NEWS

American Idol: Corey Clark Threads the Needle

Written by Eric Olsen
Published May 05, 2005

Between the phone records, the answering machine message, the corroboration of the parents, the photos of them together, the detailed knowledge of Abdul's home and habits, I have very little doubt that SOMETHING interpersonal occurred between American Idol contestant Corey Clark and judge Paula Abdul back in '03, as he claimed last night on ABC's Primetime Live special.

However, Clark (and ABC) — who alleged that Abdul coached him on song selection, helped buy him clothes and style his hair, and initiated a sexual relationship — has cleverly left himself with an out for the inevitable next phase of the "scandal," which is an "investigation" by Fox of the allegations of improper conduct between the then-22 year old Clark and 40 year old Abdul, by stating today on Good Morning America that he will not aid Fox in their investigation, thereby letting Abdul off the hook and precluding the examination of any "hard evidence."

"I don't have any interest in helping American Idol out whatsoever, because they haven't helped me out whatsoever," Clark said. "They made it very hard for me to do what I'm doing, which is my career."

Should Abdul be kicked off the show? Clark was asked. "I don't know. I'm not attacking her at all. She just happens to be the key to getting this 900-pound gorilla off my back.

"I think they should look at what I was trying to say, which was that she risked so much to help me avoid the exploitation of the machine called American Idol," he said.

Aah, so he did it for the children.

Fox replied this morning in a statement. "We have concerns about the motives behind last night's purported news special, as much of it was filled with rumor, speculation and assertions from a disqualified contestant who admitted during the special to telling lies.

"Regardless, we are absolutely committed to the fairness of this competition. We take any accusation of this nature very seriously no matter their source and we have already begun looking into this."

"We have gone to great lengths and great expense to create a voting system that is fair and reliable. Judges may offer opinions, but viewers vote using their own subjective criteria, and it is the voters who ultimately determine each season's American idol."

They also indicated they had asked Clark for his help investigating the claims but "that has yet to happen."

And it won't because Clark doesn't want it to happen — it's not to his advantage to alienate Abdul THAT much and to swell a backlash against himself in sympathy with the elfin singer/dancer/choreographer were she to be kicked off the show — and neither does Fox.

The way it stands now, Clark got an hour of prime time TV exposure, including numerous shots of him recording his tell-all song "Paula-tics," he had the opportunity to reasonably prove that his allegations weren't fabricated out of thin air, he got to tweak the nose of the show that kicked him off for nondisclosure of legal problems resulting from an altercation with his younger sister, AND he will probably be able to avoid too much antagonism from fans of Abdul and the show, because he, in effect "refuses to testify."

No one REALLY loses, and Idol life rolls on. I wonder if this result was negotiated behind the scenes. It will be very interesting to see if Abdul is renewed for next season after all of this, however.

Career media professional Eric Olsen is honored to be the founder and publisher of Blogcritics.org, which, quite frankly, rules - as do his wife and four children.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
American Idol: Corey Clark Threads the Needle
Published: May 05, 2005
Type: News
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: News, Video: Reality TV, Video: Television
Writer: Eric Olsen
Eric Olsen's BC Writer page
Eric Olsen's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Eric Olsen
Video: News
Video: Reality TV
Video: Television
All Video Articles
Eric Olsen's personal weblog
All News articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — May 5, 2005 @ 10:47AM — Ken

It's May sweeps period in television.
Never believe anything you see/hear during ratings months, especially when someone has a book coming out!
Don't be so gullible.

#2 — May 5, 2005 @ 10:49AM — Eric Olsen

I agree with your premise, but what am I being gullible about?

#3 — May 5, 2005 @ 10:51AM — MYNIPPON [URL]

While I have no problem with people having a relationship with anyone they want, but when relationship does go sour, what kind of ethics say that you should go public with all the juicy details and embarrass a public persona?

#4 — May 5, 2005 @ 10:52AM — Eric Olsen

situational ethics

#5 — May 5, 2005 @ 10:58AM — Anon

you're looking for ethics from the entertainment industry? you know you won't find anything, right?

#6 — May 5, 2005 @ 11:01AM — Eric Olsen

only as applies to image, and image is money

#7 — May 5, 2005 @ 11:01AM — linda

i think paula should be tossed on her fat butt.
she is rotten as a apple
she carried on and look at her with constanine crying like a idiot.
she better get off her high horse and stop trying to think she is so young.
if american idol wants to stay on get rid of her.

