REVIEW

TV Review: Doctor Who - "The Age Of Steel"

Written by Daniel Woolstencroft
Published June 09, 2006
page 1 | 2

cybermen2.jpgSurely the Cybermen themselves are worth seeing? No, actually, they've got their fair share of problems, too. For example, despite the fact that Lumic has invented the Cybermen, when he's inevitably "upgraded", he's still (initially) wheelchair bound. What's more, he's conveniently posted human guards on his impregnable Zeppelin control centre, to allow Mickey and Jake to get on board using a form of lethal smelling salts; some of the most astonishingly lazy writing I've ever seen.

Beyond the writing, the carefully choreographed Cybermen actually start to look quite ridiculous. cybermen1.jpgThey move in perfect formation, marching in time to stompy, badly over-dubbed mechanical beats that sound like the start to a cheesy industrial dance track — a kind of "What if Trent Reznor made Cybermen" type scenario. I found myself expecting them to leap into some sort of camp rendition of "YMCA" after a while; they just look so incredibly silly. Towards the end of the episode, a stampede of humans actually manages to knock some of the cybermen off balance, another element that looks stupid. These things are supposed to be made of steel, and yet a few squiddy humans are capable of knocking them out of the way.

I mentioned a disappointing lack of specifics with regards to the Cyberman creation process in last week's episode. This week we get lots more detail. Sadly. The terrible CGI sequence (featuring awfully rendered Cybermen) is neither scary or imaginative, and is easily the worst effect I've seen this series.

Most of the dialogue here is pretty awful too, but the award for the worst line has to be the Doctor's "You didn't 'ave to kill 'er!" Tennant isn't terribly convincing for most of this episode either. Even his long-winded monologue to Lumic feels like little more than a forced device to explain Mickey's heroic feat of hackery. Said feat is yet another moronic aspect of this episode; Mickey hammers away on a keyboard for a bit as numbers inexplicably appear on screen, then (somehow) transmits the code to Rose's mobile phone, which, as luck would have it, can use Bluetooth to communicate with the Cybermen.

And while on the subject of the Doctor: it's a bit early to start taking him out of "uniform." This Doctor's outfit is nondescript enough without confusing the issue by having him ponce about in a dinner jacket.

Top all of this off with an ending that's supposed to be tear jerking, but which actually waves goodbye to a character we're all heartily sick of, and this episode is one big failure. Had I not been burned by my hope that part two would be better than part one, I'd hope that the season finale (in which the Cybermen are supposed to make another appearance) raises the bar a bit. It couldn't get any lower. So, less "Age Of Steel" and more "Age Of Morons" really.

page 1 | 2
Daniel Woolstencroft is the brains behind Is There Food? - containing topics as diverse as zombies, Apple, technology, film, and other assorted strangeness.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
TV Review: Doctor Who - "The Age Of Steel"
Published: June 09, 2006
Type: Review
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: SF, Video: Adventure, Video: Action, Video: Television
Writer: Daniel Woolstencroft
Daniel Woolstencroft's BC Writer page
Daniel Woolstencroft's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Daniel Woolstencroft
Video: SF
Video: Adventure
Video: Action
Video: Television
All Video Articles
Daniel Woolstencroft's personal weblog
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — June 10, 2006 @ 21:54PM — Duckula

Harsh but fair!

#2 — August 21, 2006 @ 18:04PM — Ronald Brak [URL]

We only just got this episode in Australia. You might be interested in checking out this piece that I wrote BEFORE I read your review. It appears that great minds think alike:



#3 — April 15, 2007 @ 18:02PM — Peter Weaver

I think you're being a bit harsh mate. Just remember that kids watch Doctor Who aswell.

If you want really decent Doctor Who, you have to go back to the days when the stories did the talking, because the special effects were abysmal. Try tomb of the cybermen with Patrick Troughton.

The new Doctor Who is a special effects extravaganza, and its mainly aimed at kids.

#4 — April 15, 2007 @ 18:25PM — Ian Woolstencroft [URL]

I think you're wrong there.

The new series is aimed at a family (i.e. kids and adults) audience far more than old Who. Just look at the broadcast times - old Who 5.30pm on a Saturday evening, new Who 7pm (or 7.40 this week thanks to the football) that's peak family viewing time.

There are also some (humorous) sexual references in there as well that are clearly not aimed at children.

And there's nothing wrong with expecting decent writing even if the show was aimed just at kids.

#5 — May 1, 2007 @ 09:03AM — Mondas [URL]

Harsh but true.

This episode was very disappointing.

#6 — May 21, 2007 @ 11:41AM — solios [URL]

An accurate assessment, unfortunately. Pity the new season makes this episode look awesome in retrospect.

Makes me pine for the garbagebags-and-helmets cybermen. The scripts, they were better.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/49023)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments