OPINION

Identity and Sports: Montreal Canadiens and Athletic Bilbao

Written by Alessandro Nicolo
Published April 17, 2007

It's soul searching time in Montreal. Nos Glorieux are out of the playoffs this year and to many this has become too much of a comfortable habit.

Many fans and journalists on the French-language side of the equation openly talk about needing more local content - specifically French-Canadian talent - on the Montreal Canadiens. Their English-speaking counterparts simply want the best available players to represent the club. The merit principle should prevail.

Such a conundrum. French Quebec does usually tend to romanticize and politicize about its hockey club. They hark back to a more pristine time when native sons entered the realm of Quebecois folklore for their dominance of the hockey universe.

From a marketing standpoint this only makes sense. From a hockey operations perspective it can make things a little sticky. There is a legitimate argument to be made to bring in more French players, but at what cost? The Canadiens' drafting machine that once allowed them free reign in the province through the territorial draft is gone. More importantly, other clubs in the NHL have been more successful at getting their hands on Quebec's best talent.

Simply put, too many factors conspire against turning the Canadiens into mini-Team Quebec a reality.

This idea of mixing culture, politics and sports is nothing new in sports. It happens in soccer all the time.

Hailing from the autonomous Basque region, Athletic Bilbao is a soccer team in Spain's top soccer league La Liga and offer interesting parallels to what Habs fans are debating.

Basques have a strange place in Spanish soccer. It has on one side contributed many great players to Spanish soccer but it has also had to share its resources with France (there is a French section on the Western side of the Pyrenees).

It is also a place with divided loyalties. While many Basques will openly say they want Spain to lose they are too invested in the success of the country - After all, their own wear the colors of Spain at international tournaments.

Quebec nationalists will also, though to smaller degrees, speak like they don't care about Team Canada choosing instead to support the Quebec players within the team. In the end, they realize that Canadian victory is a victory for Quebec as well. After all, as I said above, their sons wear the colors of Canada. It would make little sense to do otherwise.

page 1 | 2
Alessandro Nicolo is an obtuse freelance writer living in obscene obscurity.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Identity and Sports: Montreal Canadiens and Athletic Bilbao
Published: April 17, 2007
Type: Opinion
Section: Sports
Filed Under: Sports: Football (English), Sports: Hockey
Writer: Alessandro Nicolo
Alessandro Nicolo's BC Writer page
Alessandro Nicolo's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Alessandro Nicolo
Sports: Football (English)
Sports: Hockey
All Sports Articles
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — April 17, 2007 @ 07:17AM — Tuffy [URL]

The Atlanta Braves created a very strong scouting system in the 90s by concentrating their efforts on a region (Georgia and surrounding) instead of a skill or body type. Could Montreal succeed building a team with such a system or does hockey not lend itself to this approach?

#2 — April 17, 2007 @ 08:49AM — alessandro Nicolo [URL]

I know the Braves (and my former Expos who concentrated on Latin America) had the best development system and it has worked for them. I guess there are many ways to appoach this. I believe the New England Patriots consider the character of the player before joining their organization.

The Habs used to have total control over Quebec talent under the territorial draft. Since it was removed the province's best talent was scattered across the league.

The Canadiens could concentrate in Quebec mre but I'm not sure why they don't do this more effectively. They do draft many players from the Province but scouting has not been very strong. Economics plays a role also. Taxes and the currency exchange does not help. Most want to be paid in U.S. dollars. Another problem is that there may not be enough Quebec-born players anymore. Last I checked football and soccer enrollment is passing hockey.

It's tough being a Canadian team in a pro North American league.

Soccer teams like Bilbao and across Europe have strong academies and development programs explicitly attached to clubs. We don't have this in North America. It's a different system and only clubs like the Braves find their niche on their own.

Anyway, maybe I should try and study the actual development process!

#3 — April 17, 2007 @ 08:52AM — alessandro Nicolo [URL]

For the record, when I say French talent I mean Quebec talent. Oversight on my part for one small section.

#4 — April 19, 2007 @ 09:35AM — Philip Savage

I enjoyed your article but Basque nationalism (in its Eta form) is still deadly as the recent ceasefire breaking bombing at Madrid airport shows.

#5 — April 19, 2007 @ 10:18AM — alessandro Nicolo [URL]

Philip, thanks. I thought they called for a permanent cease fire.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/62644)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments