Dave's Top Ten of 2004 - Your Results May Vary
Published January 02, 2005
6. The Five Obstructions
Hardly anybody got to see this and that's too bad, because it's a great film...if you're a filmmaker. I don't know how much appeal this would have, actually, outside of that niche, but inside, it has quite a bit. Crazy Lars Von Trier challenges his mentor Jorgen Leth to remake Jorgen's film The Perfect Human five times over, each time with a number of restrictions to raise the bar. In one case each shot can only last half a second. In another he must shoot it in a format he despises - the cartoon. Each time he surprises himself, and us, with the results. It ultimately ends up being a film about filmmaking and the responsibility (or avoidance of responsibility) of the director as a storyteller. Bored yet? If not, check it out.
5. The Passion of the Christ
Yes, yes, I know. I'm not supposed to like this film. Or if I do I'm a red state evangelistic wacko. But if you cut beyond the hype you'll see a film that is masterfully directed (who knew Mel had it in him?) and emotionally wrenching (Christian or not, the film is largely about a mother's love for her son). Is it violent? Oh, my, yes. Will you get more out of it if you already know or are interested in the minutiae of the gospel? Probably. Will I stop talking like Robert Evans now? Maybe. But the point is that in terms of sheer filmmaking, this is an outstanding achievement. But I will admit to the bias of appreciating that this is one of the few films about the Bible that seems to make an effort to stick to the source material. So my recommendation may come with a pillar of salt. (Sorry. Couldn't help it.)
4. The Incredibles
Ah, finally. A film everyone can agree on. But don't scoff at that. It's no mean feat. Just because a movie is a feel-good flick doesn't mean it has universal appeal. Plenty of cynics loved this movie, too. And that's the magic of Pixar (and in this case, Iron Giant & Simpsons alum Brad Bird, who writes and directs here), to make a movie that everybody can love. On top of that, it has fantastic production design (or whatever you call that for an animated film) and an outstanding performance by Bird himself as superhero fashion designer Edna Mode. It's no coincidence this is already up on the IMDB top 250 (as are Garden State and my top three picks).
- Dave's Top Ten of 2004 - Your Results May Vary
- Published: January 02, 2005
- Type:
- Section: Video
- Writer: David Dylan Thomas
- David Dylan Thomas's BC Writer page
- David Dylan Thomas's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Well researched and presented list. I'm sad to say I've missed many of these (thank Gods for Netflix) and this is good reminder to get going. Eternal Sunshine is one of my favorite films of the '00s, and Before Sunrise one my favorites from the 90s. Can't wait to see the new one.
Eric Berlin
Dumpster Bust: Miracles from Mind Trash
http://dumpsterbust.blogspot.com
Great list, although I have to say my biggest gripe with "Five Obstructions" is aimed at the genius who decided to use white subtitles for a movie that has a white background for at least half of its scenes. Probably represents man's inhumanity to man or something, huh? I'll send my ophthalmologist bill to Lars Von Trier. :-)












Good list and great commentaries. Thanks for including The Five Obstructions - it really is great and far too few will see it. The intensity of the relationship between these two filmmakers is fascinating.