cows given life.
Birnbaum's play is much like stitching a dead cow together after it has been butchered. The result isn't one cohesive, living, breathing piece, but a horrific bloody mess that has good edible parts that we're not allowed to stew and chew on intellectually because we're distracted by the crazy stitch work that only barely holds this thing together.
- Theater Review: Bleed Rail Is a Bloody Mess
- Published: May 29, 2007
- Type: Review
- Section: Culture
- Filed Under: Culture: Theater
- Part of a feature: Breaking Legs in Lalaland
- Writer: Purple Tigress
- Purple Tigress's BC Writer page
- Purple Tigress's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us






Nothing I love more than a strong response to my work. Obviously, I don't agree with you, but a good tirade sure beats someone falling asleep in their seat. I'll come visit your site again when I'm not in the firing line! Nice work!
Best,
Mickey Birnbaum