Why Do College Comedians Suck?
Published December 01, 2006
Now, two things are possible. First, that these two colleges' officials were members of the PC Nazi Brigade, and they wanted to censor everything before students were exposed to it. (And yes, in both Alfred and Potsdam’s case, they are card carrying members of the brigade.)
Or it could be that this part of Tiny’s act is part of his routine to win favor with the audience. What supports this theory is that colleges today are run by conservatives and liberals who want to serve as the parents to students in the real parent’s absence, so when they are involved with student booking they are too involved and control everything, including the content you’re exposed to.
This theory is slightly better than the first one, as we’re getting closer to why the college comedian’s material might be ruined because of the college’s influence. But there are many colleges out there that let comedians say what they want, in which case…
3) There are no excuses: most college comedians suck. We’ve all seen a bad comedian before, but sometimes college students are exposed to people who should quit and become professional perverts. At least this way when they molest their audience there is some kind of penalty for it.
I’m honestly sick of hearing about how long it took to get to my school, why the school’s weather sucks, and worst of all, the bullshit public service announcements every comedian makes about how awesome life is and how you shouldn’t wrap kittens in dynamite.
I have yet to encounter a comedian that has made a comment relative to my school that would be funny during their routine. Usually we just get the standard, “Hyuck, hyuck, man, that school food sucks, what do they serve in your dining hall… crap?” This line is often followed by the comedian leaving college material behind and moving on to their boring life. Did I miss memo that said everyone had to be like Jerry Seinfeld? You’re a loser… and?
I realize a lot of the comedians are starting out on the college circuit or they are just doing the gig to collect a paycheck in between “projects”, but we need a damn good laugh these days, and some of the garbage we’re getting makes me want play with GI Joe toys and give them mental disorders that make it impossible for them to interact with each other.
It could be that all or none of these theories are correct, or the answer is somewhere in between, but when you have so much material to work with for every college campus out there (Potsdam has mutant farm animals roaming around in a cage on Route 11 for example) there is no reason to use the same tired routine and go through the motions to “entertain” us. Unless some of these comedians simply suck, in which case they shouldn't quit their day job.
- Why Do College Comedians Suck?
- Published: December 01, 2006
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Culture
- Filed Under: Culture: Arts, Culture: Education, Culture: Humor and Satire, Culture: Society
- Writer: Brandon J. Mendelson
- Brandon J. Mendelson's BC Writer page
- Brandon J. Mendelson's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Hey I do comedy at colleges, maybe I suck.
Lots of things can make a show go wrong, the over all setup of the room can have a big effect. Many stags in colleges are more for bands or public speaking and give a big warehouse feel as opposed to a tight creepy attic feel that goes good for comedy.
There is also an abundance of shitty comics working, that could be a factor also and maybe more likely.
Stand up comedy is going through a revolution, I compare it to the X games. It use to be awesome in the bmx best trick when they would do a no handed landing, now they do a back flip 360 and land with no hands. Same thing is happening to stand up, its a "comedy revolution"
get on board with the revolution,
James Uloth





Interesting. Nothing worse than being in the audience while a comedian bombs. PC Nazi's don't help as you pointed out.