Living In Israel - Hebrew Press Distorted Misfortune to Push For Killing Immigration to Israel
Published October 06, 2006
Without that questionable lawsuit or an arrest warrant hanging over him, he could arrange to pay the cell-phone company and the other company suing him for legitimate debts. And nota bene, he does not have hospital bills.
Would running back to America help Rubin? I sincerely doubt it. He is over fifty years old, has spent half his life here, and would have lots of trouble getting work in a country he hasn't lived in for over a quarter century, a country where he would get no help adjusting. He likely has no Social Security because he did not work for "forty quarters" in the States. He left when he was twenty-six years old.
Is falling onto hard times after a quarter century any reason to leave the country? I know a fellow who was in a similar situation a couple of years ago. He had raised 13 kids here, has a grandchild or two, and was in debt up to his eyeballs. He could not get reliable transport to a job, so could not find decent work. He did get help, and thank G-d he is still here.
Let's turn now to Yediot Ahronot, the newspaper that ran this story. Why did they run it with this angle? Here we come to the painful truth of the matter, where we get to see just what kind of beast this paper and the other two major Hebrew dailies really are.
This story, with this headline and this lead paragraph, is designed to kill the basic lifeblood of this country and its raison d'être, "kibútz galuyót," the ingathering of the Jewish exiles, bringing them home to Israel after 1,800 years of wandering and persecution.
What better way to convince the Israeli (and Jewish) reading public that Israel is not a place to live than to have an immigrant (who is here for a quarter century already) in trouble condemn it in his own words? What a sickening sight: The descendants of the glorious enterprise of "settling the Land" taking a knife to their own nation's throat on its English language website.
This is news?
No, this is a tragedy.
- Living In Israel - Hebrew Press Distorted Misfortune to Push For Killing Immigration to Israel
- Published: October 06, 2006
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Culture
- Filed Under: Culture: History, Culture: Media, Culture: Religion, Culture: Society, Politics: International, Politics: Policy
- Writer: Ruvy
- Ruvy's BC Writer page
- Ruvy's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
I made two glaring errors in this story.
One is a technical one. The lawsuit in the Yediot AHronot story talks about NIS 52,000. That means that deducting the NIS 11,00 fo the two checks leaves NIS 41,000 the claimant is seeking from Rubin. Shame on me!
The second is that one remains an immigrant for the rest of his life if he remains in the country he has immigrated to (or goes to live in a different country). So Rubin, like me, will be an immigrant to the day he dies, assuming G-d willing, that he stays here and does not try to run away to America...


The writer was born in Brooklyn and lived in Minnesota for a number of years. There he managed restaurants and wrote stories. He moved with his family to Israel where they now reside. He is published by Jewish Indy, as well as by Desicritics.org.


Sounds like the Sin of the Spies all over again. Oy!