REVIEW

DVD Review: The God Who Wasn't There

Written by Scott C. Smith
Published December 22, 2005
page 1 | 2 | 3

Flemming eventually gets to the point in discussing the timeline of when Jesus was to have lived and the writing of the books of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. Most biblical scholars agree that Mark is the oldest of the four, written approximately 40 years after the life and death of Jesus (as it makes reference to the destruction of the second temple in the year 70 C.E.). The earliest writings were the letters of Paul, and as Flemming notes, in Paul's writings there is no mention of the miracles Jesus performed, no mention of the parables, really no mention at all of a living Jesus.

Finally, at the 15-minute mark, the interviews begin. Flemming has assembled a very small group of people as experts, who do offer an interesting look at the writing of the bible and the early days of the Christian church. Flemming interviews historian Richard Carrier; the late Alan Dundes, professor of folklore and anthropology at UC Berkeley; Dr. Robert M. Price, professor of theology at the Johnnie Coleman Theological seminary; authors Sam Harris and Richard Carrier; and Barbara and David Mikkelson of the Urban Legend Reference Pages (Snopes.com). And while almost all of these folks raise some thought-provoking insights into the early formation of the Christian religion. Especially interesting is a comparison of the Jesus mythos to the stories of the Pagan man gods Osiris and Dionysus, both of whom were born, lived, and died in almost the exact same way Jesus did.

The downside to the interviews is that, of everyone interviewed, only one has a graduate degree in theology, while the other has a PhD in folklore. The rest may be educated, but not in biblical history. I would have liked to have seen interviews with more theologians and biblical historians. Those interviews would have added much more credibility to the production.

Flemming's narrative is all over the place. After about 10 minutes of interviews with the folks listed above, Flemming switches gears to discuss Mel Gibson's film, The Passion of the Christ, and its seemingly unending violence (Flemming breaks down all of the violence and gore scene-by-scene). Flemming notes that films like Jesus Christ, Superstar and Martin Scorsese's The Last Temptation of Christ pulled in small numbers at the box office, while Passion earned over $300 million dollars. I'm not sure what Gibson's film has to do with discussing whether or not Jeus really lived.

The interviews resume at the 30-minute mark (briefly) before Flemming tries to connect Christianity to the torture at Abu Ghraib. Again, another pointless diversion.

page 1 | 2 | 3
Scott C. Smith is a freelance writer from Hillsboro, Oregon, returning from a two-year-long break to resume writing for Blogcritics. He is best known for his rabble-rousing web site, What's In Scott's Head, and his political columns at Counterbias.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
DVD Review: The God Who Wasn't There
Published: December 22, 2005
Type: Review
Section: Video
Filed Under: Culture: Religion, Video: Documentary
Writer: Scott C. Smith
Scott C. Smith's BC Writer page
Scott C. Smith's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Scott C. Smith
Culture: Religion
Video: Documentary
All Video Articles
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — December 22, 2005 @ 16:36PM — Rodney Welch [URL]

It certainly wasn't religion that killed the Waco kids. It was Janet Reno.

#2 — December 22, 2005 @ 17:32PM — Phillip Winn [URL]

Brian Flemming's gift is in marketing, not necessarily staying on-topic. In fact, there is historical evidence for the existence of a man named Jesus who attracted some followers and was later put to death for insurrection, though whether He was God is unprovable almost by definition.

The dates of the various pieces of the New Testament are hotly disputed, and have ever been, but it is easy to find people who can argue for dates for all four gospel accounts (in some form or another) prior to 70AD, predating even Paul's epistles.

#3 — December 22, 2005 @ 18:37PM — Guppusmaximus

This guy is ridiculous... Belief in Christ as the Son of God is just that, a belief. Faith based as it may be, The historical evidence of Jesus Christ points to the accuracy of the New Testament. You don't have believe in anything if you don't want to, but this guy should quit his hate filled propaganda against a group of people that did him no harm. It sounds like he was a troubled child and now has resentments about his lost childhood...Oh well!

#4 — December 22, 2005 @ 19:33PM — Christopher Rose [URL]

Guppus: Or he could just be trying to figure out what's going on. I don't really see it as propaganda to educate ourselves as best we can about issues as fundamental as the nature of Jesus or the existence of god(s).

It's one thing to argue that Jesus was the son of this god being but what I still don't understand, and nobody seems willing to take on the task of dealing with, is the bottom line: the very nature of god and the religions that this extraordinary creature has inspired.

As I understand it, the idea is that about a little over 2000 years ago some alien being not of this earth, who had already been hanging around here on Earth for at least another 3500 years before that (is that right, Ruvy?) somehow had a son through non-contact sex with a married earth woman and this special child did some fantastical stuff that's inspired a lot of people through all the ages since.

Heady stuff.

#5 — December 27, 2005 @ 09:58AM — Celebrant

Personally, I liked Flemming's work. I thought he did a good job of keeping the viewer's interest, instead of getting pedantic. I would highly recommend it to anyone--especially people who never question their own "faith."

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/41350)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments