Gulag: A History

Written by Tom Donelson
Published December 21, 2004

Anne Applebaum's Gulag deals with the human cost of the Soviet concentration camp system and the price the average Russian had to pay for the new utopia. She writes, "Even in prison-camp slang, the world outside the barbed wire was not referred to as freedom but as the big prison zone larger and less deadly than the small zone of the camp but not more human- and certainly not more humane." The history of the Gulag is the history of Stalin's Soviet and lies as an indictment of a whole ideology. Why read this book? Too many of us really do not know much about the Gulag. We have memorials to the holocaust but none for the Gulag. We simply do not understand why it matters.

From the very beginning, official information about the Soviet Camps was available for all to see but too often ignored. Anne Applebaum makes one interesting aspect of how many Western intellectuals actually were sympathetic to the goals of the Soviet System and often judged the Soviet Union not so much for results but for the stated ideals. They were perfectly willing to ignore the Gulag and the totalitarian nature of the Soviet System. As Anne Applebaum noticed, "those who wrote "favorably" about the Soviet Union won more access to archives, more access to official information, longer visas in the country... Of course, it goes without saying, of course, that no outsiders were allowed access to any material about Stalin's camp." One professor recently stated, "Many of my students have never even heard of the gulag."

Going through the book, one thing comes to mind. Soviet camp system matched their Nazis counterpart for cruelty. Yet, we do not honor the victims of the Gulag nor even truly remember them. It is as if they disappeared from the pages of history as they disappeared from the daily life of the former Soviet Union.

Ms. Applebaum is determined that these victims will not be forgotten and she puts a human face upon the history of the Gulag. We are not just given the facts as impressive as they are but we are exposed to their stories. Ms. Applebaum's book should end that nonsense that the Cold War was a mere misunderstanding. It was truly a battle of good vs. evil and Ms. Applebaum demonstrates the evil that permeated the Soviet system.

What makes Applebaum book powerful is that she did have access to Soviet materials but as she sadly notes, many in Russia and outside are not truly interested in studying the past. Professor Steve Merritt argued, "The cancer of police terror was embedded in the original DNA of Lenin's creation, ''an integral part of the Soviet system,' in Applebaum's words." Anne Applebaum told of a former prisoner's wife being imprisoned for the same crime a second time. The husband argued that, "She served her time Does the law really permit to punish a person twice for the same offense?" The prosecutor merely replied, "Of course not. But what's the law got to do with it." Soviet law was arbitrary, merely depended upon the moment.

page 1 | 2
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Gulag: A History Gulag: A History
Anne Applebaum
Book,

Gulag: A History
Published: December 21, 2004
Type:
Section: Books
Writer: Tom Donelson
Tom Donelson's BC Writer page
Tom Donelson's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Tom Donelson
All Books Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — December 21, 2004 @ 18:41PM — Eric Berlin [URL]

I'm glad that the atrocities committed under Stalin are finally getting some closer study. Unfortunately, my knowledge of the subject is mostly confined to passages in Herman Wouk's "War and Remembrance" saga.

Eric Berlin
Dumpster Bust: Miracles from Mind Trash
http://dumpsterbust.blogspot.com

#2 — December 21, 2004 @ 20:53PM — Harry Forbes [URL]

Thanks for a good review. As I recall this book did get reviews in the NYT when it came out. I have not read Applebaum's book, but have read most of Solzhenitsyn.

Personally, I can think of nothing that has colored my own world view nearly as much as reading Solzenitsyn's accounts and his analysis of the Gulag. Coming to some understanding of these events will change one's view of the world forever.

If "only" 15% of Russians have a positive view of Stalin, the percentage of people in the West with such a view is much higher, mainly due to the staunch support Stalin enjoyed in the US from academics and the left in the 1920s and 1930s.

The facts are available, thanks to some survivors and historians like Anne Applebaum. Those who remain ignorant or in denial concerning the Gulag are more culpable than those who deny the Holocaust.

#3 — December 27, 2004 @ 14:30PM — Bryce Eddings

Posted at Advance

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/23510)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments