REVIEW

DVD Review: Capote

Written by Ken Molay
Published June 09, 2006

There is a point late in Capote where author Truman Capote is lamenting the fact that the subjects of his book keep getting stays of execution. "It's harrowing," he says. "All I want to do is write the ending, and there's no fucking end in sight." Amen, brother. That's how I felt about the film.

In a special features clip on the DVD, the director (Bennett Miller) says he wanted a very simple film where the camera didn't take you out of the story, usually a viewpoint I completely agree with and applaud. But Miller's recipe for simplicity is simply plodding literalism and a lack of dynamism in his storytelling.

Far too many shots in this movie consist of setting the camera in place and letting it film whatever the actors happen to do. Sometimes they switch to the perspective of a cameraman holding the camera as steadily as possible and filming an actor in extreme close-up. Every so often they throw in an outdoor establishing shot with a wide view of a bleak countryside highlighting the isolated setting of a house or a prison. It's all so studied and unimaginative you could scream.

The director said in his interview that he doesn't like storyboarding or framing out how a scene will play. It shows. This is cinema of the moment, with no feel for how the pacing will play out over the course of almost two hours. Every beat of dialogue is played out slowly, methodically, deliberately. Sometimes it seems as though the actors are thinking about how they want to play the next line with each pause in delivery.

For those who don't know, Capote deals with the period in Capote's life (after having established himself as a talented short story author and scriptwriter) from the time he first sees a news story about the brutal murder of a small family in rural Kansas up to the eventual execution of the killers and the publication of In Cold Blood, Capote's novel that changed the way the world thought about literature (many claim it to be the first novelization in story form of a nonfiction subject). Along the way, we get glimpses of Capote's high-living social whirl, his friendship with Harper Lee (as she writes, publishes, and sells film rights for To Kill A Mockingbird), and a few subtle small allusions to his implied gay personal life.

We see Capote as a conflicted man who both cares about the protagonists of his novel and as a ruthless manipulator who will say anything and lie bald-facedly to get what he wants. Philip Seymour Hoffman carries the movie with his performance, as he is the focal point of every scene. He does the requisite portrayal of the outrageously flamboyant Capote with the high pitched, lisping voice and the showman's mannerisms. But I never felt like we learned a lot about Capote the man.

page 1 | 2
Ken Molay is a movie enthusiast with an active Netflix account. He reviews whatever shows up next on his rental list, which may include classics, foreign films, documentaries, or the latest Hollywood blockbuster.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
DVD Review: Capote
Published: June 09, 2006
Type: Review
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: Crime, Video: Drama
Writer: Ken Molay
Ken Molay's BC Writer page
Ken Molay's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Ken Molay
Video: Crime
Video: Drama
All Video Articles
Ken Molay's personal weblog
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — June 9, 2006 @ 18:57PM — Lisa McKay [URL]

This is an interesting take on the movie, Ken, although quite different from my own. I found it to be quite compelling and not slow-moving at all, but to each his own.

One quibble -- you mention "...a few subtle small allusions to his implied gay personal life." I didn't find Capote's orientation to be implied, nor did I think the allusions were subtle. We are shown Capote sharing his home and his life (and his bedroom) with writer Jack Dunphy, his longtime partner. Capote was openly gay (during a time when openness was not the norm), and I think the film reflected that pretty accurately.

#2 — June 9, 2006 @ 19:24PM — Howard Dratch [URL]

Thank you, I think, for the review. I was planning to sit down with Capote this week and was a bit hesitant as it could easily be made sappy, sloppy, violent or boring.

Now I am not aching to see it but nor am I refusing to. I do not think it is a reaction to your review as much as to how you picture the film -- neither here nor there.

Judging from the addition of Lisa's comment, I think I will be forced to see it in order to decide if it was worth seeing.

#3 — June 9, 2006 @ 23:22PM — Rebecca [URL]

I also found the movie extremely compelling. I added to my personal DVD collection when it came out. However, when I saw it in the theater I was already a very big Capote fan. I think the film is very much one of personal taste; some may find it compelling, others may think it drags on.

#4 — June 15, 2006 @ 19:17PM — Howard Dratch [URL]

Now that I followed the advice to see Capote and somewhat ignored the negative aspects of the review, I agree whole-heartedly plus some with Rebecca and Lisa.

I found a powerful, insightful, beautifully photographed (without which it would not have been so intense an experience) movie that left me thinking and writing. I still don't want to read In Cold Blood but I never did. The movie, however, is intense and intensely engrossing.

#5 — June 21, 2006 @ 22:41PM — Greg

A guy (Capote), a self-centered one at that, wakes up and actually develops a bit of conscience. He's drawn into something that makes no sense for him, yet fate pulls him in so that he's thoroughly emeshed in this story. It's the great clash of cultures too: east coast and midwest. Hoffman pulls it off in my opinion - showing a temporary growing up -- and illustrating the emotional core of this story in his own story. The reviewer can only see the shortfalling of this film - sadly, it's his shortfalling.

#6 — June 22, 2006 @ 01:19AM — Steve C. [URL]

I thought Capote was pretty damn good, and I don't generally like biopics. I think the 'plodding' pace is a necessity, partly because it was such a drawn-out affair and partly because the coming of conscience isn't something that happens overnight.

I'm glad to see someone giving due to Clifton Collins Jr., though. He was the best thing about the movie, and he deserves more love for it.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/48999)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments