Book Review: The Show I'll Never Forget - 50 Writers Relive Their Most Memorable Concertgoing Experience - Edited by Sean Manning
Published March 02, 2007
When writing is done particularly well, one of the main things it should be able to do is transport the reader to the unique place or time that the writer is attempting to capture through their words. In this book, 50 writers are basically turned loose to do exactly that.
The writers — who range from legit (and semi-legit) rock scribes like Charles Cross and Chuck Klosterman, to musicians like Sonic Youth's Thurston Moore — offer up their most memorable concertgoing experiences. These range from obvious choices like the Beatles, Stones, and Springsteen to more obscure, but no less memorable performances from the likes of the Lounge Lizards and Einsturzende Neubauten.
What makes these stories so interesting and compelling is the broad canvas that a term like "most memorable" allows these writers to draw from. The stories here — and there are several great ones — are not always memorable for a particularly remarkable performance so much as they are for the circumstances surrounding the remembered event. The result is a great little collection of stories that are often as much humorous or even bittersweet little remembrances, as they are about the musical performances that serve as this book's common, binding thread.
Editor Sean Manning's story of an R.E.M. concert kicks the book off with a tale typical of many that follow. It begins with Manning scurrying across town on a gopher sort of errand for what is perceived to be an ungrateful boss, and ends with him joining said boss at choice seats to an R.E.M. concert. Not long after, Manning gets his first writing assignment.
In one of the book's more bittersweet stories, Dani Shapiro recalls spending her high school years in Jersey striving to be one of the "Jersey Girls" romanticized in the songs of Bruce Springsteen. She finally sees her hero at Madison Square Garden, but recalls the experience as one of "numbness," where "life was going on all around me but I just couldn't join in." A few years later, with Springsteen all but forgotten, Shapiro is asked to audition for the Brian DePalma video for Springsteen's "Dancing In The Dark," and the memories come flooding back. Shapiro gets her "Jersey Girl" dreams dashed once again, losing the part of the "dancing girl" to future Friends star Courteney Cox.
In another interesting story, Charles Cross remembers the Halloween 1991 Seattle homecoming of Nirvana — a show that I also attended — during the height of grunge-mania. My own memories of that show were of the incredible energy and pride in the air as Seattle's hometown heroes cemented their place as standard bearers for the new rock and roll. Cross however, was able to get closer to the source than I was (even though I wrote for his paper The Rocket at the time). Cross reveals here that Kurt Cobain felt that the show did not live up to his own lofty expectations, and that he was actually most concerned with the reception the opening act (which featured a former girlfriend), Bikini Kill had received.
- Book Review: The Show I'll Never Forget - 50 Writers Relive Their Most Memorable Concertgoing Experience - Edited by Sean Manning
- Published: March 02, 2007
- Type: Review
- Section: Books
- Filed Under: Music: Live Concerts, Music: Lists, Books: Nonfiction, Books: History, Books: Entertainment
- Writer: Glen Boyd
- Glen Boyd's BC Writer page
- Glen Boyd's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Thanx Gordon. I'm just pissed all the concert shirts I picked out didn't show up in the addys.
-Glen
I have two concerts that I'll never forget, both at that fabled old hall Winterland in SF. The first was The Who at their peak in '76, and the same for Springsteen, peaking in December '78. I've been trying to duplicate those experiences ever since, but like all things remembered from such a distant past, nothing will ever replace them for me...
Brad,
You can actually relive that Springsteen Winterland show through the concert stream available to listen to for free over at Wolfgang's Vault. And yes I agree that it's a great one. Thanx for the comment.
-Glen
This article has been selected for syndication to Advance.net, which is affiliated with newspapers around the United States. Nice work!


>







Nice review, Glen, well-written. You've triggered a lot of memories...