Looking For Alice, Finding Carroll

Written by Aaman Lamba
Published February 16, 2005

A Wasp In A Wig is a blog drawing on various themes of Lewis Carroll, and other 19th century English writers. The Annotated Alice has long been one of the best books around. Carroll's allusions, mathematical puzzles, social commentary and creative humor make him a valuable resource in a fragmented age. His apparent pedophilia is reviled, while his literary works appreciated. This dichotomy is brought out in an entry on this blog celebrating his 173rd anniversary

Clearly we love the works of Lewis Carroll here. Personally I find his life an inspiration and a guiding light.

That said the hardest thing for me to deal with and accept was that Dodgson was a pedophile. The signs are everywhere but in my youth I chose to ignore them and believe that this man operated on a higher plane where love could exist purely for it's own sake.

That accepted it most be noted that Dodgson died as a virgin. While he spent many nights wrestling with what he called his demons there is no indication that he ever harmed a child or entered into any inappropriate relationship.

He controlled his impulses and tried to force his love into the higher plane I imagined.

This self control adds to his pleasant legend.
..........
There was much to love and ponder over the man.

Some interesting entries from "A Wasp In A Wig" include an exhibition of Alice Art in London and a new book on Lewis Carroll, annotating his bank account - well described by the author in the Times Literary Supplement
The account also shows conclusively that at least one major aspect of Dodgson's famous image is absolutely wrong. His reputation has always been that of an obsessive, picking at detail in a way which could drive others frantic. As Isa Bowman recalled, before a railway journey Dodgson would "exactly calculate the amount of money that must be spent, and, in different partitions of the two purses that he carried, arrange the various sums that would be necessary for cabs, porters, newspapers, refreshments and the other expenses of a journey . . .". Then there was his correspondence with Macmillan's, beginning in 1875, after he had analysed the Alice accounts. "On every thousand copies sold", he complained, "your profit is £20.16s 8d, mine is £56.5s 0d, and the bookseller's £70.16s.8d. This seems . . . altogether unfair . . ." After bombarding Macmillan
with letters, Dodgson began fixing the sale prices of his books himself in order to secure a larger profit, earning himself the enmity of booksellers and enhancing his reputation for financial sharpness.

page 1 | 2
Aaman Lamba is a Blogcritics editor, as well as the Publisher of Desicritics.org, a Blogcritics network site covering media, politics, culture, sports and more with a global South Asian focus
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Looking For Alice, Finding Carroll
Published: February 16, 2005
Type:
Section: Books
Filed Under: Books: Children, Books: Fantasy, Books: Humor, Books: SF, Culture: Arts
Writer: Aaman Lamba
Aaman Lamba's BC Writer page
Aaman Lamba's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Aaman Lamba
Books: Children
Books: Fantasy
Books: Humor
Books: SF
Culture: Arts
All Books Articles
Aaman Lamba's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — February 16, 2005 @ 12:56PM — Lono [URL]

Lewis Carroll rules! As someone with an Literature degree, it should carry at least a little weight when I say Alice in Wonderland (which is actually two books) is the best book ever written. It is timeless, and never fails to impress or entertain me.

#2 — February 16, 2005 @ 13:56PM — Aaman [URL]

The concern about Carroll's pedophilia is in line with our modern sensibilities, but his preferences were not out of place in his own times - when the (not yet) Bishop of Canterbury could propose to a twelve-year old, and nary a complaint.

Great author, indeed - and talented in many more fields

#3 — February 16, 2005 @ 15:42PM — Richard Porter

Does this mean that we should embrace Carroll, just as Hollywood has embraced J.M. Barrie, the creator of Peter Pan (Finding Neverland)?
This movie seems to have left out a major part of that author's life, namely his fascination with young boys.
By your accord, we should excuse Michael Jackson, Barrie and Carroll and anyone else because they are extremely talented, are geniuses or during their lifetime the world wasn't civilized enough to realize how morally wrong their lusts would lead them.
Praise the stories not the man.

#4 — February 16, 2005 @ 15:50PM — Aaman [URL]

Ah - I expected the comparisons - I did not excuse this element of his life. It may have been a motive force for his creativity, and was morally wrong. In fact, it was probably the main reason he did not take up the cloth, as it were. He knew he was tormented by these demons, unlike, say, Michael

The contradictions exist in these people's lives - do with them what you will.

#5 — February 17, 2005 @ 02:15AM — Lono [URL]

You are all losing track and making very serious accusations which I think are totally baseless. The Alice in the book was a real life girl, Alice Little. She was the daughter of a good friend who used to accompany them on picnics.

Sure Dodgeson (pen name Carrol) was a strange fellow with a great imagination... that doesn't make him a pedophile. If you are to use that same rule of them (that creators of children's art are all pedophiles), then eveyr single employee of the Disney corporation should be charged and hung.

#6 — February 19, 2005 @ 03:52AM — Mike [URL]

This discussion of Carroll as a pedophile is pretty out of date isn't it? The newest research shows that the whole image of his so-called 'obsession' with small girls was created almost entirely (and almost accidentally) by biographers and dreamers anyway.
See the 'Looking for Lewis Carroll' website which had the latest research from the best writers on Carroll

#7 — February 19, 2005 @ 12:52PM — Aaman [URL]

Thanks Mike - great website.

#8 — April 7, 2005 @ 09:55AM — Richard Astley-Clemas [URL]

Everythings been said about this tiresome subject and little of it made sense anyway by applying todays morals and politically correct thinking to what happenned well over a century ago.
No one seems to have realised that Dodgson/Carroll would have been impotent thus a threat to nobody

#9 — April 7, 2005 @ 12:34PM — DrPat [URL]

If impotence or virginity were a bar to pedophilia, Michael Jackson wouldn't be in the trouble he's in.

Whether or not Dodson (or Barrie, for that matter) ever consumated their lusts, that they experienced a sexual urge toward children is part of the historical background of these men.

#10 — April 7, 2005 @ 12:45PM — Shark

Just wanna add a suggestion:

Alice in Wonderland by Abelardo Morrell

Beautiful and brilliant, it belongs in every Alice fanatic's collection.

PS: re - alleged pedophilia -- get a life, morons.

xxoo
S

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/25587)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments