Jump to: main content, Blogcritics Home
Blogcritics.org
A sinister cabal of superior bloggers on music, books, film, popular culture, technology, and politics.

Search


SAVE TIME AND MONEY! Blogcritics is your BUYER'S GUIDE. Follow the AMAZON links!
Buy Now!
Buy Now!

Music Blog Network

Top Posters

Most prolific Blogcritics for June
Chris Beaumont (50)
Mayra Calvani (41)
The Masked Movie Snobs (34)
David Bowling (33)
Richard Marcus (30)
Jordan Richardson (29)
Josh Lasser (26)
Mel Odom (21)
Katie McNeill (18)
Blake Matthews (17)

[Leaderboard]

Show your love:
Blogcritics: news and reviews

Blogcritics: news and reviews
Blogcritics: news and reviews
Link to Blogcritics!

« CD Review: The Understanding by Röyksopp || Home ||
Opinion

Pseudo-messianic Live8 celebrities

Posted by Al Barger on July 05, 2005 03:22 AM (See all posts by Al Barger)
Filed under: Culture, Culture/Tech: Media, Music: Video, Politics: World, Video: Music, Video: Performing Arts - Scroll down to read comments on this story and/or add one of your own.

Ugh, but this Live8 nonsense turns my stomach. The cheap egotism and particularly the delusions of grandeur among the participants really make me want to give these people a good old fashioned attitude adjustment up side the head.

This event had little or nothing to do with helping out poor people, and everything to do with pop singers wanting to think that they are powerful historical figures with messianic powers.

Bob Geldof to the G8 leaders: "Now feel the force of the gale that's hit you."

Look at this photo of Geldof.

He looks like he thinks he's Jesus and Malcolm X all rolled into one.

Riiiiiight. They put on a show, much like Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland in the old movies- except that they didn't think that a little song and dance made them Christ figures.

That would be as opposed to, say, Chris Martin of Coldplay. Coldplay's Chris Martin announced from the London stage, "[This is] the greatest thing that's ever been organized in the history of the world."

As a student of Nietzche and Ayn Rand, I'm all in favor of egoism. You should earn it honestly, though. As Nietzche might say, it makes me sick to my stomach to watch these people lying to themselves and making these big public displays of cheap self-glorification.

Bob Geldof, for example, is a fairly accomplished songwriter, and has to his credit at least one modern standard, "I Don't Like Mondays." That's an outstanding and also a famous song. There's pretty fair honor and bragging rights in that.

But no, that's not good enough. He has to convince himself that he's some kind of prince among men. He's leading a people's uprising against the evil corporations. "Now feel the force of the gale that's hit you."

In fact, he organized a concert. He's a concert promoter. Giving him maximum credit, he has made a fairly impressive technical achievement simply by getting all these things executed simultaneously across multiple stages on multiple continents. That seems to show some impressive managerial skills.

But that still does not make him Jesus returned. Nor does it justify this cheesy statement he made in a letter to British newspapers in which he presumes to speak for the world: "Everyone taking part in these concerts is there because the many generations watching will not tolerate the further pain of the poor while we have the means to prevent it. We will not applaud half-measures, or politics as usual. This must be a historic breakthrough. Do not disappoint us. Do not betray the desires of billions and the hopes of the poorest of our world." In my best imitation of the Church Lady, I say "Well, we like ourselves, don't we Mr Geldof?"

In short, these peole are just stroking themselves off in public. Being a more modest person, I think masturbation should be a private thing. Call me old fashioned if you will. Stuff like this leaves me feeling vaguely embarassed just for being a fan of pop music.

Speaking truth to deludees of grandeur, Noel Gallagher of Oasis said:

"Correct me if I am wrong, but are they hoping that one of these guys from the G8 is going to see Annie Lennox singing 'Sweet Dreams' and think 'f**k me, she might have a point there'?"

"Or Keane doing 'Somewhere Only We Know' and some Japanese businessman looks at him and says 'we should really drop that debt, you know'?"

"It isn't going to happen is it?"


More fine reading at Blogcritics.org. Scroll down to read comments on this story and/or add one of your own. Support Blogcritics.org by shopping at Amazon.com from this page.


Posted by Al Barger on July 05, 2005 03:22 AM (See all posts by Al Barger)
Filed under: Culture, Culture/Tech: Media, Music: Video, Politics: World, Video: Music, Video: Performing Arts

Comment on this post and/or leave a message for the author here.

Post a comment

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/32035/)

[ Please read the Official Comment Policy.]

Name:


Email Address:

(The email address will be displayed using special encoding for spam-protection, and is not displayed at all if an URL is supplied.)

URL:


Comments:


Remember info?



Syndicate Blogcritics.org

RSS
Add to My Yahoo!

Open threads on:
Music, Video/Film/TV, Books/Magazines, Culture/Technology, and Politics



[Leaderboard]

Music
Podcasts
TV/Film
Sports
Culture
Politics
Sci/Tech
Books
Gaming

SEND PRESS RELEASES, REVIEW MATERIAL, ADVERTISE ON BLOGCRITICS


MusicStack
Starpolish

BLOGCRITICS INTERVIEWS:
NEW: Jennifer Ehle
Joan Saberhagen
Doktor Goulfinger
Benny Andersson
Jeremy Robinson
Mark Kendrick
Steve McCardell
Adam Goldberg
Joanne Hall
R.K. Milholland
Craig Womack
Deana Hoover
Harry Reems
Susie Suh
Reverend Run
Charlie Reid
Hanson
Mark Curtis
Kate Mulgrew
Justin Murphy
Mark Treitel
Moe Berg
Kathryn Lively
Ian "Knox" Carnochan
B.J. Bourg
Ashok Banker, part 2
Brendon Lindsey
Seun Kuti
Jeffrey Keenan
Marshall Blonstein
Tom Kratman
Eric Olsen with Eric Berlin part 2
Mark Bryan
Kiersten Grey
Eric Berlin and Duke de Mondo
Rob Aston
Danielle Ackley McPhail
Perry Serpa
Sue Ziehler
P. June Diehl
Reese Lloyd
Michael Timmins
Ruby Dee
Brian Wenger - Scientologist
Jonathan Moeller
Dave Freer
Jim McGuinn
Max Overton
Tim Forbrook
Eric Olsen with Eric Berlin pt 1
Vicki M. Taylor
Rusten Currie
Don Mancini
Donna Sunblad
mpho and pals on music, pt 2, pt 3, pt 4
Ryan Escolopio of Wakefield
Dorice Nelson
Cary Tennis
Lisa Seung
Sharon L. Connons
Davie Allan
Jenna S. Smith
Carol Cornwell
John McNally
Kit Ehrman
John Malm ('93)
Phenomenal Fleeners
James Longley
Teel James Glenn
Lance Anderson
Don Hurst
Eric Flint
Nadine R. Carter
Opiate For the Masses
Memphis Bleek
Reza Aslan
Ash's Tim Wheeler
Jane Goodall
Temple Stark, pt 2
Michael Geoghegan, pt 2
Robert B. Parker, pt 2, pt 3
Michael Z. Williamson
Tom Verlaine
Daniel J. Flynn
"Mr P" - young Bush administration operative
Motorhead's Lemmy
Seed of Chucky Director Don Mancini
Gregg Hurwitz
Frank Marino
Hans Koning
Relient K
Eric Olsen
Tom Wolfe
The Golden Republic
Guy Kawasaki
Nicolas Cage
Beyond Indigo's Kelly Baltzell
Ginger of the Wildhearts
Raspberries
Douglas Rushkoff
Tim Catz of Antler
Incredibles director and producer
Joe and Phil Nicolo
Kevin Shirley
Chimaira, Machine Head, Trivium
Pete Trewavas of Marillion
Sascha Konietzko ('04)
Johnny Clarke
Joseph Hill
Dan Oliver
Sonic Youth
Katie Melua
Korean director Kim Ki-duk
James Lowe of the Electric Prunes
Toby Morrell of Emery
Travis Morrison
Mickey Bozinovich
Lycia
Christopher Deliso
Clayton Teague
Jason Priestley
Sonny Landreth
Emmylou Harris
Mark Anderson
Henry Kisor
Stephen Unwin
Me'shell Ndegeocello
Greg Ginn
Mike Watt
Paul Barker
Chris Muir
Andrew Sullivan
Jeremy Pelt
Sascha Konietzko ('98)
Brock Clarke
Jay Nussbaum
Mau Mau Sex Sex producers
Richard Brookhiser
Peter Tosh
William Tsangares
Mary Carey
Andrew Loog Oldham
Tucker Carlson
Rick Hiebert
Always Sunday
Allan Slutsky
Dr. Helen Smith
Jan Hammer
Martin Atkins
Gretchen Lieberum
Moby
Billy "illy B" Martin
Buzz McCoy
Neal Pollack
Steven Van Zandt
Frank Black
Residents
Les Paul
Cary Sherman

AWARDS AND SUCH:

NEW!
- AlwaysOn and Technorati "Open Media 100"

About.com Blog In Profile

Best Weblog About Music, 2003 Weblog Award

A Yahoo! Pick of the Week

Best Media Blogs
Forbes.com

Sarah's Picks
TechTV Blog Report

Blogcritics on NBC-TV
Mike Wendland's High Tech Talk

2004 Weblog Awards
Best Group Weblog Nominee

RSSTop55
Best Blog Directory And RSS Submission Sites



   Blog: contraction of "web log," i.e., personal journalism web site.
+ Critics: those who discuss and evaluate cultural artifacts.
= Blogcritics.org: News and reviews of popular culture by multitude of superior bloggers.

In Association with Amazon.com

Latest posts
All posts