Soul Asylum: Three Decades of Music
Published July 20, 2006
Their career has spanned three decades and Soul Asylum has experienced many ups and downs, the most recent low being the death of founding member and bassist Karl Mueller. It's in the shadow of his passing that they are now riding the high of their recent release, The Silver Lining.
Mueller, along with Dan Murphy and Dave Pirner, started out in the '80s as the punk band Loud Fast Rules but in '84 shifted their sound as well as their name to Soul Asylum. With the release of Say What You Will Clarence…Karl Sold The Truck they began their ascent into stardom, the pinnacle being '92 release of Grave Dancers and the Grammy nominated "Runaway Train."
What follows is a look at the large collection of music that is the Soul Asylum catalog. This discography contains the recognized albums as listed on the band's website; EPs are mentioned in context and any unofficial or compilation CDs are not included.
Say What You Will Clarence…Karl Sold the Truck: The album was released in 1989 and included the 1984 EP Say What You Will…Anything Can Happen plus five tracks from what were recent recording sessions. Those tracks appeared on a separate EP Time's Incinerator (only available on cassette). Songs like "Dragging Me Down" and "Broken Glass" are prime examples of the trio's punk roots.
Made to Be Broken: This album was released in January of 1986 on the Twin/Tone label. 10,206 vinyl copies and 4,920 cassettes of this album were sold before it was reissued on CD in 1989. Currently it is out of print in the vinyl and cassette formats. It has the distinction of being the first original LP length album put out (and not a combination of EPs).
"Tied to the Tracks" and "Another World Another Day" are just two of the notable tracks from this album and they demonstrate the evolution of the band's sound. In "Another World Another Day," only 1:27 long, their sound is clearly reaching and bending from the discombobulated and erratic punk to hard rock.
While You Were Out: This album came out in November of 1986, and if you include the EP Time's Incinerator, it marked the third release for the band that year. They changed up the production, using Chris Osgood this time around. "No Man's Land" is the track you're most likely to remember from this CD, but "Miracle Mile" and "Closer to the Stars" are better examples of where the band is going melodically.
Clam Dip And Other Delights: Actually a six-song EP in the states, the album contained two additional covers on the original release in England. Foreigner's "Juke Box Hero" and Janis Joplin's "Move Over" were dropped from American release. "Chains," which is a cover from little known Minneapolis band Wad, made it onto both versions of Clam Dip And Other Delights. "P-9" is a tribute to striking meat plant workers from Austin, Minnesota (the name of their union was P-9).
- Soul Asylum: Three Decades of Music
- Published: July 20, 2006
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Music: Alternative Rock, Music: Indie Rock, Music: Punk Rock
- Part of a feature: Featured Artist
- Writer: Connie Phillips
- Connie Phillips's BC Writer page
- Connie Phillips's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
What about Candy From A Stranger? It came out in 1998.
And if you don't like "Freaks" off While You Were Out, you don't like Soul Asylum.
Phil/Jon,
You're absolutely right, Candy From A Stranger was a 1998 Soul Asylum released. I used the Discography from their official website as a model in order to keep the list to official recognized releases.
Had I used some other sources the list could have been almost twice as long.
I'm not sure why that one is not included on their website.
This is just a thought, but I believe 'Candy From A Stranger' is currently out of print. You can only get it used or as a combined import with Live At The Palais Royale, so that may be why it's not on their discography at the moment.
I'm sorry, that was probably more information than you wanted. I'm a big music collector, so I tend to get carried away sometimes.
You're absolutely right, Rebecca, and I bet it is the reason they don't include it on their discography.
It's never too much information - share away!
It's a damn shame "Candy..." is out of print. "The Game" is one of their finest moments, in my humble opinion.
Connie, thank you for all the wonderful articles on Soul Asylum this month. I'm enjoying the hell out of it.
Jon,
Though Candy is out of print it can be found through used dealers and auction sites if you keep your eyes open.
I'm glad you've enjoyed the series on Soul Asylum, I really enjoyed writing about them. They have such a full and rich history and hopefully will continue to make records for quite some time.
Except Pirner didn't write "Promises Broken". A Murphy/Perlman composition. Understandable error.









What happened to Candy From A Stranger?