#8 — May 5, 2005 @ 11:03AM — Eric Olsen

Linda, why so negative against Paula? Yours is the first really negative reaction I've heard toward her about this

#9 — May 5, 2005 @ 11:39AM — Elaine

Corey Clark was one of my favorites on AI2. Now he disgusts me. His motives are obvious and IF what he says did indeed happen, he was an adult and apparently knew the help etc. being given him was wrong. He's nothing more than an opportunist and trying to boost sales of his book and cd. Hopefully he will fade into obscurity soon.

AI would not be the same without Paula. Should any of Coreys allegations be true, let AI deal with it.
As for Corey, I wouldn't be so proud if he were My son.

#10 — May 5, 2005 @ 11:42AM — Eric Olsen

well-put Elaine

#11 — May 5, 2005 @ 11:48AM — Kelly

PLEASE ANSWER THIS QUESTION....
Paula left a message on his phone saying don't say anything to the press.she didn't know what it was regarding.

if she didn't know what it was regarding than why di she even call Corey?of all people why call him....this was before she even knew what the press wanted.


what is Corey doing that is so wrong...yes he is using it to promote his album,but the roof is there.Artists do things like to all the time.

#12 — May 5, 2005 @ 11:57AM — Eric Olsen

essentially he is kissing and telling for the sake of publicity - as I said, if he was going to do this, he was smart to not take it as far as cooperating with an investigation

#13 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:08PM — Mike

Actually here is not much proof at all.

Corey's friends and family have a vested interest so are not reliable witnesses.

The Sprint employee was not named or brought forward to substantiate the allegations that Paula bought him a phone.

He showed phone records for his home and that there were some long conversations. One can't assume the content of them or varify the caller.

None of the other contestants can figure out how he got out so late and often without security knowing about it.

Paula took him shopping in public to buy clothes, CDs and a haircut. They went to a nightclub too. Why is there nobody who can corroberate that aside from Corey's skeevy " friends"?

Corey has an ulterior motive and much to gain.

Last but not least is the body language. When answering truthfully, one looks up and to the left. Liars look down and to the right.

Case closed. hehehe

#14 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:17PM — g.v.naga


I think this is just publicity Corey is trying to get by using the public figure's name.
As for as Paula Abdul is concerned, should she be fired? this is upto Fox. I do think that there should be a complete investigation and then necessary action. Even if there is a hint of impropriety, then Paula should be fired.
Wouldn't you do the same to a college Professor, if there is a Professor involved?

#15 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:19PM — Eric Olsen

those are very salient points Mike, but I think we would have heard far more indignant and high-decibel support for Paula from Fox, etc etc if the show did't present an at least plausible case. But like I said, I think everyone onvolved is perfectly happy to let it slide from here and leave it in limbo.

#16 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:37PM — Mike

Well I did hear that AI wanted to let Paula go before the start of this current season but that she made some real concessions and took a cut in perks to keep her job. I think we would have heard far more indignant and high-decibel support for Paula from Fox if the show was planning to keep her. I think this is a convenient way to get rid of her..

#17 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:37PM — Eric Olsen

maybe so, but in the relative quiet of the off-season

#18 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:38PM — Elaine

There are two videos on this website in which Clay Aiken gives his take on the Corey/Paula story. When you access the website it will automatically scroll down. Scroll back up and watch the one taped in Raleigh and another after the GMA interview with Corey.
Interesting perspective and I'd put more faith in Clays opinion than anything Corey Clark might say.

#19 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:38PM — Eric Olsen

they are also likely gauging the level of support she gets from the public after this

#20 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:41PM — Elaine

Good point Mike. As far as Coreys looking down when making certain statements. Shades of Scott Peterson interviews....lol

#21 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:51PM — Mike

Yes, Eric! Scott Peterson is a perfect example.

I first noticed it when Susan Smith was pretending that her children were kidnapped and she was talking and crying to the media to " Please help me find my children". It was a gut feeling I had at the time that was later proved correct.

I watched the video clips and I agree, I'd believe Clay on this one.

#22 — May 5, 2005 @ 12:52PM — Eric Olsen

thanks for the link Elaine, very interesting

#23 — May 5, 2005 @ 13:01PM — Mike

Sorry, Elaine, I was thinking of something Eric said while replying to you.

Thanks for the clips.

#24 — May 5, 2005 @ 15:09PM — c moore

Corey Clark is THE NEW OMAROSA! He's whiney, he's back peddling, and he acts like a spoiled child. You can't have it both ways 'playa'.

#25 — May 5, 2005 @ 15:11PM — Eric Olsen

and he is trying to do that, isn't he? Good point, c!

#26 — May 5, 2005 @ 16:01PM — Elaine

Excellent comparison to Omarosa!!! =)

#27 — May 5, 2005 @ 16:21PM — mellynie

I think Paula is CRAZY for doing such a Scandelous thing with my used to be obsession of AI2, I just feel like they are both immature for doing this. Paula is in her 30's now I think she should start acting her age, and GROW UP!!!!! HEY !GIRLS! DO YOU STILL THINK HE'S HOT OR NOT, I PICK NOT!!!!!

#28 — May 5, 2005 @ 17:46PM — -E [URL]

First of all, she is in her 40s now.

Secondly- him saying he doesn't want to help AI because they didn't help him. And what, pray tell, does he think is the reason he is where he is and able to get the publicity he is getting? I think he is in denial that they did in fact boost his career.

But who cares? If I found out some chick on the show was sleeping with Simon or Randy I wouldn't care. I'd be curious about the quality of the sex.... but that is because I am a self proclaimed pervert.

And if he did have a sexual relationship with her, can he not handle that ending? I think we've all dated people that didn't end up being "the one" or whatever. That is part of life. Go on with your life. Or you could define your entire career based on it. Which seems more beneficial to yourself?

And did women think he was attractive before? I must have wonky taste in men or something because he wasn't attractive. Oh well, I'll take a dork any day anyway.

#29 — May 5, 2005 @ 18:51PM — Eric Olsen

I think he resembles a pipe cleaner

#30 — May 5, 2005 @ 19:22PM — Elaine

Mellynie, you are assuming what Corey says is true. Check the video interviews with Clay Aiken (website in one of my previous posts). He sure doesn't put much stock in Corey Clarks story.

#31 — May 5, 2005 @ 20:06PM — kcunac

This guy is such a loser. So two years later, and down on his luck, he comes out & tells a "story". what's the matter Corey? Fame not as easy as you thought? Have to kiss and tell to get some traction....no future for this no talent loser.....by Monday we'll have forgotten all about????what was his name again?

#32 — May 5, 2005 @ 20:07PM — Eric Olsen

nor did any of his other fellow finalists they interviewed on whatever tabloid entertainment news TV show crap that came on earlier

#33 — May 5, 2005 @ 20:55PM — Elaine

Another website showing support for Paula from former contestants.

#34 — May 6, 2005 @ 01:57AM — Lonnie

I do not believe the allegations against Paula from Corey Clark. If they were true...seems to me that Paula treated Corey with a lot of class. Bought him clothes, cell phone, hair cut, coached him, invited him to her home and boosted his ego. Seems to me that Corey is ungrateful, selfish and just cannot accept rejection. He's just a scorned boo-hooer. Grow up Corey!

#35 — May 6, 2005 @ 09:18AM — Eric Olsen

that seems to be the majority reaction to this

#36 — May 6, 2005 @ 12:11PM — -E [URL]

Now, that isn't to say we think that any relationship wouldn't have violated common sense ethics behind the professional nature of their conncetion to each other.

But did the producers of Primetime Live really think this "expose" would devestate Fox's American Idol? Pretty lame attempt if you ask me.

#37 — May 6, 2005 @ 12:22PM — Eric Olsen

I doubt they much care since ABC won that time slot for first time all season!

#38 — May 6, 2005 @ 17:33PM — Nicolette Rivers [URL]

I absolutely think that there is enough evidence there that something went on. That being said: he's scum.

What Paula did was wrong. What Corey did was worse, which is use all of her help, and rat her out later on.

He wasn't feeling a need to get this off of his chest until he had something to promote, and I bet you anything that if he would have WON American Idol he would still be sitting on his little secret.

#39 — May 6, 2005 @ 18:44PM — Natalie Davis [URL]

Evidence of something, yes. But everything produced that I've heard of sounds circumstantial at best. And they don't prove beyond a reasonable doubt that anything specific took place -- they haven't proven that Abdul bought the clothes or haircuts or CDs. They haven't proven that their relationship was sexual. The only people shown on Clark's side were his own parents and friends. Other contestants are skeptical. I remain so. But yes, whether Clark's allegations or true or not, he still comes across as a complete cad. As Frenchie Davis, former AI2 contestant, said on Entertainment Tonight, Clark's actions are "tacky."

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/29062)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments