The Uncontestable Official and True List of the Top 20 Records of 2004

Written by Al Barger
Published December 29, 2004
page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

10 - "I'm So Ronery" Team America Soundtrack
Being presented as the sad lament of the self-pitying North Korean dictator sung in an extreme "Asian" accent that rewrites the very title, the song is totally set up as comedy. Yet it has such a memorable and honestly compelling sad melody that it still comes out a beautifully sad song, even having to jump over the comedy hurdles to get there. This is just a superior piece of songcraft.

11 - "Button My Lip" Elvis Costello
Elvis has rarely constructed underlying instrumental grooves nearly as good as this or "Bedlam" from the same album. Both of them have much more supple and involved grooves that will thus give longer lasting flavor than perhaps even some of his classic catchy but more hamhanded grooves such as even "Pump It Up."

What really sets off the whole combination of tune and groove is the what might be called jazzy arrays of dissonance that Steve Nieve is setting off in the keyboards as the track progresses. Steve Nieve is BAD.

12 - "Family Tree" Loretta Lynn
This sad fiddle driven broken home lament has a particularly interestingly bitter and malicious lyric. "No, I didn't come to fight/ If he was a better man, I might" Nonetheless, she's brought their children to meet the woman who's burning down their family tree.

This is one of the most straightforward country recordings on this Van Lear album, one of the things closest stylistically to her classic hits.

However, it's a thousand miles different in meaning and intent from "You Ain't Woman Enough." It sounds more obviously "country" than some of the other Van Lear Rose songs (ie it's acoustic), but it sounds neither stylistically nor emotionally like Loretta's classic fightin' woman songs. It's a whole new sound for her.

13 - "The Delivery Man" Elvis Costello
I'll start by saying that this is just the kind of Elvis song that might seem insular to casual fans. In just the kind of cleverness that might infuriate the less patient, he had some half-developed storyline for this album, especially this track- which he purposely cut short and scrapped.

Except that it leaves this song in particular as having a half told story which we never quite get filled in on. On the other hand, you could try to call that a dramatically useful "mystery" as per the "Ode to Billy Joe."

Purely as a stand alone song, though, this has a very compelling melody and tone. He's managed to compose an epic rock waltz that can't be denied. Given the Southern gothic tone, you might think of this as some kind of advanced response to The Band.

page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6
Unreformed hawkish Hoosier hillbilly and sometimes candidate Al Barger runs the still squeezin' down the psychodelic Kentucky moonshine at MoreThings.com, what with the paranoid religious visions and the Pentacostal music and visions of God and Sarah Palin and anarchy running amok and such. Somebody oughta call the cops to report his out of control freedom of conscience. Till they come to take him away somewhere where he can't hurt anyone else, you can check out his weekly column of NEW ALBUM RELEASES.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
The Delivery Man The Delivery Man
Elvis Costello
Music,
Naturally Naturally
Sharon Jones and the Dap-Kings
Music,
Team America: World Police Team America: World Police
Music,
Van Lear Rose Van Lear Rose
Loretta Lynn
Music,
SMiLE SMiLE
Brian Wilson
Music,
Songs About Jane Songs About Jane
Maroon 5
Music,
Good News for People Who Love Bad News Good News for People Who Love Bad News
Modest Mouse
Music,
Musicology Musicology
Prince
Music,

The Uncontestable Official and True List of the Top 20 Records of 2004
Published: December 29, 2004
Type:
Section: Music
Filed Under: Music: Adult Alternative, Music: Alternative Rock, Music: Blues, Music: Country and Americana, Music: Indie Rock, Music: Pop, Music: Progressive Rock, Music: R&B, Music: Rock, Music: Roots Rock, Music: Soundtracks
Writer: Al Barger
Al Barger's BC Writer page
Al Barger's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Al Barger
Music: Adult Alternative
Music: Alternative Rock
Music: Blues
Music: Country and Americana
Music: Indie Rock
Music: Pop
Music: Progressive Rock
Music: R&B
Music: Rock
Music: Roots Rock
Music: Soundtracks
All Music Articles
Al Barger's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — December 29, 2004 @ 20:58PM — Aaman [URL]

nice list - well reviewed - some new stuff to check out

Elvis Lives!

#2 — December 29, 2004 @ 21:48PM — Eric Berlin [URL]

Your list gets my vote on the power of the Team America songs alone (though I would have included "Montage," "Korean Medley" [one of the more bizarre and catchy songs I've ever heard], and "Everyone has AIDS" instead of I'm So Ronery). It's amazing that a song called "America, F*&^ Yeah" can work on so many levels, isn't it? The best part, of course, is that it kicks ass and stays with you... and then you start thinking about it. Thus is the genius of Parker and Stone -- both very talented musicians in their own right.

#3 — December 29, 2004 @ 22:49PM — Rodney Welch [URL]

"Essentially sincere"? "...it kicks ass and stays with you"? What are you guys on? It's a start to finish parody. There's no sincerity and absolutely nothing to think about -- except how funny it is.

#4 — December 29, 2004 @ 23:51PM — Al Barger [URL]

Rodney brother, you're not getting the whole picture with Parker and Stone. Team America are the good guys- warts and all. It's not just a pox on all your houses; they're presenting a considerably more nuanced outlook than that.

Beyond analyzing the political meaning of the lyrics, there's the whole tune and presentation. This song and movie represent a lot of careful thought. This is a really catchy and infectious song, and not in fact sarcastic.

"I'm So Ronery" kicks ass, but I was particularly wanting to include "Freedom Isn't Free" as well. "Pearl Harbor Sucks and I Miss You" wasn't far behind. You can't include everything.

#5 — January 4, 2005 @ 15:07PM — richard

What a joke, you don't have a clue, give it up lameass

#6 — January 4, 2005 @ 15:13PM — Eric Berlin [URL]

Richard - Some examples to illustrate your point would be nice (and fair).

~ Eric B.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/23730)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments