OPINION

Can a PC Guy Become a Mac Guy?

Written by Bruce Kratofil
Published February 11, 2007

My four-year old laptop is showing definite signs of strain. Even if there isn’t a physical breakdown coming soon (and at four years, it has lasted longer than any other laptop I’ve ever had), it’s having a hard time keeping up with the demands of current software. In fact, if you believe the adage that you measure computer years as dog years, it would be the equivalent of a 28-year old computer.

So it’s time for shopping, and it happens to be at the same time that Windows Vista, the newest OS from Microsoft, is available. And Vista is generating a distinct lack of enthusiasm from me, unlike some of its predecessors. Since I wrote a book about Windows 2000, I actually started using it nine months before its release; for Windows XP, it was a series of online articles at C Net and other sites, so I had it about three months early.

There were no publishing plans this time, which certainly helps lessen the enthusiasm. But in any case, the new feature set for Vista hasn’t knocked me off my feet. There’s a new look, but it’s just eye candy. Security has improved, but it still isn’t as strong as it should be, especially if you are still going to be using your old applications. Lots of the really revolutionary stuff got dropped, and the DRM restrictions are a real turn-off.

So maybe it’s time to look at a Mac.

Why, after nineteen years of using PC products (I was an Atari guy before that) would I consider a Mac? Well, it isn’t because I believe in being trendy (anyone looking at the music in my iPod, or my wardrobe, can tell you that keeping up with what's hot isn't high on my list). It’s a mix of business reasons and technology reasons.

More and more of my billable hours are coming from some sort of multimedia work, often from some location away from my office. That’s more of a strong point of a Mac, with its iLife software. Also, when I look at the user logs for the websites I design and manage, the percentage of visitors using Safari (the Mac OS X web browser) is steadily increasing. Thus I want to easily check the way my sites appear on a Mac.

page 1 | 2 | 3
Bruce Kratofil blogs on bugs and other things that can go wrong with your computer at The BugBlog, and writes about computers and economics at BJK Research
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Can a PC Guy Become a Mac Guy?
Published: February 11, 2007
Type: Opinion
Section: Sci/Tech
Filed Under: Sci/Tech: Computers, Sci/Tech: Internet, Sci/Tech: Personal Tech, Sci/Tech: Software
Writer: Bruce Kratofil
Bruce Kratofil's BC Writer page
Bruce Kratofil's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Bruce Kratofil
Sci/Tech: Computers
Sci/Tech: Internet
Sci/Tech: Personal Tech
Sci/Tech: Software
All Sci/Tech Articles
Bruce Kratofil's personal weblog
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — February 12, 2007 @ 03:16AM — Dennis Howlett [URL]

I moved to Mac after 24 years of being on PC. Never looked back. I don't even work with Microsoft files any more. I simply import to something like Zoho and share the resultant files with colleagues. Or I request clients upload and I'll take it from there.

Saves time and money. So even though the initial investment is relativley high, the payback in productivity is incredibly fast + I have the benefit of being able to use shared applications without worrying about client file usage.

One tip - buy as much memory as your machine will take. You'll appreciate the performance improvement.

#2 — February 12, 2007 @ 07:07AM — Bruce Kratofil

Thanks, Dennis.

On memory -- that's a tip that works for both Mac and PC. IMO, its more important than processor speed.

#3 — February 12, 2007 @ 07:53AM — Daniel Woolstencroft [URL]

Looking forward to the next installment Bruce.

I'd agree with Dennis in terms of memory; I ditched my last Mac recently because it's just not cost effective to upgrade, and the sorts of things I want to do - so called Power User stuff - wasn't running at an acceptable speed with 1gb of ram.

#4 — February 12, 2007 @ 10:36AM — Bill Sherman [URL]

As another PC guy who's also looking to get a new computer this year - who's been wondering about the Macs, too - I'll be following this series with much interest. Great start!

#5 — February 12, 2007 @ 10:45AM — Christopher Rose [URL]

I'm also on the verge of buying a new computer and, as I wanted to avoid the problems that can come with using the first iteration of any software, such as Vista, I checked out my mate's fairly new Mac laptop.

Frankly, I was shocked at how clunky and un-user friendly it was. Apart from it's possibly greater stability, there was nothing about it at all that was any better than my three year old PC.

There's tons of software and hardware that just isn't available for a Mac. And Safari is a rubbish browser compared to Firefox. And it was white! It looked like a cheap transistor radio.

Skeptics and cynics please note: Yes, I know it's less prone to virus attack and you can get Firefox for a Mac too. I don't work for Microsoft either!

Microsoft and Apple ought to be forced to merge and try really fucking hard to make just one computer that actually works properly...

#6 — February 12, 2007 @ 11:39AM — Bruce Kratofil

"Frankly, I was shocked at how clunky and un-user friendly it was"

I'm not an expert Mac user (for I haven't bought it yet), but in my experience of using it, it's not that it's clunky or unfriendly -- it's just different.

If you are used to moving up to the top right of the window to click close -- then it will feel somewhat awkward to move up to the left. Multiply it by lots of other common tasks that are a little bit different, and it will feel awkward.

Ultimately, what you want to be, in an OS sense, is a switch-hitter.

#7 — February 12, 2007 @ 11:50AM — Christopher Rose [URL]

Hi Bruce, I guess it's just that I was expecting so much more. After years and years of subliminally picking up the message from my arty mates about how much better Macs are, I wasn't expecting to find it so, well, the same really.

Until computers work like they do on Star Trek, my phaser is set to kill not stun!

#8 — February 12, 2007 @ 12:47PM — Howard Dratch [URL]

Good article. For me the wrong question. Can a Mac guy become a PC guy because the Macbook Pro is so expensive?

The answer is that I couldn't. Vista seemed harder and less friendly than even Panther -- I have Tiger now. I liked the prices but not the software or the machines. Only the money hurt -- enough to wait a while for more than the 1gb of memory that came with it.

Safari is better than it was by far but Firefox is much better (I use BonEcho which is Firefox optimized for Macs). Try NeoOffice freeware or OpenOffice to replace Word -- although I have never used Microsoft anything except in the store.

The disappointments are upgrading or replacing some software to Mac Universal Intel versions and my wallet.

I don't think Mac guys have a chance as PC guys which might say something. But I wait for more of your choices and articles.


#9 — February 12, 2007 @ 13:11PM — Ken Edwards [URL]

Funny story about walking into the Apple store looking like the PC guy Bruce.

Cleveland is the closest Apple Store for me too, they should build one in Toledo already.

I can't wait to read part two, and hope you get a Mac :D

I find it helps greatly to have both platforms at your disposal. I have a PC laptop I use to check my web sites on, but my main rig is a G5 tower.

#10 — February 12, 2007 @ 13:18PM — Christopher Rose [URL]

As Ken's story demonstrates, if it's necessary to have a PC and a Mac, both suck! But at least there's more stuff for a sucky PC than there is a sucky Mac.

#11 — February 12, 2007 @ 13:24PM — Bruce Kratofil

Wow, this may just become my most commented story ever, after only about 12 hours online.

But then again, talking about switching operating systems is almost like talking about religion.

Ken - it's good to see you would rather come to Cleveland to spend money instead of Detroit; maybe Eric Olsen will have another Blogcritics party and you can kill two birds with one stone.

Howard - at this point, expense is the only thing that may tip the scales to Windows

#12 — February 12, 2007 @ 13:42PM — Ken Edwards [URL]

Chris, despite your claim, I find very few applications on Windows that I cannot get on the Mac. The apps that are only for Windows are specialty apps that the developer never brought to the Mac.

I can do everything work-wise on my Mac or my PC. I just get it done a hell of a lot faster on my Mac.

Yea, I hope that EO has another party, the last one rocked! And... I don't like driving to Detroit.

I have been to the Apple Store in Columbus, but thats a drive too!

#13 — February 12, 2007 @ 15:51PM — Glenn [URL]

I recently picked up my first Mac (a MacBook Core Duo) and I'm practically sleeping with the damn thing. It's got some sort of crazy cult powers over me.

As far as MS Office goes, if this is just clients sending you their web page designs or content, and you are converting it to other formats, I'd just use one of the many web-based Office equivalents to open the documents. Zoho, Ajax13.com, Google apps, etc. Save some $ for RAM. :)

#14 — February 12, 2007 @ 22:53PM — Ken Edwards [URL]

Oh yea, Text Edit open MS Word documents. There is also OpenOffice!!

#15 — February 12, 2007 @ 23:09PM — Mark Saleski [URL]

i don't understand this "more stuff for the pc" thing. sure, in terms of titles that's true.

but list some things you can't do on the mac that you can do on the pc?

and yea, i realize this is a religous war thing, though my wife bought a mac this year and misses nothing about her pc.

#16 — February 13, 2007 @ 00:03AM — El Bicho [URL]

see, Mac guys don't know what they are doing. Saleski posted the same comment twice.

[Yikes, sorry for spoiling your punch line El B. Dupe deleted by Comments Editor]

#17 — February 13, 2007 @ 15:55PM — Bruce Kratofil

Actually, it may be cheaper to get Parallels and a copy of XP (which is probably in the clearance bins right now)

#18 — February 13, 2007 @ 16:00PM — Mark Saleski

bicho: see, Mac guys don't know what they are doing. Saleski posted the same comment twice.

i posted that from a pc, mr. smartypants.

#19 — February 13, 2007 @ 17:18PM — El Bicho [URL]

CR, the attribution and Saleski's response still get the joke across. Just be glad you didn't let Saleski go in and remove the comment himself or you would not hear the end of it. heh heh!

#20 — February 13, 2007 @ 23:16PM — Pico [URL]

A very relevant article to me, as I'm considering jumping back to the Mac (I once had a Macintosh SE until 1995). I'll be looking forward to reading more about your experiences.

#21 — February 17, 2007 @ 00:27AM — Amrita [URL]

I've been trying to resist the lure of the PC and so far the expense has stopped me. but i'm due for a new laptop pretty soon and mac ... is...calling... my ... name.

Count me in as one of those people who're going to wait and watch for your posts with interest.

#22 — February 28, 2007 @ 18:59PM — Nukapai [URL]

Thanks for the timely article (just as timely as having the MAC guy/PC guy advert coincide with the launch of Vista...).

I need a new laptop - have needed one for a long time - but haven't decided what to do yet.

Can't wait for part 2!

#23 — September 22, 2007 @ 22:44PM — Patrick Allmond [URL]

Amazing that I just discovered this useful article. I am considering the same. Even though the posting are 7 months old so far it is great information.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/59536)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments