OPINION

Grand Theft Auto Given Adults Only Rating

Written by Matt Paprocki
Published July 21, 2005

Is it over?. Will the critics finally back off? What does the AO rating mean for future Grand Theft Auto entries? What does it mean for games in general?

Simply put, no one knows.

It's been an odd, long, frustrating scenario to follow, as the Hot Coffee mod slowly made its way around the internet. There are absurdities here, notably that blowing police away with a shotgun is more acceptable than a one-minute sex scene involving people who don't even use the necessary parts. It's probably been the most overblown incident since the always popular Janet Jackson Super Bowl mishap.

What's most aggravating is Rockstar's stance, claiming the mod is not on the game disc, and having the games developer, Take Two, fully admitting it days later. That's their fault, and they deserve some form of punishment, simply for being stupid. Not for leaving the code on the disc (it happens all the time, just maybe not in this way), but for blatantly lying about something and causing the industry to be burdened by uninformed people who wish to do nothing but bash the title.

There are, of course, positives here as well. Developers may be more inclined to create content suitable for an AO rating, but its up to mass retailers to stock these titles. If they're willing to carry unrated DVDs with content not suitable for theaters, there's no reason they should be afraid of carrying video games like this.

There will also be much rejoicing by critics like the PTC, Joe Liberman, and Hillary Clinton. They'll claim they were successful, but truth be told, they accomplished nothing. The game has sold over five million copies. The few re-stickered titles with the AO label will slowly trickle out with no one interested left to buy them. Copies will sky rocket on eBay as people who are easily misled start paying triple digits for the "Hot Coffee" version of the game. Those parents who don't care still won't.

Now the battle will change. Instead of pouncing on the industry with "Game rating system doesn't work," their tone changes to "Porn in video games legal to sell your children." They've backed an industry into the wall, and they won't stop until the issue finally dies and they're re-elected.

People need to be educated, and if they truly cared, they would go out of their way to educate parents these games are out there (of course, if they don't know by now, they have issues of their own). Blaming voters, however, doesn't win elections, and that's the only thing they ever truly cared about in the first place.

Matt Paprocki is the former reviews editor for Digital Press, a video game website with an appreciation for the retro side of the industry. The deep game collection which spans nearly 30 systems and 2,000 games line his walls for research purposes. Matt strives to bring credibility to video game journalism, and take it in a new direction to aid the industry in becoming respected with all forms entertainment media. He currently freelances for GameArgus.com and MultiPlayerGames.com.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Grand Theft Auto Given Adults Only Rating
Published: July 21, 2005
Type: Opinion
Section: Gaming
Writer: Matt Paprocki
Matt Paprocki's BC Writer page
Matt Paprocki's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Matt Paprocki
All Gaming Articles
All Opinion articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — July 21, 2005 @ 00:54AM — Sterfish [URL]

I'm just at a loss for words at how ridiculous all of this is and how far it went. I think this case is worse than the Janet Jackson debacle. Janet's incident happened during something that was supposed to be relatively harmless and family-friendly. This rating change was made to a product that already had a rating for mature audiences. That's like an R-rated film suddenly being rated NC-17 after it already went into theaters.

If anything positive comes out of this is that it might open up the idea of legitimate adult entertainment, entertainment that isn't pornography. GTA games are consistently popular and if the next title gets an AO rating as well then those outlets that do sell AO games could end up benefitting so much that some stores may change their tune.

#2 — July 21, 2005 @ 01:14AM — Tan The Man [URL]

Man... I don't think there was any criticism over the Playboy Mansion game... was there?

#3 — July 21, 2005 @ 01:58AM — freeza

i like gta3! this seems dumb!

#4 — July 21, 2005 @ 13:18PM — Ken Edwards [URL]

And you clearly have sex in Playboy Mansion. And it is more of the story then the girlfriend system in San Andreas.

#5 — July 21, 2005 @ 13:51PM — Danny Monty

Also, I find it odd that there weren't complains for a while about "The Guy Game" which had actual human female breasts" rather than the "pixelated realistic bodies" having sex. It took the fact that there was a topless 17 yr old to get people mildly upset about the Guy game and even still, there is no "mass outcry" against it.

#6 — July 25, 2005 @ 19:28PM — Kris

This is regulation at its worst. From what I understand the scene that people are so worried about requires a downloadable patch to reach which may mean it only exists in the PC version of the game (I could be wrong). But that's beside the point. The ESRB is basically giving GTA a porn-level raiting as a tactic to try an hurt sales of the game because it forces retailers to remove it from their shelves. This is under-handed and if internet porn can be protected by free speech legislation this game certainly should be able to as well.

Bottom Line: Parents, be parents and if you don't want your kid playing a game made for adults-DON'T BUY IT FOR THEM! Read up on titles before you let them play and help us keep the government out of this.

#7 — July 25, 2005 @ 19:33PM — Matt Paprocki [URL]

No one is forcing stores to remove it. They are doing so voluntarily. EB is still carrying it, albeit behind their counter. It will be re-released later this year with a M rating and the offending code completely removed.

The scene is accesible in all versions.

And why would the ESRB want to hurt sales? That makes no sense.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/32905)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments