The Ring Two: Ringing Hollow

Written by Chase McInerney
Published March 21, 2005

What The Ring boasted in mood, atmosphere, pacing, characterization, layers of complexity and legitimate spookiness, its successor tries to make up for in ... um ... well ... rampaging deer.

In other words, The Ring Two is a failure. And that's a particular letdown, considering that Hollywood tapped Hideo Nakata for it, the Japanese director whose 1998 horror film, Ringu, was the original source material for The Ring.

Naomi Watts reprises her role as Rachel, the dogged newspaper reporter (if you didn't see 2002's Ring, incidentally, forget trying to make sense of anything that goes on in this sequel). She and her preternaturally mature son, Aidan (David Dorfman) have tried to leave behind the horrors of Samara's home videos by moving to a small town in Oregon. But it's not that easy, and so it isn't long before the appearance of our favorite ghost in desperate need of a haircut.

Unless a movie is packaged to be camp, it can handle only a couple of absurdities before things turn laughable. Ring Two asks its audience to swallow an awful lot of gristle. After a local teenager dies under suspicious circumstances, Rachel has no problem sauntering into an ambulance, where she subsequently unzips the body bag to inspect the corpse. Nor does it prove to be a challenge for her to sneak into the crime scene and retrieve a videotape still in the VCR (lucky break for Samara that evidently no one in the Pacific Northwest has made the switch to DVD players).

There are some amusing bits, but they don't really gel into anything cohesive. Sissy Spacek makes an interesting cameo as Samara's biological mother; it's a hoot to see Spacek, who set the standard for creepy kids back in 1976 with Carrie, more or less riffing on Piper Laurie's role in that earlier movie as Carrie's crazed momma. We know Spacek's character here is crazy because she collects huge piles of newspapers, which — according to Hollywood — is a tell-tale sign of mental illness (i.e. A Beautiful Mind).

Most annoying of all is how The Ring Two cheats by revising the entire backstory of its progenitor. The first Ring centered on the conceit that Samara, a creature of pure evil, was something of an anomaly to the natural order of the universe. In that film, Samara's mother had suffered miscarriage after miscarriage before finally giving birth; Samara's very existence, it seemed, was an affront to nature.

But you can forget all that. Without wanting to give too much away (am I thoughtful or what?), that whole notion is turned on its head in Ring Two.

Evidently, sequels are easy to crank out when screenwriters aren't tied to pesky matters of the logic and previously established narratives.

Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
The Ring Two: Ringing Hollow
Published: March 21, 2005
Type:
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: Horror
Writer: Chase McInerney
Chase McInerney's BC Writer page
Chase McInerney's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Chase McInerney
Video: Horror
All Video Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — March 21, 2005 @ 21:16PM — Aaron, Duke De Mondo [URL]

Chase, i was looking forward to Ring 2, and indeed still am, but the presence of Hideo Nakata never really excited me the way it has some folks. His Ringu 2 was utterly diabolical, save for the scene in the editing suite.

And whatever the case, this must surely be better than the original ring 2, Spiral, which they then ignored totally on account of it was so hilariously shit.

you can find a review of it by clicking the Asian Horror bit on www.mondoirlando.com

it truly was abysmal.

#2 — March 21, 2005 @ 21:52PM — Dave Nalle [URL]

I think Ring 2 was quite effective and the changes to the backstory are subtle and not so alien to the original as you suggest.

The best review might be my 13 year old daughter's who was blown away to see Sissy Spacek - "OMG Dad, it's Carrie" - as Samara's birth mother and who thought that overall it was more intense than the first film was.

I think the first film was visually and conceptually stronger, while this film was better on plot and overall suspense. I'd probably say the first film was better, but Ring 2 is still well above horror film average.

Dave

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/27053)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments