OPINION

The Expert Jerk: Click It or Ticket - Seat Belt Safety or Stupidity?

Written by Gray Hunter
Published May 21, 2007

On May 21, be sure to start wearing your seat belt because a nationwide operation has begun: Click It or Ticket. I’m so glad law enforcement officials will be observing the seat belt usage of the entire nation. It’s much better than tracking down the crackheads and tweakers in the community. Those types only rob banks and kill people, unlike the losers who don’t wear their seat belts in their own vehicle. Those guys are the worst.

I just don’t get the seat belt issue. Okay, sure, there is some evidence that seat belts can prevent some injuries. Here are some statistics from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) website:

  • Of the 31,910 vehicle occupants killed in crashes in 2001, 60 percent were not wearing a safety belt. [The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Annual Assessment of Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2001]
  • Seventy-three percent of the people who were in a fatal crash in 2001 and were restrained survived; of those who were not restrained, only 44 percent survived. [NHTSA, Annual Assessment of Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2001]
  • In 2001, 63 percent of 16- to 20-year-old drivers and passengers killed or seriously injured in crashes were not wearing a safety belt. [Fatality Analysis Reporting System, 2001 Annual Report File (ARF)]

These statistics are from the government so their veracity is automatically in question. In a statement from a separate entity, CarAccidents, “Failure to wear a seat belt contributes to more fatalities than any other single traffic safety-related behavior. 63% of people killed in accidents are not wearing seat belts. Wearing a seat belt use is still the single most effective thing we can do to save lives and reduce injuries on America's roadways.”

Of those fatalities, how many would have died whether wearing a seat belt or not? When an 18-wheeler rolls over on you, a seat belt won’t do you much good. If it’s for safety, as the government says, that we are being forced to wear our seat belts in our own vehicles, then why do new cars come with jacks for plugging in digital accessories like cell phones? Isn’t that dangerous for drivers? I believe so. In fact, it’s probably one of those jerks who will run into me while I’m not wearing my seat belt.

What of motorcyclists? In Arizona, adults are not required by law to wear a helmet. I’m sitting in my half-ton truck — forced to wear a seat belt — looking at some idiot on a Honda Goldwing with no helmet. At least my government thinks I’m worth saving. I’ve got a seat belt. Ha! Screw the bikers.

page 1 | 2
Gray Hunter enjoys an eremitical life in the desert. Beer and words are two pleasures in his life. He holds down two jobs while he works at his novels and stories.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
The Expert Jerk: Click It or Ticket - Seat Belt Safety or Stupidity?
Published: May 21, 2007
Type: Opinion
Section: Culture
Filed Under: Culture: Crime and Court, Culture: Society, Politics: Law and Rights, Sci/Tech: Health/Fitness
Writer: Gray Hunter
Gray Hunter's BC Writer page
Gray Hunter's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Gray Hunter
Culture: Crime and Court
Culture: Society
Politics: Law and Rights
Sci/Tech: Health/Fitness
All Culture Articles
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — May 21, 2007 @ 18:48PM — Yakov Hadash [URL]

What brilliant observations! While we're at it, let's blindfold our NASA scientists and take away all of the computers from IBM's engineers -- after all, without those "crutches," they'll really work hard to try to accomplish their goals!

Also, we should cut everyone's legs off.

#2 — May 21, 2007 @ 18:54PM — Gray Hunter

Yes, I agree wholeheartedly. Let's face the fact that the NASA "scientists" are all on meth these days, so blindfolds wouldn't hamper their work at all. The IBM jerks should be able to do the math in their head - if they weren't busy with all their cyberfantasies.

Yes, **** the crutches of society!!

As far as cutting off legs ... well, it didn't do any damage to the Black Knight's ego. He just saw the severed limbs and attacked all the more.

Rock on.

#3 — May 24, 2007 @ 01:43AM — Honest John [URL]

My wife and I were on a date night tonight in San Diego and got NAILED by a CHP offer with the claim that my wife was not wearing her seat belt. If there is one safety queen in America, it is my wife. She always wears her belt with or without a law. She was turned sideways while talking to me and pulled the strap back a little so she could shade herself from the sun and look at me. She was definitely bucked up, but the officer still gave us a ticket.

I told the cop that I have been hearing about the Click It Ticket concept lately and was surprised to be one of the victims. He agreed that there was definitely a campaign. Therefore, by his own words, it is not about saving lives but about a quota.

It is tough being an officer and having to listen to most people say, "I am innocent." It is just disappointing to be a citizen with a clean record and get written up for not wearing a seat belt!

#4 — May 24, 2007 @ 08:04AM — Gray Hunter

Honest John,

I am sorry to hear about your victimization. However, I am glad that you shared it with us. This is more proof of the stupidity of the seat belt issue.

I have, so far, been spared. But they are watching.

#5 — May 24, 2007 @ 12:22PM — Cary Sappington

Yes, Corzine has admitted his error and paid the fine for not wearing a seat belt. I'm glad he has taken up the public service initiative to publicize his error and convince others to wear their seat belt.

I am however, disappointed in all previous commentary that ignores the cause of Mr Corzine's accident and injury when the data is clearly stated. His vehicle was travelling well in excess of the posted speed limit (90 mph in a 65 zone) Even though the vehicle's emergency lights may have been on and flashing, where was the emergency? Corzine was travelling to a meeting with Imus and the Rutgers womens basketball team. This is an emergency requiring excessive speed on a crowded roadway?

Clearly, the use of emergency lights and high speed is needed in many circumstances. I do, however, believe in this case that use was NOT warranted. Where is the outcry about this abuse for an elected official?

#6 — May 24, 2007 @ 12:26PM — Gray Hunter

Sounds like Corzine and other abuser would be good fodder for a new Expert Jerk article. I will do what I can.

#7 — May 24, 2007 @ 12:38PM — andy roth

Corzine was'nt truly the one who was lucky. It was all the motorist around him that were luckily not killed or injured when his irresponsible driver (a cop) broke the law. Gov Rendell Of Pa has the same problem, never wheres a setbelt(look at any photo of him in his car, moving or not). and his driver is another corrupt cop that believes he's above the law because he's driving the governor.
Whether I wear a setbelt or not, is my business. Now of course its a source of monitary input for local police departments. so its there business.

#8 — May 24, 2007 @ 13:46PM — Pete Murway

My father and I were in a head on in Long Island on Rockaway Blvd. We were in a VW bug, the other car was a Caddy. I got the point of wearing seatbelts at an early age... 1963 was a bad year for seatbelts, there were none in the car we were in. I was 4y/o at the time. As you can tell I'm alive- I never knew my father. End of story. Please put your seat belt on. Thankyou.

#9 — May 24, 2007 @ 17:28PM — Randy

I posted this on another blog and want others to read this also:

Seat Belt Law
I agree completely to the post about the 91 MPH in a 65 zone!
I was pulled over once for going (Downhill) for going over '2' MPH by an Ohio State Patrol in a 55 MPH highway and given a warning ticket! I guess he did that to just to show activity to his supervisor.
Why the Hell was the State Patrol traveling at that speed with the Governor in his vehicle? Was he on official duty chasing someone who was observed as Not Wearing His Seatbelt or Maybe he was transporting him to a late Dinner Campaign Money Raising Dinner Reservation? (Perhaps a rumor they heard of a special offer on Krispy Creame Donuts).
Let's get the whole story out in the open here!
The attorney who pushed the Seat Belt Law in Ohio years ago, who was at that time my attorney (and I can state not that good as far as working for the little man unless a lot of money was in involved), had to have his original version of the law rewritten before it would be accepted that ... (paraphrasing), NO Ticket could be issued as a primary reason for being pulled over - This ticket could be given as a secondary ticket ONLY in addition to the principal reason a witnessed violation had occurred!
Example: A speeding violation was witnessed and the violator was stopped, upon the approach up to the driver's window the officer witnessed that the seat belt was not being used, then and ONLY then could a Seat Belt Ticket be issued as a Secondary Offence!
So much for that - You must admit that once the government has their foot in the door... they will find a way to make a revision as to change it to make it possible to create a money maker scam out of it.
Now that you can be pulled over as they watch you drive by to issue the ticket for up to $200.00 - It is a Cash Cow and an easy way to pump money into their system. (As one Dallas Policeman stated, "Each ticket I write... adds to my retirement fund"
More manpower has been placed on this Easy Money Maker now than any other policy in the past with all of the checkpoints set up intending to catch the Driver and each passenger to get the most money from each stop.
It is turning truly into a Police State, (Pun Intended), to create an easy relief to the cost of the judicial system as it is much easier to just pay the fine than to spend the money and time on fighting it in court!
Instead of placing the manpower on fighting true crime, they are making a contest out of seeing how many tickets the police can write on this misdemeanor.
My vehicle was broken into a few years ago and approx. $6,000.00 of items stolen out of it, along with about 8 other vehicles ... when I called the Dallas Police to report it the officer said that they were too busy to come out the location to check it out and took my cell phone number and said that an officer would call me back to take the details. It has been 4 (FOUR) years now and I have never heard from them again.
People... you are losing your rights quickly - And once it has been turned over to the Government... You will never regain them

#10 — May 24, 2007 @ 18:07PM — Gray Hunter

Exactly, Randy, exactly!

#11 — May 26, 2007 @ 21:28PM — Kathy

I was recently a victim of a Bait-and-Switch tactic by a state trooper (aka: Der Kommissar).
I quickly put my seat-belt on before he even got out of his car. He approached me and said that I did not have a license plate on the front of my vehicle, however, he would simply give me a warning for that. Then he proceeded to tell me that he noticed that I was not wearing my seatbelt while he was driving in the opposite direction. He then handed me a ticket and I was forced to pay a fine of a whopping $ 92.00!
I paid it along with a note on the check that the $ 92.00 was for my support and obedience to The Third Reich! Heil Hitler! I also included a picture of Hitler and wrote "Policemen wear your swasticas and show your true colors." I also sent the court a picture of a large building with an arm coming out of it doing a salute to Hitler and captioned it as follows "this is a courthouse in the U.S. in the new millennium." I hope I made my point. I feel that we are in a "Police State" and that more of our rights are being taken away, one unfair law at a time. I feel that there will come a time in the not so distant future that there will need to be a showdown between citizens and our government. If we don't start standing up for our rights, we won't have any rights left to stand up for!

#12 — May 27, 2007 @ 12:36PM — Kathy

I heard a rumor that the government can legally listen in to anyone's personal phone calls now due to the so-called "War on Terror". Is this true?

#13 — May 28, 2007 @ 00:49AM — Gray Hunter

Kathy, that is somewhat true. There was much debate regarding the US "monitoring" its own citizens.

#14 — May 28, 2007 @ 07:58AM — JoJo

I was pulled over about a week ago and received a seatbelt ticket. The officer said he clocked me at 75 mph yet he gave me a warning for the speeding and a ticket for not wearing the seatbelt. The ticket states that I was pulled over for speeding yet no where on the ticket does it say how fast I was going. I don't believe he even clocked me at all. Well, I drive a pick-up and truck and am only 4'11" tall and the shoulder harness restricts my neck so that I can not turn my head as far to check the blind spot. I have a perfect driving record right now and I want to fight this ticket, especially since I don't think the Euclid Police Officer actually clocked me at all. The harness also rubs against my neck right where I have a mole and it's unconfortable. I have been wearing the seatbelt ever since, though. My pick-up is a two seater and it's okay for people to ride in the back of the pick-up without being restrained. Please correct me if I'm wrong. Just because I don't like wearing a seatbelt does not make me a criminal and the reason they are giving warnings for the primary reason they pull you over they give the seatbelt ticket because it costs more. I am on disability and plan to go to court and at least ask if I can do community service or something. I just don't have the money. I really need to know if this is constitutional when there is no victim except the ticketee. I have been a Liberatarion since 1976 when I first voted and wrote in Roger McBride for president. Their policy was to eliminate victimless crimes. I need to fight this and I need help. My court date is May 30, at 9:00am in Euclid, OH.

Thanks,

JoJo

#15 — May 28, 2007 @ 08:00AM — JoJo

What is a URL?

#16 — May 30, 2007 @ 16:55PM — Joanne Winfield

This is in reference to my last post. On May 29, I called the Euclid Police Dept to find out what the price of the seatbelt ticket was. I was really ready to fight it since my sister is an attorney and all, but my ticket was only $25.00 so I just paid it. It's weird that the ticket is different prices in different places. I think I just got lucky to be pulled over in Euclid. The officer didn't know how much the ticket would be, but he handed me a list of municipal courts with Euclid's circled. My ticket was for a driver with no seatbelt. I had no passengers, but I have driven with people in the back of my pick-up truck without ever getting a ticket.

JoJo

#17 — June 9, 2007 @ 20:37PM — Grieving Aunt

My beautiful, full of life, funny, smart and loving 19 yr old niece died in a car accident the day before Mother's Day (May 12, 2007). She wasn't wearing a seatbelt. She was known for not wearing her seatbelt as she said it was uncomfortable. The driver was wearing his seatbelt and lived w/o injury.

A look at the Blazer shows the cab intact, but the back window broken out due to my niece flying through it backwards, first hitting it w/the back of her head and landing 35 ft from the car. All of her ribs as well as her sternum were broken in addition to multiple fractures to her head.

Thankfully, her face was spared and her mom was able to see her one last time to say goodbye - at the funeral viewing. She died on the side of a dark road. Needless to say, we all are very happy about the seatbelt law. If one person's life is spared because of this law it is worth it.

Death of a family member forever changes your life - as a parent, your life will NEVER be the same. Buckle up, there's someone in your life that loves you and will miss you forever. Do it for them if not for yourself.

#18 — June 9, 2007 @ 20:54PM — Grieving Aunt [URL]

I forgot to mention in my previous post that my niece was sitting in the front passenger seat (the cab area that wasn't dammaged), and would have not only survived the crash had she a seatbelt on, but w/no or minor injuries. Please buckle up - it may save your life.

#19 — April 16, 2008 @ 00:22AM — Brank

So, divulge to everyone what caused the accident that your niece was involved in. Was drinking involved, someone not paying attention, someone fell asleep. Not wearing her seat belt didn't kill her, whoever caused the wreck killed her.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/64216)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments