Bruce Springsteen: The Folkloric Boss
Published May 10, 2005
Bruce Springsteen
Devils & Dust
Columbia
By Carlo Wolff
My thoughts run in threes on this album, Devils & Dust: folk, rock, pop; Johnny Cash, Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen.
There's a doctoral dissertation to be written on the culture of Columbia Records, primary home to Cash (he started on Sun and defected to Mercury, but his key stuff was on Columbia, at least until Rick Rubin landed him for the American Recordings), Dylan (a Big Eye stalwart save for an early-'70s defection to David Geffen's Asylum for a few records) and, ever since Greetings From Asbury Park in 1973, Springsteen. All are idiosyncratic, speak for the common man (albeit in different tongues), and are, in their heart, folksingers. They're also quintessentially American, compassionate, and even spiritual.
Each imagines himself into the core of this country, and each speaks for America at its best. Theirs are lonely voices, particularly these days. Cash's, sadder yet, is now still.
The nearest antecedent to Springsteen's first album in three years is the similarly intimate, similarly anomalous 1987 disk Tunnel of Love. This is not the Springsteen of the grand gesture, who performs with the E Street Band. Nor is it the Springsteen of Nebraska, his chilling, gothic 1982 work, or of the even less audible, equally moving Ghost of Tom Joad, his 1995 sleeper.
This is more diverse than these, and, perhaps, subtler. It's surely one of his most controlled and effective albums, even though he lets loose emotionally on several tunes. As a storyteller, he's extraordinarily precise and imaginative here.
My wife, a diehard Springsteen fan as I'm a diehard Dylan fan (it's generational), turned me onto "Maria's Bed," the beautiful hornpipe at the center of this. It was the first tune I heard from it, and it's enchanting and joyous. Then I popped the CD into my car player and began to absorb it. It's a complicated, textured album indeed. There's the stark, cold "The Hitter," a tune about a corrupt boxer who tries to hold onto his integrity. There's "Black Cowboys," a bleak, vividly imagined picture of ghetto life. There's "Leah," a rollicking tune of domestic aspiration, and there's a clutch of tunes about the tamed, commercial West we know now and the lost Wild West that inspires us.
- Bruce Springsteen: The Folkloric Boss
- Published: May 10, 2005
- Type: Review
- Section: Music
- Writer: Carlo Wolff
- Carlo Wolff's BC Writer page
- Carlo Wolff's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Why he didn't include it on "Hungry Heart" and "Lucky Town," his forgettable double release of 1992, is a mystery.
I think you mean "Human Touch," not "Hungry Heart."
Please, it's absolutely vital that you get your Springsteen trivia correct!
;-)
Devils and Dust is
It’s surely one of his most controlled and effective albums...? Controlled, yes. Effective? No. I keep reading all of these rave reviews, and I just don't see it. I have a very difficult time believing any of it. None of it seems true to me, all of it seems pretentious, like Springsteen is posturing. The DVD side reveals this most disturbingly.
Don't get me wrong -- I love Springsteen. I really wanted to like this album. But it falls very flat. Is it because I am not up to the challenge? No - I am supportive of all of Springsteen's musical choices, from the dismissal of the E Street band in favor of studio musicians for the Human Touch/Lucky Town disaster (of which, if you combine the two albums and cut out the riff-raff, there is a solid album between the two) to his brilliant Tunnel of Love to his incredible Ghost of Tom Joad. But D+D? Sounds like he's trying too hard, is too self conscious and is not writing any more from his gut. While it is a "It’s a complicated, textured album", it falls to the bottom of the stack in my Springsteen library. And Patti Scalfa is never obtrusive on a studio album because, thankfully, she is hardly included. She is very obtrusive, however, in a live show more for the fact that she seems so out of place. She is worse than Linda McCartney - a cardboard cutout better left in the prop trailer.
I like Patty and I liked her album. However, there are 47 members of the E Street Band at last count (including 19 guitarists), and many of them must go if the band is to avoid the muddy indistinguishable sound they essayed on the Kerry-for-Boss tour.
I absolutely hate this dishonest album of outtakes. I ripped it on the other Bruce post, and can't muster the strength to do it again. Just know everyone's not raving, Marc.
Nice review. I think Devils and Dust may be Bruce's best album.
I have to disagree with what seems to be the commonly accepted view of the double album set, Lucky Town and Human Touch. I love both.
This work of art in words you have created now has another venue for success, glory and taking control of the world :-) - and many more eyes - at the Advance.net Web sites, a place affiliated with about 10 newspapers.
One such site is here.
Also please let your contact know, if you had one, that this article, is published at one more place. That helps a lot.
Thank you.
Temple Stark


Carlo Wolff is the author of 


super job on both of these icons, Carlo, thanks!