Oprah Winfrey Stands By James Frey On Larry King Live
Published January 12, 2006
James Frey's book A Million Little Pieces was the No. 1 best-selling non-fiction book of 2005, beating out The World Is Flat, Freakonomics, and The Daily Show. He received a boost when Oprah Winfrey, doyenne of daytime talk shows, had him on her show and recommended his book, saying it kept her awake two nights in a row. The book and the author were the center of controversy and ridicule recently, when the Smoking Gun website exposed the lies at the heart of the tale of a man gone bad, and then redeemed.
Larry King hosted James Frey on his show last night to justify/explain his book and it's placement as non-fiction.
The fact that Oprah Winfrey stood by the wily Milli Vanilli-shifty James Frey on Larry King Live cost her some credibility.
It is kind of hard to believe that Oprah was just sitting at home in her jammies, flipping channels and saw James on Larry King and decided to pick up the phone like the rest of us and give her royal statement.
I felt like throwing up either at her naiveté or at her obvious attempt at trying to cover up the fact that she had been duped.
The book, A Million Little Pieces, was sold as non-fiction, which would mean it was an autobiography, but later when James got burned by The Smoking Gun he called his book a "memoir."
I was under the impression that the word "memoir" was just another classy word for autobiography. Larry asked him the same thing, to which James replied that the interpretation depends upon "individual perception" and it was a story that spanned fifteen to twenty years of his life.
Here is the meaning of memoir, according to dictionary.com:
1. An account of the personal experiences of an author.Did James' perception of the word "memoir" mean a rough sketch of his life with some facts smudged by alcohol and drugs?
2. An autobiography. Often used in the plural.
3. A biography or biographical sketch.
4. A report, especially on a scientific or scholarly topic.
5. The report of the proceedings of a learned society.
Does he really expect sympathy from us when he explained that he was merely being creative about his experiences? Or as he put it, "a cut on his cheek became a gash," should be seen in the same vein as a traffic violation of having a beer bottle jammed near the driving seat to being held in possession of drugs?
Diehard Oprah fans may stand by this shifty fellow but he is just another con artist who took the Diva and her brood on a spin.
And, like a boy who had done something naughty at school, he tagged his mother along to vouch for him.
The whole interview was a fiasco we could have done without. It was an attempt made by a con artist to clear his name and he dug his literary grave deeper.
Frey has betrayed our faith in autobiographies. Now when we venture into bookstores we would look at "memoirs" with suspicious eyes or think of them as "compressed memories" as put by Oprah, which are either exaggerated or a whole lot of bullshit.
Memo to Ms. Winfrey: Perhaps the saying, "Fool me once shame on you; fool me twice shame on me" should ring a bell.
- Oprah Winfrey Stands By James Frey On Larry King Live
- Published: January 12, 2006
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Books
- Filed Under: Books: Biography, Books: Crime, Books: Nonfiction
- Writer: Deepti Lamba
- Deepti Lamba's BC Writer page
- Deepti Lamba's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Oh I think they care. But I don't think this is going to really have any long-term repercussions for anyone.
Good piece,SP.
I'm writing up my on take - a satire piece.
Meanwhile this piece, pointing out how Dave Eggers dealt with this type of issue in his great book, is the best I've read on the matter.
Thanks Scott, I had a friend back in Dallas who used to ghost write for celebs and politicians - James Frey will raise few eyebrows in the publishing world
Here's the direct link to my satire piece
Well expressed. Actually, that would make a good truth-in-advertising category for book stores to cover all bases:
Memoirs/Compressed Memories/Bullshit
An update of sorts as Elie Wiesel is the latest to play the Oprah reading game
I have just finished the book by James Frey, and clicked onto the net to find all this uproar going on that i knew nothing about. I feel taken in conned and ripped off emotionally ( not to mention financially) and lost some faith in autobiographies generally. It has on another level been of great help to me. I have been plauged by the huge obligation to write my own autobiography, and now understand how important it is to be as honest as possible. If there is anyone out there who would be interested in aiding and publishing a story that would leave Frey himself awed, by a non- writer ( i dont need fame as an author, i just have to write this for any benefit it may have to mankind) honestly Oprah , then please contact me, because im not sure where to start. Thank Elizabeth.







I don't think Oprah's core audience cares - from the call-ins to Larry King, they are more carried away by the iconic status of the author than the facts