On being objective
Published December 09, 2004
Lester Markel was the autonomous czar who ran the New York Times's Sunday sections for some 40 years, from 1924 to 1964.
He wrote:
- The reporter, the most objective reporter, collects fifty facts. Out of the fifty facts he selects twelve to include in his story. Thus he discards thirty-eight. This is Judgment Number One.
Then the reporter or editor decides which of the facts shall be the first paragraph of the story, thus emphasizing one fact above the other eleven. This is Judgment Number Two.
Then the editor decides whether the story shall be placed on Page One or Page Twelve; on Page One it will command many times the attention it would on Page Twelve. This is Judgment Number Three.
This so-called factual presentation is thus subjected to three judgments, all of them most humanly and most ungodly made.
To all who believe that they are "objective" I say, you are fooling yourself.
Moreover, in your attempts to eliminate emotion and subjectivity from your decisions, you are apt to wreak havoc both upon yourself and those who suffer the consequences of your so-called good judgment.
Be human and be real.
You'll be far better off in the end.
[via Daniel Okrent and the New York Times]
- On being objective
- Published: December 09, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Culture
- Writer: bookofjoe
- bookofjoe's BC Writer page
- bookofjoe's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
I think the whole power of being objective is missed. Objectivity focuses on that things are a certain way. It looks at accepting things in life you cannot change and changing the things you can. Emotions are good but they must follow the objectivity. One probably cannot be totally objective but it helps to stay focused on being a productive person. Colonel Sanders kept trying after being rejected and today we have KFC. What if he had said nobody wants my chicken recipe instead believing someone out there would buy it? He would not have been the rich man from his recipe.




"Descartes Error" by Antonio R. Damasio-
You can't be objective without being subjective, and vice versa. Ayn Rand is beating at the lid of her coffin...