OPINION

My Oscar Wish List

Written by Diane Kristine
Published March 04, 2006

Sacrificing themselves to prove the motto "the rich get richer", Oscar nominees and presenters are soon to be the recipients of gift baskets designed to fulfill their every whim, including free trips, espresso machines, jewelry, and a day with boxer Joe Frazier. Well, maybe not all of them dream of that last one. I have my own list of whims I wish Oscar would fulfill for me ... but I'm not holding my breath.

Wish #1: "Supporting" versus "lead" consistency

I find it odd that Jake Gyllenhaal was nominated for supporting actor for Brokeback Mountain, when in a movie about a straight romance, either he or Heath Ledger would have been a contender as lead actress (well, not Gyllenhaal or Ledger, then, but you know what I mean). Sure, it gives them both a chance to win, but it's a little ludicrous that in the same category, you can have a co-lead as well as an actor who gets 10 minutes of screen time, like William Hurt in A History of Violence. But like the is-it-comedy-or-is-it-drama debate with the Emmys, there seems to be no good way to enforce consistency.

Wish #2: More X chromosomes

None of the five best picture nominees had a female lead at all (though you could argue the ensemble of Crash doesn't have any leads). The discussion about gender disparity in Hollywood isn't going away any time soon.

Wish #3: Respect the funny

The last thing we need is additional awards categories and the resulting additional ceremony length, but it's too bad that well-executed comedy very rarely gets recognition from the Academy, pitted against weighty themes like homophobia, racism, terrorism, and media responsibility. I'd rather replace the comedy-doesn't-get-its-due lament with the is-it-comedy-or-is-it-drama lament ...

Wish #4: The Golden Oscars/The Academy Globes

... so, I know it's not going to happen, but I'd like the Oscars and Golden Globes to marry and have an awards ceremony baby to replace them both. The Globes' DNA would provide a televised show of only the categories I care about, a culture of fun acceptance awards, and a separation of drama and comedy. The Oscar DNA would provide the prestige and not-laughable voting membership.

Wish #5: Decent ratings

Following the almost-inevitable low ratings of this year's awards show, some will point the finger at host Jon Stewart's niche appeal, forgetting the absence of a Lord of the Rings or Titanic blockbuster. He's a brave man, but I suspect he'll get comedy out of it either way.


Diane is a publications manager who's addicted to television, movies, and books and justifies her pop culture obsessions by writing about them for Blogcritics. She also runs the TV, Eh? website, a compilation of news and information about Canadian television series.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
My Oscar Wish List
Published: March 04, 2006
Type: Opinion
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: Awards Shows, Video: Film and TV Business, Video: Television
Writer: Diane Kristine
Diane Kristine's BC Writer page
Diane Kristine's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Diane Kristine
Video: Awards Shows
Video: Film and TV Business
Video: Television
All Video Articles
Diane Kristine's personal weblog
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — March 5, 2006 @ 04:48AM — Sterfish [URL]

I pretty much agree with everything you put. The whole supporting versus lead thing kind of irked me when Jamie Foxx was nominated for supporting actor for Collateral.

I'd change wish #3 to "Respect the genres." Frankly, the Academy awards don't like to nominate comedies, sci-fi/fantasy, horror, or action regardless of the quality. I really hate the assumption that a dramatic performance is automatically better(or more difficult) than a great comedic performance.

#2 — March 5, 2006 @ 15:03PM — Diane Kristine

You're right, Sterfish, about the Academy unfairly snubbing genre films. I don't have an easy answer to that - it's true in the Emmys too, where a show like Battlestar Galactica isn't likely to get many nominations. I do like the Globes' division of drama and comedy/musical, though of course it's far from a perfect system either.

Even though I thought the wrong film of the trilogy ended up winning Best Picture, I was happy the Lord of the Rings was an Oscar mainstay, since they're not the kind of movies they usually recognize. Baby steps, I guess.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/44456)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments