DVD Pick of the Week. 5/10
Published May 10, 2005
This week's pick is Assault on Precinct 13. I approached seeing this theatrically with trepidation. I was a fan of the original film from John Carpenter, which itself was a remake of Rio Bravo, and had already been remade, by John Carpenter again as Ghosts of Mars. My curiosity over took the trepidation, I wanted to see what director Jean-Françis Richet could bring to the table.
This version differs greatly from the Carpenter original. Sure it retains the setting, sure it retains the isolationist factor. What it changes, is the bad guys. In the original, the cops and villains trapped in the station were under siege from an army of faceless gang members, this time the villains are given a face, they are the police. On top of that they are given a reason for being on the offensive. Plus, the trapped have more interpersonal drama.
This ended up being a very good action thriller. The story held together better than I expected. The performances was good as well. Laurence Fishburne gives an imposing visage, Ethan Hawke is good as the burned out cop, and Drea de Matteo had fun with her role. Give this one a chance, I think you will be pleasantly surprised.
Other titles for the week:
- 12 Monkeys: SE. It loses the DTS track from the earlier release, but it reportedly has a much improved transfer. Plus it's a great movie!
- Alone in the Dark. Ugh, avoid this piece of junk.
- Appleseed. A new CG film based on a manga series. I do not know much about it, but the trailer I saw made this sci-fi epic look intriguing. It is available in 3 flavors, single disk, 2-disk in a metal tin, and 2 disk tin with a figure.
- Fury. Fritz Lang's first American film and it stars Spencer Tracy. I have seen it described as a pre-noir classic.
- Hoop Dreams: The Criterion Collection. I have heard that this one of the best documentaries of the modern era.
- In Good Company. One of the best films to come out so far this year.
- Joan of Arcadia: The First Season. This first season was a wonderful family drama.
- The Life Aquatic: The Criterion Collection. Disappointing in theaters, weird for the sake of being weird. May play better in the home venue.
- Marillion: Marbles on the Road. Very good concert video from this long lasting prog band.
- Nang Nak. Asian horror film has a lot of good word surrounding it.
- Racing Stripes. This was a fun, yet forgettable, family film.
- WWE: Wrestlmania XXI. The latest incarnation of wrestling's biggest show.
That's it for this week.
Visit me at Draven99's Musings.
- DVD Pick of the Week. 5/10
- Published: May 10, 2005
- Type: Review
- Section: Video
- Part of a feature: DVD Pick of the Week
- Writer: Chris Beaumont
- Chris Beaumont's BC Writer page
- Chris Beaumont's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
I have a well documented weakness for Marillion's Marbles on the Road DVD, so I salute that choice!!
Frans
I recently reviewed the Marillion DVD, or at least tried to I don't think it came out as good as I had hoped here.
In Good Company was a great film, and was even at the top of my theater list until I saw SIn City.
Is this new version more entertaining than the original? I know you say they are different, but does it add to the film? I was sceptical to see it because I didn't like the original (I seem to get bored in movies easily), but with the differences, I am wondering if I should give it a look.
Well, they are 2 different films. THe two films are different and the same, the new one definitely amps up the action. Whereas the first one had a slow burn thing going on, this one ratchets up the tension.
I am not sure I could say this is a better version. But for those who did not like the first, should give this one a shot. I think you may like it. (says the guy who knows nothing of your tastes :) )


Christopher Beaumont spends much of his time writing about entertainment when he isn't sitting in a movie theater. He is known around the office as the "Movie Guy" and is always ready to talk about his favorite form of entertainment and offer up recommendations. Interests include science fiction, horror, and metal music. His writings can be found at 
My pick would be In Good Company. It was a cliched plot that did not play out as a cliche. A pleasant surprise and worth a pick up.