Book Review: I Shouldn't Even Be Doing This! by Bob Newhart
Published October 24, 2006
Bob Newhart unbuttons his mind to offer up a wonderful memoir about his life and his amazing career in comedy. He had a seemingly average family life growing up on the west side of Chicago, graduated college, served in the military, became an accountant, yet there was a funny person trying to get out.
Newhart and his friend Ed Gallagher created comedy bits together, which they eventually sold to radio stations. Apparently, Newhart forgot what he learned in school as the venture lost them money. Gallagher had a wife and family, so the partnership ended, but Newhart persevered. He obtained minor spots on television, but nothing was happening.
He considered becoming a comedy writer and attempted to sell “The Submarine Commander” to Don Adams, who didn’t think it was his type of material, but encouraged Newhart to continue to send him other samples. Two weeks later, Adams was on The Steve Allen Show and performed part of the routine. Although he was furious at the time, Newhart was thankful for the transgression because it spurred him to perform his own material as the only way to keep other comedians from stealing it.
Newhart’s radio bits made their way to Warner Brothers Records. They thought the material would make a funny record and wanted to capture Newhart in front of a live audience, which sounded good to Newhart, but he had never performed at a nightclub before. The Button Down Mind of Bob Newhart became such a colossal hit that not only did it top the record charts, but it went on to receive the 1961 Grammy Award for Album of the Year, beating out Ray Charles and Frank Sinatra.
Newhart rose to fame at a time when comedy was transitioning from the old guard of guys in suits doing mother-in-law jokes to the new breed of stand-up comics made up of the likes of Mort Sahl, Jonathan Winters, Lenny Bruce, and May & Nichols. His success on the nightclub circuit and follow-up records opened the door for him to do television and movies.
However it wasn’t until 1972 when The Bob Newhart Show, the second to have such a name, hit the airwaves that he made his mark on the medium. He played psychologist Bob Hartley, a perfect occupation to allow Newhart’s comedic persona to shine. He accomplished the rare feat of having a second hit TV show when he returned in 1982 with Newhart, playing a do-it-yourself author who moved to Vermont to become and innkeeper. Newhart’s wife Ginny came up with the ending for the series as all being a dream of Bob's from the previous series. I am hard pressed to think of a better last episode of a television series. Newhart also discusses his other shows that weren’t as successful.
- Book Review: I Shouldn't Even Be Doing This! by Bob Newhart
- Published: October 24, 2006
- Type: Review
- Section: Books
- Filed Under: Books: Biography, Books: Entertainment, Books: Humor, Culture: Celebrity
- Writer: El Bicho
- El Bicho's BC Writer page
- El Bicho's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us




Given that I'm in my mid-fifties, it's wonderful to say that I grew up on Bob Newhart. Even before television. I'm delighted that he's sharing the contents of his mind and memory with the rest of us.