Disease of the week: Women's magazines
Published June 01, 2005
While flipping through Women's Day magazine today in the Jiffy Lube waiting room, I wondered: Where do they get these stories?
Each issue features a first-person account by a woman suffering from a disease. The disease is usually rare and the account is a heroic one, outlining the struggle and suffering of the woman who, inevitably, goes from doctor to doctor unable to find relief. Eventually, the cause is found. But not before the woman starts a support group for fellow sufferers and becomes the world's foremost authority on her particular ailment. The moral: Take charge of your life, Never give up, Win one for the gipper. The story is heavy on sidebars: "See your doctor when..." "Alternative therapies," etc., etc.
This week was a twofer: A first-person account of a woman suffering chronic pain (from I don't know what, those Jiffy Lube guys are fast), and Cindy McCain discussing her stroke.
It's not just Women's Day that has a weekly disease; all the supermarket women's magazines have them. Where do they get them? Do they approach women on the street who look ill? Troll MEDLINE for strange syndromes? Plant agents in doctors' offices?
Inquiring minds want to know.
- Disease of the week: Women's magazines
- Published: June 01, 2005
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Culture
- Filed Under: Books: Magazines, Books: Women, Culture: Media
- Writer: Rachel
- Rachel's BC Writer page
- Rachel's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Likely freelance writers pick up on a growing trend and flood editor's with witty yet poignant tales of woe and triumph.
I hate that shit! I think it is a way of modeling a passive, obedient non political roles for females. They aim to portray loss and disease as a normal state for women. If a disease has an overwhelming environmental component the response modeled for us is still supposed to be medical and individual, never to organize and stop the root causes of it.
People magazine has also been heavy into that stuff in their own way. It's sick to contemplate that stuff as much as they do. There's other things that life is about. It's all formulaic crap too and it leaves a lot of people with false ideas.
Cerulean, To be fair, the formula generally stresses the heroic struggle of the sufferer as she takes control over her life. If the cause is environmental, doubtless she started some kind of group to educate the public about the dangers of XXX. But often the diseases, whatever the cause, are extremely rare, though the headlines imply that you, too, could be in danger.
Interesting observation, Rachel. I think we have become a society that lives in such relative ease that we need to read or see someone suffering to get that "soap opera" psychic release. We feel better about ourselves for some odd reason. Carl Jung said:
Man needs difficulties; they are necessary for health.
I think it applies to both men and women.





in glancing out of the corner of my eye at the mags my wife and mother collect I have often had the same perplexities lay heavy on my brain pan - thanks Rachel!