Was Benny Goodman A Doppelganger?
Published September 30, 2006
Here's a test for you. If someone says "clarinet player", what's the first name that comes to mind? I'd bet the farm — if I had a farm — that you'd answer with the name of the guy who was known as the King of Swing. But he was also someone I once considered to be my musical doppelganger, in ways that go beyond what most people would consider sane and normal.
When I first became interested in swing music and then discovered Benny Goodman, I soon realized that he and I had a
lot in common. Both born in Illinois - check. Horn-rimmed glasses - check. Both sorta big guys - check. Played clarinet - check. Played it flawlessly - well, four out of five isn't bad. Of course, Benny was born over 30 years before me so I guess we couldn't really be twins, but still. (I just thought of something else we had in common — our initials were the same, or at least they were if I go by my nickname. And by the way, look at the picture and you'll have a clue why most of my nicknames have started with "Big".)
At first I really didn't know very much about Benny's life, or the ups and downs of his career. Most of my info probably came from the movie The Benny Goodman Story, in which a lugubrious Steve Allen tried to match his fingering of the clarinet keys to Benny's dubbed playing (and it was amazing how often he failed.) As a newly-minted swing music fan I just enjoyed the music and probably bought most of the story, without giving too much thought to how accurate it was. I now know that an awful lot of it was typical Hollywood fluff, but it did have some facts too — for example, demonstrating Benny's steps toward eliminating racial barriers, and also showing how his virtuosity on the clarinet even amazed classical musicians.
- Was Benny Goodman A Doppelganger?
- Published: September 30, 2006
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Music: Instrumental, Music: Jazz
- Part of a feature: Retro Redux
- Writer: Big Geez
- Big Geez's BC Writer page
- Big Geez's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Thanks for the comments, Dude. Sounds similar to my upbringing, except in my case I choose the clarinet because my dad had played in in the school band, and we had an old nickel-plated one for me to start with. I came to my fondness for Benny later.

The Big Geez is a retiree who takes time off from trimming ear hair to write about music -- sometimes doing conventional reviews, but often just sharing his opinions about how something resonates with his memories and those of his generation. You can read more of his faux pearls of wisdom at the 

I grew up listening to my folks' 78s of Benny Goodman. I wanted to BE Benny Goodman! When I went out for band, they told me "We got all the clarinets we need, kid. Take a saxophone." I took the saxophone home for a couple of weeks, but absolutely hated it. Honk, Honk!
Benny Goodman's band was the Rolling Stones of the 30s and 40s - lurid headlines, drug busts, death, scandal, and tragedy - but something bigger than the band kept it all going.
Long live the King of Swing!