REVIEW

Movie Review: Poseidon

Written by A. Horbal
Published May 14, 2006

Poseidon is a perfectly serviceable disaster flick, but it's remarkable only for the extent to which it's unremarkable. It holds steadfast to the same mores which defined the original Poseidon Adventure. They were already out of date then, in 1972, and I can't imagine what made Warner Bros. think that they're back in style.

There are, I suppose, "spoilers" ahead, but only if you've never seen a disaster movie before. As the passengers on a swank luxury liner count down the seconds to midnight one New Year's Eve, their ship is overwhelmed and overturned by a gigantic "rogue wave".

In a Hollywood version of an exercise in game theory's prisoner's dilemma, ten passengers decide that they're going to ignore the captain's command to stay put in the "airtight" ballroom and wait to be rescued. There's a likable gambler (Josh Lucas), an unlikable gambler (Matt Dillon), a mother-son pair (Jacinda Barrett and Jimmy Bennett), a former mayor of New York (Kurt Russell), his recently engaged daughter and her fiancé (Emmy Rossum and Mike Vogel), a stowaway (Mia Maestro), a Latino waiter (Freddie Rodriguez), and a suicidal architect (Richard Dreyfuss).

Their subsequent attempt to reach the hull of the ship and safety lends itself to a satisfying, if somewhat predictable, game of Who's Going To Die Next? The non-white characters, of course, and the drunk; and finally, in a heroic moment of self-sacrifice, the alpha male who's past his prime. This leaves two white, affluent "family units" to tell the Poseidon's tragic tale of woe. And Richard Dreyfuss, who I suppose has too much star power to be killed off.

Or perhaps it's an olive branch extended to the gay rights movement by Hollywood that last year failed to reward Brokeback Mountain with the Best Picture Oscar - we're told in passing that Dreyfuss' Richard Nelson is gay. Thank God for small favors, or too little too late? Meanwhile, they sure did "miss the boat" (!) with the burgeoning immigrant rights movement.

And so once again it's the rugged individual male dragging the women and children to safety. Just once, just once I'd like to see a female character taking matters into her own hands in one of these films instead of slowing everything down by sobbing hysterically all the way.

The effects are uninspired, but well-rendered, and Poseidon's relatively short 99-minute runtime moves at a mercifully brisk pace. But it's nothing we haven't seen before, and it's more interesting for what it doesn't do than what it does, namely, demonstrate that someone in Hollywood knows that there's a world beyond yonder hills that's changed a mite bit since the Warners rolled into town in 1918.

The author's name is Andrew Horbal. He blogs about film criticism at No More Marriages! and writes about film for Lucid Screening and PopMatters. He thanks you for your time and consideration.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Movie Review: Poseidon
Published: May 14, 2006
Type: Review
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: Adventure, Video: Drama
Writer: A. Horbal
A. Horbal's BC Writer page
A. Horbal's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by A. Horbal
Video: Adventure
Video: Drama
All Video Articles
A. Horbal's personal weblog
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — May 14, 2006 @ 13:05PM — Mark Decker [URL]

"It holds steadfast to the same mores which defined the original Poseidon Adventure. Disaster flicks were already out of date then, in 1972, and I can't imagine what made Warner Bros. think that they're back in style."

This statement betrays a complete ignorance of the disaster movie genre. It is well established that the 1972 Poseidon Adventure film was the inspiration for the disaster movie epics that blossomed in the 1970s, not some antecedent. Its success allowed films like The Towering Inferno and Earthquake to follow, among dozens of others. Saying that disaster flicks were "out of style" is categorically untrue--It was the 1972 movie that gave them life!

#2 — May 14, 2006 @ 13:11PM — A. Horbal [URL]

This is an unfortunate instance of editing. My sentence originally read:

"It holds steadfast to the same mores which defined the original Poseidon Adventure. They were already out of date then, in 1972, and I can't imagine what made Warner Bros. think that they're back in style."

It's the film's ideas that are, and were, out of date. Not the genre. I'm changing it back now...

#3 — May 14, 2006 @ 13:12PM — Victor Plenty [URL]

Ignorance of the "disaster movie genre" is a blessing.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/47716)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments