The Best and Worst of 2004: My Humble List
Published January 03, 2005
Top 3 Foreign Language Films
- 3. I'm Not Scared. Here is an impressive film about a young boy who discovers his family is involved in a kidnapping plot.
- 2. Bad Education. A film you have to work at to decipher, but it's worth it.
- 1. Hero. Simply gorgeous.
Top 5 Disappointing Films
- 5. I, Robot. Here was an opportunity for an intelligent science fiction film, what we get is a one-liner filled chase film.
- 4. Van Helsing. I liked the Mummy films, but this one has no gas behind it. A great looking set couldn't save it.
- 3.(Tie) The Life Aquatic and I Heart Huckabees. I really wanted to like these, but despite the quirkiness, they were rather shallow and empty.
- 2. Alexander. Usually you can't go wrong with Stone, but this one is an overlong dreadful bore.
- The Village. I have loved each of Shyamalan's films, except this, which is a shame because there is so much to like.
Top 5 Surprising Films
- 5. Friday Night Lights. I'm not much of a football fan, so I was surprised by how entertaining this movie was. Probably one of the better sports films I've seen.
- 4. Spartan. Wonderful dialogue and a great performance from Val Kilmer combine to make an exciting thriller.
- 3. Napoleon Dynamite. Again, don't know the point of this, but it is surprisingly good.
- 2. Dawn of the Dead. Wanting to hate this didn't work, turned out to be an entertaining reimagining of the zombie tale.
- 1. Wicker Park. This was the biggest surprise this year, the commercials didn't look all that spectacular, but the film was surprisingly good.
Top 5 Actors
- 5. Tom Hanks for The Terminal. Hanks puts on a clinic here, an absolutely mesmerizing performance, that reminds me of Cast Away.
- 4. Zach Braff for Garden State. A fantastic understated performance, not what you'd expect from JD on Scrubs.
- 3. Paul Giamatti for Sideways. Following up last year's American Splendor comes an even better performance as a wine connoisseur who is also at a crossroads.
- 2. Johnny Depp for Finding Neverland. Another wonderful performance filled with a childlike innocence.
- 1. Jim Carrey for Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. A great subtle performance in a very moving film.
- Honorable Mention: Val Kilmer for Spartan, Giuseppe Cristiano for I'm Not Scared, and Jim Caviziel in The Passion of the Christ
Top 5 Actresses
- 5. Kate Winslet for Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. I am not a very big fan of her, but her job her goes far in turning me, it's a good performance.
- 4. Natalie Portman for Closer. A beautiful showing for an ugly character.
- 3. Maia Morgenstern for The Passion of the Christ. A beautiful near silent performance.
- 2. Uma Thurman for Kill Bill Vol. 2. Physically and mentally exhausting tour de force of revenge.
- 1. Bryce Dallas Howard for The Village. An incredible performance in a terribly disappointing film.
- Honorable Mention: Catalina Sandino Moreno for Maria Full of Grace and Virginia Madsen for Sideways.
- The Best and Worst of 2004: My Humble List
- Published: January 03, 2005
- Type:
- Section: Video
- Writer: Chris Beaumont
- Chris Beaumont's BC Writer page
- Chris Beaumont's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Thanks!
The 5 star film was The Passion.
As for Sideways, I haven't checked out too many other lists yet, but when I walked out of the theater, I loved how the film seemed to be filled with real world characters in a situation that was more or less realistic, it just struck a chord.
super job of boiling things down and coming to conclusions - thanks Chris!
welcome back, Eric - I guess we'll see more of you hereabouts now?
Thanks Aaman, I am deciding how interesting the many obstacles to my participation in the electronic world over the last 10 days or so would be to hte world at large - I'm sure I'll do something on it
I'm impressed with your incredibly detailed breakdown of the year in film. This list reminds me, above all others, how many fine films I manage to miss annually.
I agree that you should include your star ratings for each film. For instance, I'd like to see where the Surprises and Guilty Pleasures match up against the Best (and Worst).
Eric Berlin
Dumpster Bust: Miracles from Mind Trash
http://dumpsterbust.blogspot.com
Eric,
I'll do that. When I am home at my own PC. If you visit my blog, there is a link on the left side which will show you the complete list of films I have seen. I originally thought about ranking and posting the entire list, but there are so many films in the middle that could go in a variety of directions. Maybe I will post the list with a one line review each?
I think you could do a separate post listing all 100+ movies with a one-line review and your rating. That would be a great way for people to get a quick read on your take from the entire year in film. Personally, I'd like to see your 5 stars, 4.5s, 4s, etc. separated out, then alphabetized.
But that's just the opinion of one (just graduated) academic librarian...
Eric Berlin
Dumpster Bust: Miracles from Mind Trash
http://dumpsterbust.blogspot.com
Congratulations!
I'll be putting something up, keep your eye out!
That's a great roundup! I missed a lot of these movies, but I'll be using this list to help me decide what to try and catch while it's still playing.
Excellent list. I'm in the process of putting my own together. I know how much sweat and blood went into all those stats, man. This isn't a task to be taken lightly. And happy new year and such to you all.
I haven't gotten to start the one line review quick guide to my viewing '04, hopefully by the weekend.


Christopher Beaumont spends much of his time writing about entertainment when he isn't sitting in a movie theater. He is known around the office as the "Movie Guy" and is always ready to talk about his favorite form of entertainment and offer up recommendations. Interests include science fiction, horror, and metal music. His writings can be found at 








Excellent, well-detailed list. Which was the 5-star rated film in your list?
Also, seeing Sideways appear across the board reminds me of A O Scott's gripes about the film in this Sunday's NY Times - he perceives the film as being a critic's favorite because the lead character has the temperament of a critic. He is not a big fan of the film.