Dumpster Bust on TV: The Apprentice II Finals

Written by Eric Berlin
Published December 17, 2004

Say what you want about reality television, but I've always been a sucker for human drama, though often grudgingly when it's overly scripted, contrived, and produced. What makes for the best and most interesting reality shows is when there is something real at stake. And I'm not talking about watching someone receive a red rose and a chance at true romance with a fetching semi-stranger.

I'm talking about shows where the players are driven, passionate, and most of all, desperately want to win. Over the last few months, the shows that most qualify are The Apprentice 2 and the Richard Branson-led The Rebel Billionaire.

The Apprentice 2, while losing a degree of its novelty and edge from the exciting first season, still managed to deliver high stakes, dramatic moments, and the necessary array of certifiable lunatics and loopy personalities to keep you tuned in every week.

The major downfall of the second season was that Donald Trump appeared to go for the surprise maneuver rather than the smart decision in the board room on several occasions. Perhaps impulsive might be the better word than surprise, but I would have to dig underneath the famous hair helmet / Andy Capp's cap to know for sure. Speaking of Andy, I felt that the young Harvard grad's ousting just before the Final Four round was the worst decision of the season. It was another example that screaming in the board room could stave off firing rather than effective leadership or performance shown during tasks. Another baffling decision was the ouster of the promising-looking Bradford early on due to his "rash" decision to waive his immunity that week in bold defense of his performance during his team's losing effort.

It was further indication, as seen in Season One, that Trump in the end does not want someone like himself (brash, extreme risk taker, gruff) but a competent yes-man who is tough and competent but will likely never bedazzle you (or outshine the strangely haired head honcho). Enter Bill Rancic and now Kelly Perdew, the Season Two winner.

Another trying part of Season Two was the upgraded role of product endorsements and forays into Donald Trump: The Commercial (as if The Apprentice didn't already advertise Donald Trump: The Brand enough) as with the addition of thinly veiled skits in which Trump "checks up" on his various properties before doling out the new task of the week.

Still, it was a fun ride and gratifying to see Kelly beat out the leadership-shirking, eavesdropper lurking Jennifer M. in tonight's finale. I'll still be on board for the kick-off of Season Three next month, where a new twist has a team of the "book smart" facing off against a team of the "street smart."

Human drama. Gotta love it.

For more on this and on every other topic under the sun, check out:

Dumpster Bust: Manufacturing Miracles from Mind Trash, Since 2003

EBb-dayEric Berlin is the Executive Producer of Blogcritics.org and publisher of Online Media Cultist. He's also prone to referring to himself in the third person in author bios in an attempt to make it look like someone Less Important wrote it for him. Contact: dumpsterbust@gmail.com
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Dumpster Bust on TV: The Apprentice II Finals
Published: December 17, 2004
Type:
Section: Video
Filed Under: Culture: Business and Economics, Books: Business, Video: Reality TV
Writer: Eric Berlin
Eric Berlin's BC Writer page
Eric Berlin's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Eric Berlin
Culture: Business and Economics
Books: Business
Video: Reality TV
All Video Articles
Eric Berlin's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — December 17, 2004 @ 08:58AM — Eric Olsen

EB, very nice review - TV goes under Video

#2 — December 17, 2004 @ 10:04AM — Eric Berlin [URL]

EO (Anyone ever call you that?),

Thanks, and please be rest assured that I'll (likely) get this right one of these days...

Cheers,
EB

#3 — December 17, 2004 @ 13:31PM — Aaman [URL]

I think the coolest bit was the O'Jays singing "For The Love Of Money" live. Overall, the audience segment was overstretched, and quite contrived.

If the first couple of episodes of Season III aren't any good - it's not going to be worth the watch.

This is so far from business reality. But we knew that anyway, didn't we?

#4 — December 17, 2004 @ 15:07PM — Eric Berlin [URL]

I agree that the finals were too long... and I felt a little insulted that we were "treated" to a 10-minute preview of The Contender (another Mark Burnett production), topped off by an interview with Sugar Ray Leonard. I think a two-hour non live final would have been fine.

I did find the final task (overseeing the NBA charity event and Polo match / Tony Bennett concert) to be interesting. There were several moments of real world business going on, too, as the clients of those events, aside from the publicity, could care less about the competition aspect of The Apprentice. A great example was when the electricity went out and the contact from X Box told a stunned looking Jennifer C.: I don't care how you solve this problem, just make it go away." That's the kind of reality that I'm looking for!

Eric Berlin
Dumpster Bust: Miracles from Mind Trash
http://dumpsterbust.blogspot.com

#5 — December 19, 2004 @ 13:40PM — Justene [URL]

This post was selected for Advance.net. You can find it on many newspaper websites such as Cleveland.com.

#6 — December 19, 2004 @ 13:40PM — Justene [URL]

This post was selected for Advance.net. You can find it on many newspaper websites such as Cleveland.com.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/23359)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments