Blogcritics Comments on Book Review: Don't Look Back - A Film and Book by D.A. Pennebaker

Comment by Steve on Book Review: Don't Look Back - A Film and Book by D.A. Pennebaker

Sun, 11 Feb 2007 13:46:51 EST

Hey, Sadi, Good to hear from you! Yes, it is difficult to say about these things re. stories about other people. Unless there is evidence I've seen to the contrary, I tend to take gossip with a pinch of salt, though even then, I tend to mind my own business, unless the gossip is about me, in which case, I would feel I have a right to know. Of course, I know virtually nothing of Dylan, so I wont even hazard an opinion on the movie as far as truthfulness goes, should I ever see it. Speaking of movies, I saw "Notes On A Scandal" with Judi Dench recently, and all I can say is, I'm glad it was just a story, very dark indeed. Amazing performances but quite disturbing. Have you seen any good movies recently, Sadi? Anyway, as it's now 8 days since your post, I'll check to see if your new List is out yet.

Comment by sadi ranson-polizzotti on Book Review: Don't Look Back - A Film and Book by D.A. Pennebaker

Sat, 3 Feb 2007 12:07:04 EST

Steve, hi! I'm sorry, i JUST saw this comment (surfing the web of all things and i found it, duh). I did hear about the film with different actors playing Dylan. I'm not sure what to make of it. It may be good. I don't know. I suppose we have to see it before really judging it in any way or knowing - it's hard. The "Edie" film is easier in some ways because Dylan himself has spoken out against it and so for this reason, then one feels okay, maybe this isn't such a great idea. Like book publishing, they are opening themselves up to liability unless they can really prove what they are saying in the film or unless they pitch it as "Fiction." As with books, you need to be clear about characters and categories. IF they made a film that resembled Dylan enough but had a disclaimer and changed enough things but implied that may or may not work, but to say this is absolutely the truth is hard. The onus is on them to provie it, and as again, with books, it's not so easy to prove such things, especially when one of the parties is no longer living. Edie, as you know, is dead, so she ain't talkin'. One could point to some of his songs and say they elliptically refer to Edie but again, a lot of people speculate on what his songs mean and if you listen to Baez in No Direction Home, then she's right - her quote about "A lot of people will be saying what these fucking songs are about... when I don't know what they're about..." (and he laughs, she says - *i paraphrase this, because I don't remember exactly what she says but you get the point). We can interpret any number of ways. That doesn't make it right. It's hard. We may be right. Sure - some more right perhaps because there is more to back it up and we can substantiate our claims and that's important and i think that's key. Nobody has a problem with that. But this whole Edie thing - i really don't know... Maybe there is enough to substantiate it. Obviously, Dylan feels quite comfortable saying there is not and feeling that nobody can prove beyond doubt that there was. Given that, I'd say he's safe. The film will be released anyway perhaps. I haven't heard the news. AS to the other, i've gone OT, apologies, it may not work. The same way i tend not to like covers of songs (though that said, i'm working on a List of the Moment that has some great covers, so i am contradicting myself here), it may work out. I'd have to see it. I'm sure I will, if for not other reason than to review it. See you List? I'm hoping for Thursday or before... keep an eye... or post here if you see... miss you. sade

Comment by Steve on Book Review: Don't Look Back - A Film and Book by D.A. Pennebaker

Sat, 20 Jan 2007 15:47:20 EST

Hey, Sadi, Have you heard about the movie coming out that supposedly has different actors playing Dylan??...can't recall where I heard about it, but it sounded like it was coming out this year. Anyway, haven't seen you at the last List Of... article since before Christmas!! Hope you had a great one. Looking forward to your next List!