Movie Review: Sin City

Written by Chris Beaumont
Published April 13, 2005

I had to see this movie twice before I could even attempt to put fingers to keyboard to birth my thoughts. Even now I am having a hard time deciding where to begin. This is such a wonderfully gritty trio of tales that take place under the same sky. It is unlike anything that you have seen, or are likely to see for some time.

I am not terribly familiar with the Sin City graphic novels. There was a time in the early-mid 1990's where I was an avid comic collector, many times I would pick one up and thumb through it, but never bought. They had an intriguing look, more inspired by old noir films and gritty crime novels of the 1950's than the more popular superhero pedigree. Years later I heard that Robert Rodriguez would be attempting an adaptation to the big screen, and it seemed like something that was very close to his heart. Then I forgot about it until it came up on the radar nearing its release date. Then the magic started, the trailers appeared and I was officially hooked. Every time I saw a commercial or trailer I got a little more amped. The one thing I was hoping was that I wasn't setting myself up for a fall. Occasionally I get my hopes up so high that nothing could possibly live up to.

Then the day came, I entered the theater found a seat in the middle in the closer half of the theater and settled down. The screen flickers on and the trailers begin, I don't remember any of them, as my senses were blown away by the feature that graced my eye sockets, so any memory of previews was conveniently obliterated. But, you don't want to hear about trailer s anyway, and I'm just dancing around what you all came here to read, what you really want to know is "Was the movie any good?" The simple answer would be an emphatic YES!

To simply run through the story, or stories, would do it a great disservice, it so much more than a plot description. But without it, it is hard to get the words flowing, so bear with me as I give you a brief spin through the world of Sin City. There are three interlocking tales, more loosely connected taking place within the confines of the same universe.

The tale of Hartigan(Bruce Willis) wraps the film, it opens the film with the aging detective on one last job, save a young girl from the son of a senator, who was working on victim number four. The second half of the tale closes the film and follows the results of that initial confrontation. The second tale centers on the none-to-bright thug Marv(Mickey Rourke), who goes on a violent quest to uncover the truth behind the death of the hooker who showed him a moment of kindness. Thirdly there is Dwight(Clive Owen), a man trying to escape a dark past, but knows that what he has coming up will make that impossible as he becomes embroiled in a battle with the mob while trying to help the hookers who run Old Town.

page 1 | 2
Christopher Beaumont spends much of his time writing about entertainment when he isn't sitting in a movie theater. He is known around the office as the "Movie Guy" and is always ready to talk about his favorite form of entertainment and offer up recommendations. Interests include science fiction, horror, and metal music. His writings can be found at Draven99's Musings and Draven99's Media Center.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Movie Review: Sin City
Published: April 13, 2005
Type:
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: Action, Video: Adventure, Video: Animation, Video: Crime, Video: Drama, Video: Fantasy, Video: Thriller
Writer: Chris Beaumont
Chris Beaumont's BC Writer page
Chris Beaumont's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Chris Beaumont
Video: Action
Video: Adventure
Video: Animation
Video: Crime
Video: Drama
Video: Fantasy
Video: Thriller
All Video Articles
Chris Beaumont's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — April 13, 2005 @ 08:44AM — Convex [URL]

Interesting review. I felt the same way and I am definately not a Rodriguez fan. It just shows what he can do out of his low budget existance and mexican settings. Its like night and day I think, between the trilogy and this.

I wonder, though, which of the 3 (I consider it 4) parts he directed? With Quentin and Miller listed as directors too, this might be what saved it from a Mexico-trilogy feel.

Luckily Quentin was not *in* the movie (at least that I could tell) and limited his involved to directing.

#2 — April 13, 2005 @ 11:16AM — Chris Beaumont [URL]

Miller didn't actually direct anything, from what I understand. Due to his cinematic approach to the books, which served as storyboards, and his presence on the set, Rodriguez wanted him to have the title. By dointg that, he had to give up is DGA membership, which cost him some work.

Quentin directed one scene, the one with Clive and Benicio in the car. The majority of this is Rodriguez.

#3 — April 13, 2005 @ 22:43PM — El Bicho [URL]

"Miller didn't actually direct anything"

That's incorrect, Chris. Here is an interview with Robert talking about their shared director duties at SuperheroHype.com:

"It was very complementary. I wanted him [Frank] to be a director rather that just there as a writer, a producer, because I felt if (it) just came to that, they might just stick him in the corner and feed him a sandwich every once in a while. But if he was a director, everyone would have to listen to him. I didn't want it to be Robert Rodriguez's 'Sin City'. I loved the book so much, I wanted it to be as close to something that he would do in the movie as possible. And it was very complementary. I tried not to do any contradictory directing. If he told an actor one thing, I wouldn't tell them the exact opposite...He let me handle all the visual stuff. He was really there working with the actors, knowing the characters so well. I didn't know everything about the characters cause it's not all in the book, a lot of it's in his head, and they loved to be able to know where the character was going in future volumes, or what he was thinking when he put it together, and how it should be performed."

http://www.superherohype.com/news/featuresnews.php?id=2759

#4 — April 15, 2005 @ 14:06PM — Chris Beaumont [URL]

Thanks for the info!

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/28108)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments