OPINION

War of Attrition: My Battle With Nextel

Written by John Guilfoil
Published July 25, 2006

In a previous post, I discussed the folly of my brand new, military specification compliant Motorola i560. I may have also ranted for a brief moment about the number of calls I drop with my Nextel service and stated that it was a contention for another article.

This is that article.

I returned from the gym today, pulled my cell phone out of a compartment of my duffle bag, and like clockwork, the phone was off. Stone dead, blank screen, off.  I turned the phone back on and was greeted by the "DO" slogan used by the walkie talkie cell phone company.

And then, poof. Off. Stone dead, blank screen, so badly wanting to throw it against a wall, off. I decided to call Nextel Care and see if I could put a stop to this and get my defective phone replaced.

The automated female voice at the other end gave me several options, including Spanish, sales, customer service, and ah yes, technical support.

On hold for about five minutes, a technical support agent finally answers and I calmly explain that I purchased an i560 from Nextel less than two months ago and that it shuts itself off by itself.

She apologized profusely and tried to explain to me that Motorola offers a warranty, but that would mean sending them my phone for repair and being without a phone for up to four days, an impossibility in my profession.

Again apologizing, she brings in another representative, this time an agent of "tele-sales." She explains to me that while Nextel stands by their hardware, Motorola warranties the phones and I would probably have to go through them.

But she wasn't 100 percent sure.

Did I mention the Nextel phone service and coverage in Boston, Connecticut, New York, Las Vegas, Denver, Orlando, Chicago, and all of southern California (some of the places I've been since I switched to Nextel) is not very good?

Somehow, the sales representative knew this, and knew that I was having problems with my service. She offered to transfer me to a third person — a customer care representative who could offer to credit my account for the dropped calls.

Well...money...

So I talk to Jack in customer care, and our conversation went something like this: "I understand your frustration sir, let me see..." BEEP!!! TRY AGAIN!"

My Nextel dropped a call, to Nextel.

So I close the phone and prepare to redial on speaker phone.

Blank screen.

Dead silence.

The phone turned itself off again.

Finally, I am able to call back after thoroughly screaming at the disconnected and turned off cellular phone. As soon as I get to the menu, BEEP.

page 1 | 2
John Guilfoil is the editor of Blast Magazine. He is the former editor and founder of The Review Center. He currently maintains the blog PRrag: All the news that's fit to spin.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
War of Attrition: My Battle With Nextel
Published: July 25, 2006
Type: Opinion
Section: Sci/Tech
Filed Under: Culture: Business and Economics, Sci/Tech: Personal Tech
Writer: John Guilfoil
John Guilfoil's BC Writer page
John Guilfoil's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by John Guilfoil
Culture: Business and Economics
Sci/Tech: Personal Tech
All Sci/Tech Articles
John Guilfoil's personal weblog
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — July 25, 2006 @ 09:34AM — Apollo [URL]

hahaha :) very hilarious John. somehow i feel connected to u (pun intended). I worked at Motorola India, Bangalore for 2 years and i think i know the guys who developed and tested ur phone :). shall i say hello to them on ur behalf.

#2 — July 25, 2006 @ 10:12AM — John Guilfoil [URL]

Oh, please give them my best regards!

#3 — July 26, 2006 @ 09:09AM — Eric [URL]

I'm sorry... but I can't find it in me to feel sorry for you. It almost seems like you wanted to get angry with them... why not stop by a store (that has the ability to replace phones) instead of calling Nextel Care over and over which already told you they couldn't do it. For an intelligent and articulate person such as yourself... that sure seems like the dumb way to do it....

#4 — July 26, 2006 @ 11:04AM — John Guilfoil [URL]

Can't do it at a store. The policies are the same, and since I purchased the phone over the phone from Nextel care, i went to the source.

#5 — July 26, 2006 @ 14:43PM — Lady Dragonfyre [URL]

John - I definitely feel for you. I decided to use my Nextel (i530) in place of a landline in order to save money.

Wanna talk about dropped calls? I lost signal THREE times while on a phone interview!

Interestingly, it never loses signal when a creditor or telemarketer is on the other end.

I find the automatic shut-offs particularly problematic. While at work, my fiancé suffered a severe Asthma attack, and went to the hospital. One of her co-workers tried to call me, but my phone shut off by itself, unbeknownst to me. I received the message several hours later when I pulled out the phone to make a call.

I certainly learned my lesson. I'm going with Verizon or Cingular when my contract is up.

#6 — July 26, 2006 @ 16:41PM — John Guilfoil [URL]

That's terrible...the i530 is supposed to be "military-strong" and it turns off by itself...
If you're suffering from dropped calls and the i530 bug, Nextel may offer you the "lowest possible price" on a new phone if you want one--of course, that means you'd have to pay money to replace what was basically a defect and not our fault.

#7 — July 26, 2006 @ 20:38PM — tc1uscg

Well John, here's a news flash. As of Feb 06. Sprint/Nextel changed policy on how they deal with "bad" phones. If they have a issue within 30 days of purchase, they MAY let you hand it over to a inhouse repair tech to fix. After the 30days, you have 2 choices. Send it back to the manufacture or activate a phone you may already have that was replaced by the junk you just purchased. Welcome to the world you and I created John. We DEMAND 100% customer service but want to pay nothing for it. Sprint/Nextel don't have to stand behind a product made by another manufacture, they just sell a phone that works (or in your case, doesn't work) on thier network. You could pay an extra 6 bucks and get the replacement insurance. Then, pluck down your deductable of $50 and walk away from the store with a new phone. Nextel has to be the worst service in the country. Maybe you will do a little homework next time you pick a carrier (and phone). Good luck. You may be looking for awhile.

#8 — July 26, 2006 @ 20:45PM — tc1uscg

Oh, forgot to mention, as I have had different carriers, Lady Dragonfly, good luck. If you really think Verizon or the others have a better way of handling your (or Johns) issue, you need to put the pipe down and go into rehab. I just came back from a week camping trip in the middle of michagan. We had people with nextels, verzon, t-moble and AL-Tel service. To my amazement, my trusty Sprint Sanyo MM7500 was the ONLY phone that worked 100% of the time, no roaming and even my EVDO features worked. During storms, everyone gathered around me to watch the radar of the approaching weax. I was amazed that the 2 verizon phones had such a problem staying up. One did roam some but for the most part, were useless. Hearing them also complain about "service" was funny since you see so many people blowing smoke and making threats about moving to other carriers when after they move, the majority wish they didn't. But to you, good luck and hope you find what your looking for. And no, I'm not a hornblower for Sprint. They work for me and since all customer sucks across the board, I get the most bang for my buck...

#9 — July 27, 2006 @ 08:53AM — Eric [URL]

I'm amazed at the "facts" people present here. Telesales does not have the same policies on replacing phones that the retail store has for starters, and the whole 30 days from the time you get your phone rant was only about 10% based on fact. I, unlike the apparent others in here, do my homework. People should definately use the company that works the best for them... but ALL companies have customers that have bad experiences. In my area its mainly Cingular that pisses people off.

Anyway, onto my point. I have Sprint (had Sprint before the merger)... but the policies are the same on phones now (in corporate markets), so I will speak to that. In the first 30 days if you just want to exchange a phone for personal preference you have to go through the sales channel you purchsed it in. Phone issues should always go to a corporate repair store because they are the ones that can REPAIR or replace the phone. After the first 30 days if you do not have the service plan on your phone, you have the option of using your MANUFACTURE'S warranty or paying a repair fee (15, 35, or 55$) depending on what "level" repair it is. In the first 30 days though MOST issues are able to be taken care of no matter if you have the service plan or not.

Call me a "Sprint Koolaid" drinker if you want, but I carry a $650 phone and have never had a problem getting it fixed or replaced. My old Cingular phone was a completely different story. Like I said, use the best company for you, but don't rant about YOUR problems. Tomorrow it will just be another person that didn't get what he/she wanted ranting about another company. They can't make everyone happy....

#10 — July 27, 2006 @ 12:32PM — John Guilfoil [URL]

If you spend $650 on a phone, it better not break...

#11 — July 29, 2006 @ 12:31PM — Eric

You would hope, but alas... thats why I have insurance...

#12 — July 31, 2006 @ 12:26PM — Mary McGuire

John, I can confirm that what you;ve described is indeed "FACT". If I didn't know better, I'd swear you wrote this stuff describing my experiences. I have, alas given up and decided to ride out the contract. I, too, purchaced over the internet, and after multiple efforts to get satifaction, I went to a Nextel store, stood in line for 20 minutes (LONG minute as I am phyically handicapped), only to be told that that they could not help me...not even politely at that. My calls get dropped 2-3 time a week.My calls to Nextel got dropped. Further, and I do not mean to come off racist, but I talked to so many folks at Nextel who could not enunciate English, about a communications problem no less, that I often hung up the phone in frustration. I believe in quality customer service. When did that become unrealistic? I will bide my time until I can get back to CIngular and never leave again.

#13 — August 3, 2006 @ 12:17PM — Lady Dragonfyre [URL]

tc1uscg: I'm actually thinking of switching over to the Sprint side. Before reading your post, I didn't know that there was any difference in their service area.

Actually, I've never had a problem with Nextel's customer service.

#14 — August 10, 2006 @ 17:33PM — Coldbeer

I had a simiar problem today. I had an i275 for just around 2 months and the earpiece quit working. I went to the store thatI purchased it from and they informed me to go to the local "warranty" store. I was informed that this is the only store in the area that can handle warranty claims. Because my phone was over the 30 day mark, I could either pay the store $35 to replace the phone or do an express service with motorola with me paying the shipping and waiting up to 5 days (this including the weekend). After about an hour in the store with the rep on the phone with motorola confirming the defect. Everything was finally covered free of charge. Other than the time I was pleased to get everything taken care of. As far as the service - no complaints.

#15 — August 22, 2006 @ 00:29AM — kevin

Add Texas and Florida to the Droped calls as well as crossed calls!!!!

#16 — September 12, 2006 @ 14:03PM — whitney

nextel is the best phone service out there. if you wanna know why your service doesnt work its becasue of the coverage area. the phone... duh you would have to send it to motorola... why because they manufacture the phone and the service agreement if you would have read it says that nextel doesnt have warrentees ... the producct manufacturer does. i love nextel and never had a problem with it and i think people should read about what they are getting into before they get into it and save them selves the trouble.

#17 — October 13, 2006 @ 08:30AM — Chris

So what was the cause of the problem with your phone? Was it easily fixed and did you have to send it off to motorola or did you just have it fixed locally?

#18 — March 4, 2007 @ 23:24PM — robert

I just left a message on the sprint/nextel site to complain about their policy of "warranty starts on the date of manufacture not the date of purchase" That's right you can actually buy a phone that is already out of warranty. And isn't anybody else tired of the long methodical verbal instrucions we must tolerate whae retrieving messages or any number of functions. The purpose of this redundant prattle is only to increase our minutes used.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/50743)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments