Gulag: A History

Written by Tom Donelson
Published December 21, 2004
page 1 | 2

Even today, the Russian people struggle with the legacy of their past. As Vladimir Putin strengthens the authoritarian nature of past Russian governments, it is time for Russians to truly examine the past. A nation that refuses to deal with its past may be forced to live through its misery again. Exposure of the Nazis crimes killed Nazism as ideology. The Nuremberg trial was not designed to just try Nazis leader but to expose their cruelty. There was no doubt about the outcome of these tribunals and no doubt that these Nazis leaders were guilty, but their crime was examined for all to see and for history.

Iraq will soon have to confront its own past as well when the Iraqi government puts Saddam Hussein and his henchmen on trial. This could have cleansing effect as the Iraqi people and the world will see for themselves the barbarous behavior of the Baath Party. For Democracy to take hold, the Iraqis must refute their most recent past before moving into the future. When faced with what Nazism truly meant, the Germans were force to renounce this evil past and this made it easier to transition to a democratic future. Soon the Iraqis will do the same.

What the Russian truly need to do is to examine this history and renounce it. To do so could strengthen their nascent democracy. About present Russia, Professor Merritt notes, "Significantly, there have been no trials, no truth and reconciliation commissions. Many of the mass graves have been unearthed, but these attract little notice in Russia and scarcely more than a paragraph in Western newspapers. Irreconcilable versions of the past contend for the current Russian soul. An astonishing number of Russians — perhaps as many as 15 or 20 percent — reject Memorial's documentation of the terror and view Stalin as a positive historical figure. Applebaum cites Russians saying that the gulag was somehow a historical necessity; that without it Russia could never have tapped the vast resources of the Far East." For us here in America, Gulag represent needed review of the past for to better understand the Cold War.

As Professor Merritt stated, "Defenders of the Soviet system have all too often played Stalin's game, excusing — or, rather, ''explaining'' — the gulag as a direct descendant of the czarist Siberian exile system. But Applebaum's numbers tell their own story: on the eve of the 1917 revolution, under the czar, only 28,600 convicts were serving sentences of hard labor, compared with the millions committed to the gulag under Lenin and Stalin. At some point numbers matter, quantity becomes quality. It is simply wrong to maintain that the gulag was nothing more than a modernized version of its czarist predecessor."

Gulag is an important part of the 20th century and we should know the history of the Soviet Union as we know the history of Nazis Germany. This past is helping to shape the present world. Understand the past; we can better manage the future.

page 1 | 2
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Gulag: A History Gulag: A History
Anne Applebaum
Book,

Gulag: A History
Published: December 21, 2004
Type:
Section: Books
Writer: Tom Donelson
Tom Donelson's BC Writer page
Tom Donelson's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Tom Donelson
All Books Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — December 21, 2004 @ 18:41PM — Eric Berlin [URL]

I'm glad that the atrocities committed under Stalin are finally getting some closer study. Unfortunately, my knowledge of the subject is mostly confined to passages in Herman Wouk's "War and Remembrance" saga.

Eric Berlin
Dumpster Bust: Miracles from Mind Trash
http://dumpsterbust.blogspot.com

#2 — December 21, 2004 @ 20:53PM — Harry Forbes [URL]

Thanks for a good review. As I recall this book did get reviews in the NYT when it came out. I have not read Applebaum's book, but have read most of Solzhenitsyn.

Personally, I can think of nothing that has colored my own world view nearly as much as reading Solzenitsyn's accounts and his analysis of the Gulag. Coming to some understanding of these events will change one's view of the world forever.

If "only" 15% of Russians have a positive view of Stalin, the percentage of people in the West with such a view is much higher, mainly due to the staunch support Stalin enjoyed in the US from academics and the left in the 1920s and 1930s.

The facts are available, thanks to some survivors and historians like Anne Applebaum. Those who remain ignorant or in denial concerning the Gulag are more culpable than those who deny the Holocaust.

#3 — December 27, 2004 @ 14:30PM — Bryce Eddings

Posted at Advance

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/23510)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments