CD Review: We Shall Overcome: The Seeger Sessions - Bruce Springsteen
Published May 08, 2006
"Keep Your Eyes on the Prize" makes a particularly good choice for Springsteen. It's almost a gospel song, though more associated with political struggles than religious. Nonetheless, this song, like "O Mary Don't You Weep," channels his secular liberal religion to the verities of our most organic American spiritual music. That idea of faith and perseverance comes out so much better in these classics than some tuneless, contrived pseudo-Guthrieism.
This is some righteous church music. You needn't be a Christian or a Stalinist folk singer to take substantive spiritual nourishment from the encouragement of "Keep Your Eyes on the Prize." This one of the most beautiful and spiritually profound recordings I've heard any time recently.
I was particularly surprised by how beautiful the "Erie Canal" came out. I remember somewhat liking this tune in grade school, but I've never heard it given a serious recording. For starters, this recording makes me realize that a lot of those grade school songs were not children's music. This is SO much better as a basic melody and song than any recent Springsteen composition, and so much more natural a statement of working class sentiment than his political contrivances.
If Springsteen wants to show solidarity with the working man, this is a particularly good way to do it. This is a beautiful display of weariness and determined perseverance, the kind of things that might be the good artistic themes that he'd want to pursue in this vein. Really though, careful listening reveals that this is basically a love song to a mule - and a very moving one at that. Hey, Sal is his co-worker, companion, and protector. That sounds better than most wives.
This song even makes a banjo come out somber. That's a pretty tough trick, as per the classic Steve Martin routine. Yet in at least a couple of places on the album, notably "Keep Your Eyes on the Prize" and this "Erie Canal," the banjo cuts an unusual and artistically rewarding non-joyous tune.
Of course, the classic "John Henry" is a perfect Bruce Springsteen song, when you think about it. Again that will-to-power thing of Springsteen projects well into this tale of the working man who died with a hammer in his hand. Springsteen turns in as good a vocal performance of the song as any I've heard, but he also has a particularly sharp, well detailed arrangement. They may be credited as "violins," but this is some legitimate fiddling, among other things. The accordion solo helps set it off. I'd put this back to back with even the Johnny Cash performance.
- CD Review: We Shall Overcome: The Seeger Sessions - Bruce Springsteen
- Published: May 08, 2006
- Type: Review
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Music: Country and Americana, Music: Folk, Music: Popular and Standards, Music: Roots Rock
- Writer: Al Barger
- Al Barger's BC Writer page
- Al Barger's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Thanks, Glen. Couple of albums this good, and even I will be calling him the Boss.
Fine review. I enjoyed it. This is a little off the topic, but I just had to say that I feel Bruce really captured the essence of Sept. 11th. on the Rising and that it is a pretty damn good album.
I like it but its the one CD I can not "copy" to my Sony Minidisc player which is very frustrating.
Jeff, I've heard about this being copy controlled, though it doesn't say anything like that at the Amazon listing. I should have mentioned that in the review.
I'd recommend taking the commercial CD back to the store, and downloading from Limewire, where it is readily available. Then you can do whatever you want with it.
Go ahead, liberate a copy in the name of the proletariat. Viva la revolucion! Guantanamera!!!
this album is really overrated. bruce and crew are bombastic on this recording.
the performance doesn't do these great songs justice.
Al, you're right about Jesse James, and Springsteen in a recent concert seemed to tacitly acknowledge as much.
According to the New York Times, Springsteen prefaced his performance of the song by citing the familiar maxim from The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance: when the legend becomes fact, print the legend. It seemed to me his way of saying it's just a song and not fact.
Jesse James was a Confederate terrorist, and no man was ever more justly killed.
T.J. Stiles wrote a fine, judicious book about him a few years ago: Jesse James: Last Rebel of the Civil War.
I would tell you where my earlier review of the Stiles book is located, but Blogcritics keeps giving me the "Banned Word" mojo -- which is also why I broke this post into four parts.





Good review Al. We may just get you to the Kool-Aid bowl yet.