REVIEW

Book Review: Distant Neighbors

Written by Howard Dratch
Published August 07, 2005

America sits powerfully now from sea to shining sea. There is a whole continent washed by both oceans carved out of the lands of native Americans, Mexicans, and anyone else who was not white enough to be coopted or Black enough to be enslaved.

To the south is Mexico. They are our closest neighbors except for Canada. Both share lengthy, contiguous borders with us. But, unlike Canada with whom we bicker now that we can no longer atttack it 18th c style, Mexico is part of a wholly alien culture. It is not America or Canada with a Spanish accent. It is a unique and sovereign country with a totally unique culture even for Central and South America.

It did not share our history of English Common Law nor the American ideal (never met) of democracy and the Rights of Man. It was at one and the same time European, Spanish colonial; multiple, mixed indigenous tribes that had shared ancient civilizations of much mystery (still) and of beautiful cities and advanced scientific and mathematical sciences. The Mayans and Aztecs are the best known although they were and are not the only indigenous groups of Mexico.

This is a complex sovereignty and a unique country that may or may not ever be understood by the English speaking countries. The USA is at the top of that list. The gap of deep understanding between the two is closer to an abyss.

As a stranger in a strange land, living here but still an American; I cannot comment on Mexican politics nor any negative aspects of the culture — it is my adopted land for now. Therefore I present a short review of a good, long book on the subject.

Read Alan Riding's book, Distant Neighbors: A Portrait of the Mexicans. It is composed of his thoughts and observations-- and they are insightful — from his years here as a New York Times correspondent. He wrote the book after leaving Mexico.

He wrote of history (America's Conquest that we called "Manifest Destiny" was so different from Mexico's strange domination by a small band of Spanish conquistadores). They came as gods and found a civilization that thought they were. They enslaved and burned books and knowledge and tried to destroy all the old religions. Instead they made one of the most successful societies of mixed ancestry in the western hemisphere (and perhaps the eastern).

Riding also writes of politics from the viewpoint of a knowledgeable foreign correspondent. He presents a complex story of interlocking parties and battles in a way that the myriad political parties can be almost understood. He presents a picture of the way the political society works that is now being changed but is ingrained in the culture.

Best, I think, is that he tries to explain the culture of a complex society in a way that an American can grasp. That is not an easy chore.

Today, more than ever, America must understand the forces of nationhood, pride, honor and desires of the nations of a shrinking world and especially those of our two closest neighbors.

I leave Canada to American expatriates there and Canadians to explain. I once listened to the CBC on shortwave about a battle memorial where a great defense was made against the invaders. It took quite a time before I realized that the invaders were us.

Howard writes on science, books, movies and news for Blogcritics and on his own blogs from the border of North and Central America.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Book Review: Distant Neighbors
Published: August 07, 2005
Type: Review
Section: Books
Filed Under: Video: Classics, Culture: Society, Books: Travel, Books: Politics and Affairs, Books: Nonfiction, Books: History
Writer: Howard Dratch
Howard Dratch's BC Writer page
Howard Dratch's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Howard Dratch
Video: Classics
Culture: Society
Books: Travel
Books: Politics and Affairs
Books: Nonfiction
Books: History
All Books Articles
All Review articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — August 8, 2005 @ 07:22AM — Victor Lana [URL]

Good points made here about the "other" country that shares the continent with Canada and the US. It sometimes seems that Americans (and aren't all three countries part of North America and thus all their citizens Americans?) are divided by borders, and it would do us all well to make some sort of effort to understand and relate.

I don't think the problem is so much to the south of the border as it is right here. Instead of trying to seal up everything from the Pacific to the Gulf of Mexico, we should be promoting a new relationship, sort of like what the EU has done.

I know people are worried about terrorism and all, but there is more to it than that. Good fences don't make good neighbors; they only make people alienated.

#2 — August 8, 2005 @ 09:41AM — Phillip Winn [URL]

The EU is trying to keep Turkey out for many of the same reasons people here would want to keep Mexico out of any EU-like arrangement here in North America. It would not be perceived as a union of equals, or even close-to-equals.

I grew up in SoCal, and so have a different view of Mexico that I suppose northerners do.

I'm very interested in reading this book now.

#3 — August 9, 2005 @ 00:10AM — alpha [URL]

It is amazing how easy it is to agree with both of you.

Victor Lana writes of alienation. We are certainly in the midst of that. It is also true that we are educated to understand Anglo-American culture, law and history. The history and culture of our other neighbor south of the border is totally ignored.

I am afraid to admit that there is not only America as the world power in that equation; but more of the ignorance of any culture that has been made by "people of color". We are awfully good at that in the US.

Phillip Winn writes that he is a from "SoCal" and therefore feels differently.
He is concerned with a tripartite continent where one country is not equal to the others and, like Turkey and the EU; not ready to hold up its end of the stick.

True. Mexico did not progress as the two other countries did for a number of reasons that Alan Riding writes of far better than I could. I live here and am bound by laws for resident foreigners.

My review was a suggestion to read a passionate but multi-faceted view of the dichotomies of a society so different in history, temperament, culture, and feelings than ours.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/33801)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments