Review: Jack's Mannequin, Everything in Transit
Published September 28, 2005
A few frightening phrases which could be used to accurately describe Everything in Transit:
1. "Something Corporate side project"
2. "features Tommy Lee"
3. "emo-pop concept album"
Thankfully, it ain't that bad. In fact, it's pretty solid, which makes for a pleasant surprise; as the voice of Something Corporate, Andrew McMahon's keening whine can be difficult to take in large doses. But here's the difference: Where Something Corporate makes a show of being a pop-punk band (think music for people who think A New Found Glory is too loud), McMahon abandons all such pretenses here, and in the process, plays more directly to his strengths as a singer and a songwriter.
Yeah, there's the typical "emo" bullshit — heart-on-sleeve lyrics, taken to the extreme; high-pitched screaming; giant heaps of melodrama — but McMahon's a really talented songwriter, and his way with sticky pop hooks elevates the material above the fray. More than anything, it's just a really enjoyable pop album, heavy on bright, tasteful piano and ringing guitars.
I read a lot of Ben Folds comparisons, but I think that has more to do with the fact that both McMahon and Folds play the piano than any similarities between their music. Folds is a pop classicist whose eclecticism and gift for wandering narrative hearkens back to the Brill Building, as filtered through an Elton John/Billy Joel lens. McMahon, on the other hand, is all first-person stories about windswept loves and rain-soaked goodbyes — if he'd been born a few decades earlier, he'd be Stephen Bishop.
That isn't so bad — and hey, "On and On" is still a pretty great song — but for the second time in two weeks, I find myself marveling at how a genre that goes by one name (in this case, "emo-pop") is really nothing more than a slightly scuffed-up replica of something else that everybody claims to hate (in this case, '70s MOR mellow gold). Also, if Andrew McMahon = Stephen Bishop, does that mean Death Cab for Cutie = Air Supply?
Well. This space isn't really built for answering such huge, important questions. Regardless, you could do a lot worse than these songs.
- Review: Jack's Mannequin, Everything in Transit
- Published: September 28, 2005
- Type: Review
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Music: Pop
- Writer: Jefito
- Jefito's BC Writer page
- Jefito's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
love the songs..its been my escape from everything..i feel happy whenever i hear all the songs in the jack's mannequin album..its real..
My name is Kristen and I love Jack's Mannequin. This CD is incredible. Everyone should buy it because no song sounds the same. Each song is amazing in it's own way.





Oh man!! this is a way good CD....i love it a whooole lot! the lyrics are great and you can tell that they really mean something to the band...and it really translates into everyday life for people like me...i really really love it!! oh man....my favorite song....DARK BLUE or LA LA LIE....THE MIXED TAPE IS WAY GOOD....KILL THE MESSENGER...i mean WOW....RESCUED...there are way too many to choose from!! :) love it!!